The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by Draco69191 pages
Originally posted by dark1365
[B
Yes, it is more "realisitic", therefore it is more likely to happen than R/H. And since you said it's "never" going to happen, R/H is sure as hell never going to happen either. [/B]

Honey. It's a children's book with dragons, dark wizards, griffins and a teenager who somehow manages to win every battle through sheer luck.
There's nothing realistic about Harry Potter. Please. 😆

Originally posted by dark1365
What? How is it more realistic? If you consider "realistic" to be defined as fighting often and reluctantly backing down, then yes it is realistic.

You've been reinforcing the concept of "opposites attract" for a long time now. Well, face it: They don't ALWAYS attract.. It's like being asked whether you'd be with your soul mate or you would rather be with someone who's your exact opposite. Of course you'd pick your soul mate.
Yes, it is more "realisitic", therefore it is more likely to happen than R/H. And since you said it's "never" going to happen, R/H is sure as hell never going to happen either.

First off. I only mentioned the opposites attract thing twice, counting my last post. And sometimes, your soulmate is your opposite! And I really don't see how H/Hr would be more realistic. Harry isn't even realistic-like, himself. Ron's a lot more of a believable character.

Originally posted by Draco69
Honey. It's a children's book with dragons, dark wizards, griffins and a teenager who somehow manages to win every battle through sheer luck.
There's nothing realistic about Harry Potter. Please. 😆

I meant in what you said about the H/Hr relationship.

Originally posted by dark1365
I meant in what you said about the H/Hr relationship.

No. What you said was: "it is more "realisitic", therefore it is more likely to happen than R/H"

love this quotes of Jkr

"I want to finish these seven books and look back and think that whatever happened -- however much this hurricane whirled around me -- I stayed true to what I wanted to write. This is my Holy Grail: that when I finish writing book seven, I can say -- hand on heart -- I didn't change a thing. I wrote the story I meant to write. If I lost readers along the way, so be it, but I still told my story. The one I wanted. Without permitting it to sound too corny, that's what I owe to my characters. That we won't be deflected, either by adoration or by criticism."

Has your original plan for the seven books changed along the way?

JKR: It has changed, but only in details. In all important respects, it has stayed the same, and the ending will be exactly what I planned before 1997. The story has taken little twists and turns that I maybe didn’t expect, but we are still on track. Each book has broadly done what it was supposed to do in taking you towards the final conclusion.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

twist and turns , hurricane , i really think it meant for rhr and h/g. she does that so that the readers will assume its not hhr in the end but it is, come on guys its a seven books series. read the essay again

As usual, excellent points Hermione7. I'm with you all the way, can't wait to see what else we find out in HBP, and how much she will trick us as well!

(quick check as to whether this is the correct board to post this on!_ OK it is well i don't no whether i should or if this has been posted before...so many pages! but info about the whole Harry, Hermoine, Ron triangle which may burst a few bubbles! (sorry!)
From a web page i found
On whether Harry and his friend Hermione will have a date when they get older: "No, but I won't answer for anyone else - nudge, nudge, wink, wink." Quote of JKRowling when interviewed by Davies, Frank: Sunday Gazette-Mail (Charleston, SC), 14 November 1999

website http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/1199-gazettemail-davies.html

🙂

You are missinterpreting that quote. The question was not about when they got older, but about whether they would date in GOF, which they didn't.

H and D all the way 'grins' getting tense in here needed to break the tension peeps 'winks'

Originally posted by air
(quick check as to whether this is the correct board to post this on!_ OK it is well i don't no whether i should or if this has been posted before...so many pages! but info about the whole Harry, Hermoine, Ron triangle which may burst a few bubbles! (sorry!)
From a web page i found
On whether Harry and his friend Hermione will have a date when they get older: "No, but I won't answer for anyone else - nudge, nudge, wink, wink." Quote of JKRowling when interviewed by Davies, Frank: Sunday Gazette-Mail (Charleston, SC), 14 November 1999

website http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/1999/1199-gazettemail-davies.html

🙂

Yeah, that quote is about harry and hermione going on a date in goblet of fire, which they didn't. I think the nudge, nugde, wink, wink thing is about harry liking cho, and hermione and victor being an item. That just applies to Gof, not future books. 😮)

Yeeah KKdave totally 😉
I soooooo can't wait until the movie!! See how they make Rupert act around Emma...try to pretend to have a crush on her! OH I cant wait!

Me neither. It'll be great to watch. I always wanted to see Rupert act angry.

Yeah the movie should be great, I wish it were coming out sooner! Novermber seems so far away.

Oh I thought it was coming January.

JKR herself said there will be a Harry/Hermione relationship.

where? i never recall ever hearing this, in fact i only remember reading the reverse, that harry and hermione are simply platonic frieds but something just might happen between ron and hermione. but plz if my information is incorrect, then could i please see where jkr stated a h&h relationship

can remember the sites, but there were like 6 where she told someone that it will be H&H, though i also heard rumors of a R&H relationship

if u go into muggle net it will give u links to jkr interview transcripts including http://www.npr.org/programs/npc/1999/991020.jkrowling.html that link which will take u to a live web cast from a few yrs ago in which u can actually hear jk say the following concerning a H&H romance: "Harry and Hermione are very platonic friends. But I won't answer for anyone else. Nudge, nudge, wink, wink."
i don't think things could get any clearer than that and i doubt there is anymore possible proof that could refer ppl to believe there will be a harry/hermione relationship, so truly, unless jk retracts the statement herself, then she has disproved a harry & hermione relationship

that disproves h&h, and i have actual proof from another chat that could possibly signify a ron & hermione relationship from a barnes&noble jk chat: http://www.geocities.com/aberforths_goat/October_2000_Live_Chat_Barnes_Noble.htm
:Q: Is it just me, or was something going on between Ron and Hermione during the last half of Goblet of Fire?
A: "Yes, something's "going on," but Ron doesn't realize it yet. Typical boy."
there has never been a time when jk enforced a h&h relationship to such an extent, at least not to my knowledge, however if i am incorrect then please supply the link so as to disprove me

😮‍💨

analysis