Wolverine vs. Spider-Man

Started by Melnorme1,019 pages

Originally posted by jinzin
in a word... yes..

cause you know.. that's what he did...

Absurd.

I know the webbing was dissolving. Otherwise Wolverine would have escaped in the first panel, rather than wait until the end of the issue.

Originally posted by wolverine8888
are u ****ing seorus so wolverine went under ground of his own willing ness?

It's not clear that he was underground. It's likely that, given the energy of the impact, he was merely covered with a layer of topsoil kicked up by the force of the Hulk's blow.

Originally posted by Melnorme
We don't see the blow connect, and given the status of Wolverine's face and body in the following panel, we can only conclude that Wolverine avoided that blow.

go read hulk #340, go read HULK vs WOLVERINE #8
go read death wolverine vs hulk, go readwolverine vs hulk 6 hours

Originally posted by wolverine8888
go read hulk #340, go read HULK vs WOLVERINE #8
go read death wolverine vs hulk, go readwolverine vs hulk 6 hours

If you can't form a proper defense on your own, I don't see how all this reading on my part will help you.

looky this is the storngest forum of wendigo who base line is far more powerful then hulk base line

Originally posted by Melnorme
If you can't form a proper defense on your own, I don't see how all this reading on my part will help you.

it called evidence. every one of those comics has wolverine getting punch full force from hulk and getting bakc up

Originally posted by wolverine8888
looky this is the storngest forum of wendigo who base line is far more powerful then hulk base line

What issue is that?

wolveirne 172 ya I got the pic from mangi

Originally posted by Melnorme
What issue is that?

Wolverine #170-172, that's Mauvais Wendigo.

It's from my ALpha Flight Respect Thread [pg.9]

Originally posted by Melnorme
Are you claiming that Secret Wars was badly written?[/B]
I'm claiming that there was a lot of PIS produced through one instance os secret wars.. I thought that was clear.... 😕

Originally posted by Melnorme
Either that, or Spidey was too much for them. [/B]

either way? so whether it was PIS or not right? right, well in that case, wolverine beats spiderman, just like he's been consistently doing for years..... with your standard of debate PIS is a non-factor at this point?

Originally posted by Melnorme
He got Professor X first, who by the way isn't omniscient. Cyke couldn't keep up with his obviously superior speed and tactical positioning. Rogue's abilities didn't help her, Colossus got webbed in the face. Wolverine got slapped around like the peak human he is. Kurt was just so friggin surprised at what happened, and let's face it, even if he acted it wouldn't have made much of a difference. [/B]

you're not telling me anything I don't already know.. the fact is all of that is shrouded in PIS. and yes kurts doing something would have definitely made a difference.. hell kurts put up a pretty good tustle with spiderman BY HIMSELF...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Anyway, the fact is that Secret Wars is as canon as it gets. Good luck arguing against that. 😛[/B]
I'm not really arguing against it.. it's well known around here that I don't think calling something PIS negates the fact that it happened... I'm just pointing this out as a retaliation to all the PIS claims that are brought up against wolverine...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Well, when you find your crayons, you look me up, lil' trooper.[/B]
doh

Originally posted by Melnorme
Anyways, Spidey wasn't knocked back 20 feet. He backflipped away. Plain as day. 😄[/B]
I'm talking about the roftop fight...
🤨

Originally posted by Melnorme
If you can't rebut the argument, except with this lame false dilemma, then you concede the point. Thank you.[/B]

actually I did rebut it, I just didn't do it directly.. guess you missed it...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Ah yes. More ad hominem. [/B]
no I'm pointing out that you need to catch up... which you do.. I'm not saying your points are irrelivent because we've already gone over them just redundant.. and they are...

