I'd go New Guardians solidly. You'd have Hal operating at double-power, Atrocius Sinestro and Carol as big guns too, and even current Lafleeze is pretty strong.
It's 7 on 5 with the 'weakest' of the 7 being able to double the power of a comrade. They win whatever Lafleeze's state.
guardian..Hal ring will never runs out of energy and become more powerful..and with him around..saint walker become very powerful too..probably the most powerful among the guardian..
I see the biggest problem Team 2 could throw at the AT is that you have 4 highly powerful energy based absorbers and manipulators on the team in Quasar, Beta Ray Bill, Surfer, and Ronan.
That could, could prove troublesome for the New Guardians.
I'd give them the edge if they weren't outnumbered thanks to energy absorbing. Without energy absorbing and equal numbers NG still take it -depending in the rooster though-.
WTF does Carol, St Walker, or Indigo adding to this fight in terms of taking anybody out? Ronan, Super Skrull, and Nova can at least stalemate them or beat them.
Then it's between Larfleeze, Sinestro, amped Hal, and Atrocitus against Surfer, Quasar, Beta Ray Bill, and Gladiator. Larfleeze clowns around too much that he could end up as a liability to his team. The Guardians should edge out them out due to Hal getting that boost from Walker. Without that boost, I could see the Annihilators taking this.
carol can be a threat. she did subdue kryb who took a beating from the glc and was smiling at the same time. hal with the boost will also be hard to beat.
larfleeze would probably want surfers board and will stop at nothing to get it. lol.
I didn't realize those 2 were added. Btw Super Skrull was never on any team with those guys. "Galaxy's Mightiest Heroes" during Thanos Imperative had those guys in the pic + Nova Prime. Anyways, with those 2 added Annhihilators win.