Yerrsot you're wrong. At the start of TPM it's Sidious who tells the TF to kill the Jedi. He knows exactly where they are. Why didn't he kill them himself?
Registered: Sep 2000
Location: Chelmsford, Essex, UK
Co-Admin
I really don't think yerssot is worried about the logic of the situation. The whole idea is so patently absurd, after all...
yerssot, based on the idea that such powerful use of the Force would be VERY useful and there are all sorts of situations where Jedi in the films WOULD have done if they COULD (and may I remind you that if you can use the Force to remotely kill you should be able to use the Force to remotely SENSE as well, meaning you could find them to koll them anyway in your theory), can you explain why this hasn't been done?
This thread is still on deathwatch, by the way.
__________________
"We've got maybe seconds before Darth Rosenberg grinds everybody into Jawa burgers and not one of you buds has the midi-chlorians to stop her!"
But not yet burried.
Kj you're right about that, but he only knew they were on the ship not were they were exactly.
The ability the choke someone that is far away and the ability to sense someone aren't connected.
Knowing one is on a certain planet isn't enough, you need to know where he is exactly, I'm talking here with a distance of 1 metre or less, not 1 kilometre.
Ush;there were some examples already in this thread and I gave an answer that no-one disagreed with, I mean the explanation was in the lines that I gave
Registered: Sep 2000
Location: Chelmsford, Essex, UK
Co-Admin
I see no credible examples, yerssor, Make them again if you must.
And if you can kill remotely why not accurately sense remotely as well? As you point out, the Force is EVERYWHERE. It should be able toi give exact location., AFter all, Vader has no eyes, he senses only with the FOrce. He never sees his targets.
No, your theoty is nonsense Force manipulation is a local phenomenon. If you want an excuse, perhaps it just can't hear you unless you are close.
__________________
"We've got maybe seconds before Darth Rosenberg grinds everybody into Jawa burgers and not one of you buds has the midi-chlorians to stop her!"
Vader can see! If you look in ROTJ, you see his eyes aren't burnt or anything.
For the other point, it is quite easily to explain that, why did Vader had to follow Leia in ANH? He didn't know where the rebels were. So even if the Force is everywhere, you don't know where everybody is. That's the reason why they don't do it in every 5 seconds.
There were 2 chokes till now. One time Motti, Vader was 5 cm away from him, and another officer were Vader had visual contact so he saw where the other was
"Let me see you with my OWN eyes' to Luke. He had never actually SEEN his son!
I thought that was when his mask was still one, with Luke than replying: But you'll die and Vader: Nothing can prevent that, and than Luke takes of the mask.
I don't know how you say it in English, but is it tinted? You know, a car with black windows but the guy inside the car can still see outside.
What do you mean with your eyes can decieve you ... ?
I know the quote comes from Obi, I wanted to know what you used it for.
He was at that point redeeming himself, taking away the mask was the final step, with death as a result, taking away the mask speeded it up.
How do you mean grease? The definition of that word that I know is oil, was there oil in his mask??
So, again you're saying that it's impossible to choke someone from the other side of the Galaxy because you need to know exactly where they are?
Ush I don't know where you got the idea that Anakin is blind from but it's not right. When he takes off the mask he can clearly see. So why would he not be able to see through the mask?
Sep 3rd, 2001 11:34 AM
