I hope not. As much as i love Sirius, im not one of those fans who likes all the people who die to come back to life. I think it takes away from Sirius dieing to save Harry.
__________________
The only thing thats with you your whole life is complete and utter darkness.
well same here if sirius comes back to life then it leaves too many questions like why not harry's parents?and how did he why did he too many loop holes!!
Well he was a pretty important character really. I think the way he died didn't really work, besides he probably aint dead. He just aint in the real world, he fell through the veil, he wasnt killed so technically he aint dead so he could posibly come back.
If dumbledore does die in HBP that leaves Harry with nobody who is close to him.
Yes I believe we will see him again...whether it is that he lived, somehow, or whether he comes back in spirit like the hogwarts ghosts. I do not believe he is simply just gone.
I think he could get back to life, afterall he is not like dead-dead, he's just lost behind that veil...
i've read a pretty good fanfiction about it once...
Gender: Male Location: Past the Point of No Return
Who says he isn't dead. What if there was something behind the viel that kills him? We can't say if he is dead or not without knowing whats behind that veil!
i think that something will happen with mirrors. mirrors have sidely important throughout the series... the mirror in book one and the mirror sirius gave harry. one he saw his parents and one was to contact sirius...and the foe glass. i think it will all be conneced to harry seeing sirius again. just a theory though. and i dont think dumble dore dies...i think its ron
Gender: Female Location: in a double decker bus...
I don't think Sirius is going to come back to life, as JK has alreasdy said he is really dead, but I definitely think we will see him again. I think nearly everyone already knows my theory, but here it is again for anyone who missed it!
Phoe's Crazy Theory: Sirius comes back in a painting, there must be one of him somewhere...
hey the painting theory seems possible.. but the mirror theory im not so sure.. i mean it sounds like it will lead up to something (unless we're reading too much into it), but not to sirius..
i think that the only way well ever see sirius again is in flash backs..
I like your 'crazy theory' Phoe!!! that's kind of what i'm thinking, along with the mirror or erised, and flashbacks and memories, and the penesieve (which effectively is memories)
however, i don't think sirius is going to come back alive - JKR wouldn't have killed him if she's have wanted him alive surely?? and quite besides that Nick says he's dead and won't come back as a ghost and so does JKR.
__________________ "Shame about the French, really. Obsessed with raisins. Humiliated grapes, really. Think about it."
- Captain Jack Sparrow
KMC Community Forums
Jun 12th, 2005 09:19 PM
miss that bugger
