The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by airangel429191 pages

Ok.....Harry and Luna did have that whole mistletoe thing...but Harry pretty well much dismissed it, b/c then he wasn't thinking of her like that and I think Luna...being dreamy...was kinda being funny/flirty/loony b/c that is her character. You could be under mistletoe with a good guy friend and give him a kiss on the cheek...its just the thing to do. With her so dreamily all the time, of course she would be into something like that.

As for Luna, it was PRETTY obvious for her wanting to be near Ron from the VERY beginning when we were introduced to her character. Other than reading hte quibbler upside down the 1st thing she wanted to do was to help Ron with his things off the train. She didn't ask Harry...She asked Ron. AND if she wanted to be closer to HArry then she would have accepted his offer to help her find her things at the end of book 5. She said no, they always come up somehow. Now i do admit that i had thought about the fact that she could be a possibility for Harry...he did change towards her, but Harry is also goign to look at his friends, Hermy, Ron and Ginny (yes she is still a friend). Hermy of course doesn't like her and she is one of Harry's closest friends aside of Ron. NEville is scared of her........so you see...he doesn't really have the support from his friends. The reason he felt better at the end of book 5 from talking to her about the Veil is b/c he so DESPERATELY wants to contact Sirius again and YES she is a person who can help him and he will admire her for this....but I dont see her liking him in that way. AND I think if for some reason all of this shows in book 6 then there will be more ginny too. Ron is goign to oppose luna, b/c he wants Harry with Ginny. Hermy doesn't like her, b/c they are too different and there was that whole library scene that when Harry was in that --im pissed off at everyone who isn't going through what i am-- mood...well Ginny was there and she calmed him down AND she did give him the Snitch on Easter. I don't remember Luna giving him anything, except for an interview from Rita that went into the Quibbler. Which was a HUGE thing for Harry.......but Luna and Harry have no past. Harry can talk to her about death b/c her mother had died. He needed to talk to someone who had been through what he had been, so it wouldn't seem like everyone else, who is always trying to prod. I do think Luna and Harry will become very good friends, but I do think JKR will kill her off.

I think with Voldemort growing fonder of how Harry thinks and feels he will catch on to someone close to him. Yes Luna is this person FOR NOW, b/c she can help him contact Sirius and I think that Voldemort might try to take her to hurt Harry. This is why I think her character will die off. I mean we heard about Diggory's parents and stuff and he still died off....I say that b/c we hear about Luna's dad who works for the Quibbler. I do think that Luna will give him LOADS of info.....but he's not going to be interested in her......he's goign to be interested in how to find Sirius. AND remember....Luna found out about Sirius from Ginny!!!

its all getting very exciting i just cant wait for book 6

keep your comments coming people

I can't wait either...i think a LITTLE chemistry will build with H/L but that it will fizzle out with her death...I dont think harry will FALL "IN LOVE" with her...but maybe her last name is LOVEGOOD....but she wont be the girl to stay with him in the end...

GINNY ALL THE WAY! 🙂 😍

in order to see one side of the whole relationship possibilities...you must be able to see what the other side is focusing on..... the H/L shippers out there.......

keep your comments coming people

It isn't about winning, I just want to make some other ships a little more open minded! 😄

Their siding with us cause well. I dunno why.... but I think it's cause they go to FAP and I debate there A LOT!

Couples

hu should end up wit hu? i dont care wat other ppl say but:

Harry/Cho
Ron/Hermione
Malfoy/Pansy

o ya and
neville/ginny
peace

keep your comments coming people

I think Harry/Ginny, Ron/Hermione, Neville/Luna, and Draco/Pansy. For the reasons why I support Harry/Ginny you can check the Couples thread! 😄

I agree plus Snape/Tonks...you'll see later..i am hoping.

I see Snape/Tonks for some reason.. Saw it as soon as I finished Snape's Worst Memory.....

Ginny/Neville
Herm/Ron
Luna/Harry

((If you don't care what others think why did you start this Hummmm))

...... I really don't think there is anything to sayy... no one ever debates what I say so I can't go back and re-re debate it... Lemme see though...

Just because their is a whole chapter dedicated to this character and just because it is named Luna Lovegood, that means nothing! There wasn't a chapter called, Ron Weasley or Hermione Granger or Sirius Black, and these turned out to be very important characters to the story. There wasn't even a chapter called Harry Potter, it was called, The-Boy-Who-Lived, and Harry is the main character!!! Though I believe that Luna will be important to the plot, I believe she will be important for a different reason!O_O

Also, Harry shows NO feelings of affection towards Luna WHAT-SO-EVER! At least in literary clues and hints Harry shows affection for Ginny and always notices her and describes her wonderfully! What is he just going to sprout affection on Luna over the summer, HE HAS NO FEELINGS OTHER THEN A FRIENDSHIP TOWARDS HER!!! At least for Ginny it has been there! But he is just a little slow on the intake!😂 Now, I will shut up and wait for the debate to put out my all! 😄

Its over

Erm- I am not going to post (re-post) everything I said here. There is a wonderful site deticated to the whole Harry Potter thing... I will still post tidbits here... but this place isn't very active.....