Originally posted by Melnorme
And what's this? In one paragraph backpeddling to state that no one claimed that there would be no walls, and in the next restating that you called into question that there might not be any walls? 🤨

Well done. 😂[/B]


because making a claim and bringing something into question are completely different things.. let's work on trains of thought shall we?

hulk can't lift that mountain calm.
hulk might not be able to lift that mountain calm, who knows

Originally posted by Melnorme
That's been the point from the get go. Surely you aren't claiming that I was seriously arguing that there would be no floor, and somehow the combatants would be fighting in a surfaceless void? Because you would have to be in order for your current claim to be correct.[/B]

false dichotomy..

please don't tell me I have to find you a definition for "mocking" doh

Originally posted by Melnorme
Wolverine is still slower than Spider-Man. Everyone who reads comics knows this, unless they're being disingenuine..[/B]
which I wholly agree to.. I just think that the difference in their speed is so slim it won't matter much, especially if the fight lasts for any significant duration...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Out of how many attempts? Hundreds? Thousands? Statistically speaking, those aren't good odds.[/B]

in terms of direct comparison.. wolverine's secured his hands on spiderman 4 out of 5 times..statistically speaking those are great odds..

Originally posted by Melnorme
You apparently don't even understand what a straw man is. It's quite amusing to watch you try, though. Go Google it, and do us all a favor. :lol[/B]
appaerently you don't if you think your rammbling was on point.

Originally posted by Melnorme
Now you're coping out. A knockout occurs for the same reasons in a comic as it does in real life. If it didn't, there would be no point in debating this, because we'd be talking about properties that defy explanation. [/B]

When someone argues that they have seen evidence of something but that the evidence doesn't count because that character "shouldn't be able to do that" they need to re-think the premise of thier conclusion. A characters abilities are based on what he or she demonstrates he or she can do, not on what someone thought they could do at one time. if spidey's never been able to knock him out well...

Originally posted by Melnorme
Absurd.

I know the webbing was dissolving. Otherwise Wolverine would have escaped in the first panel, rather than wait until the end of the issue.

no, he didn't want to hurt himself to get out until he knew he didn't have a choice...

Originally posted by Melnorme
We don't see the blow connect, and given the status of Wolverine's face and body in the following panel, we can only conclude that Wolverine avoided that blow.

😂

Originally posted by Melnorme
Backpedal much?

go ahead, whatever it takes for you to find me saying he's as strong as hulk or even comparible... 😉

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Wolverine #170-172, that's Mauvais Wendigo.

It's from my ALpha Flight Respect Thread [pg.9]


by the way thanks for the pic

Originally posted by wolverine8888
by the way thanks for the pic

No worries, if I get time later this week [I'm in exams] I can post the scans of Wolverine taking on Mauvais and Wendigo at the same time, before Mauvais eats Wendigo's heart.

Originally posted by jinzin
😂

go ahead, whatever it takes for you to find me saying he's as strong as hulk or even comparible... 😉


wendgo is comparable hell that wendigo pic I got form mangi is base lined strength of a good deal higher then that of hulks if I am not mistaken.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
No worries, if I get time later this week [I'm in exams] I can post the scans of Wolverine taking on Mauvais and Wendigo at the same time, before Mauvais eats Wendigo's heart.

thanks man

Originally posted by wolverine8888
wendgo is comparable hell that wendigo pic I got form mangi is base lined strength of a good deal higher then that of hulks if I am not mistaken.

We don't know his full strength, but he was indeed physically stronger than the previous Wendigo Wolverine was battling minutes before. Plus he also has mystical powers that were heightened in Wendigo form. He could even amp his strength up by bitting into flesh [does this right before he gets sucked into the portel]

normal wendigo is over 100 tons but base line of 100 tons so this one a good deal stronger

Originally posted by King_Mungi
We don't know his full strength, but he was indeed physically stronger than the previous Wendigo Wolverine was battling minutes before. Plus he also has mystical powers that were heightened in Wendigo form. He could even amp his strength up by bitting into flesh [does this right before he gets sucked into the portel]

Which doesn't prove conclusively that he's in the same category as the Hulk.

Which also doesn't mean conclusively that a heavy hitter can't knock out Wolverine, but we all knew that already. 😉

um dude wendigo is base line character of 100 tons. this wendigo is far stronger and more powerful then any other wendigo.
also wolverine did beat hercules befor.