Not one person has even asked me why I concider Harry a Slytherin Man....

Fiction Alley Park

Yes good question Lukia and there is about fifty of these threads!

Just because their is a whole chapter dedicated to this character and just because it is named Luna Lovegood, that means nothing! There wasn't a chapter called, Ron Weasley or Hermione Granger or Sirius Black, and these turned out to be very important characters to the story. There wasn't even a chapter called Harry Potter, it was called, The-Boy-Who-Lived, and Harry is the main character!!! Though I believe that Luna will be important to the plot, I believe she will be important for a different reason!O_O

Also, Harry shows NO feelings of affection towards Luna WHAT-SO-EVER! At least in literary clues and hints Harry shows affection for Ginny and always notices her and describes her wonderfully! What is he just going to sprout affection on Luna over the summer, HE HAS NO FEELINGS OTHER THEN A FRIENDSHIP TOWARDS HER!!! At least for Ginny it has been there! But he is just a little slow on the intake! Now, I will shut up and wait for the debate to put out my all!

Yelling at me?! Oh yeah, this is OVER! I am Soo out of here. I get no facts, no one re-debates what I say....

Ok.....Harry and Luna did have that whole mistletoe thing...but Harry pretty well much dismissed it, b/c then he wasn't thinking of her like that and I think Luna...being dreamy...was kinda being funny/flirty/loony b/c that is her character. You could be under mistletoe with a good guy friend and give him a kiss on the cheek...its just the thing to do. With her so dreamily all the time, of course she would be into something like that.

That was before the end people! Before he knew they had so much in common.

Okay so you are banking your whole debate on If and only IF J.K. decides to kill of Luna. And what if Ginny dies? You all have to think realistically too.. Ginny has a fiery temper.. we know this…

Harry is changing. He is no longer the quite person, he will blow up at you for now reason. Now Ginny would either a) Yell back at him. B) try to let him see it is pointless which will result in 1) another argument

Luna in contrast would most likely stare at Harry with a blank look and after he was done say something Loony which would totally throw him off guard.

People may not want to hear this but Harry Potter is a very unstable person, very Unstable with his emotions, thoughts, actions and is rash and reckless, which most Gryffindor’s including Ginny are.

Harry needs someone who will contrast. Luna thinks, she is in Ravenclaw for goodness sakes she doesn’t rush into things. She would use her mind, and is always calm. Even when Umbrigde captured her she was calm, thinking sort of, taking in the situation, and not relaying on animalistic instincts like Ginny.

When I find the quotes I will post them here… But moving on!

Also for those of you who are saying how Ginny will 'come to the rescue' isn't that kinda low? Taking advantage of Harry's feelings after the girl he was crushing on died cause o him? Very chivalrous. That is wrong, you don’t comfort a person because you like them, you comfort them cause you want them to feel better.

I never really liked Ginny. She was at the bottom of my list before OotP now she is 3rd from my list, but if she is written, like you all want her to be written, She goes to the very bottom, below Kreacher, Crouch, and the Giant Squid.

GOOD BYE! I have been Driven away by yellers.... and people who can't debate properly.

😍 hermione and ron will end up together .......they're cute, 😍 they "argue".....flirty like and all.....and harry.....idk.....i sorta think luna and ginny are a lil too young for him (even though i love both characters) im hopin 😄 that maybe a new female character will be introduced into the story in the next book(s) that will balance and compliment harry's character 😎 .......like lily and james!!!!!! 😍

ps.....um....harry's a gryffindor....not a slytherin ❌ ....even dumbledore says in the second book that only a TRUE gryffindor could pull out that sword 😖mart:.....sorry to burst ur bubble...

hehe a bunny!!!! ~> 🐰

I am one who likes to look at both sides of this issue.

Since the introduction of Ginny in the first book I have been a Harry/Ginny shipper for the basic reason of it's a typical pairing. Harry and Ron are bestfriends and Ron has Ginny for a little sister, so Harry and Ginny would get married hense making Ron and Harry brothers.

BUT! I have never liked the idea of the two dating during school. The reason was because Ginny's character was never developed enough for Harry to have a good enough reason to be interested in her.

I am a supporter of them dating during seventh or after Hogwarts.

Now for the other side.

I AM a supporter of Harry/Luna. It is a pairing that may, no will, occur during school years. The main reason for this was because Rowling in an interview stated that a love interest would be introduced in the fifth book. Luna, of course, is the obvious choice.

Whether or not this relationship continues, I'm not too sure about. After all, teenagers are fickle people.

My two knuts.

~Marna~