The Official Shipping Debate Thread [merged]

Started by pumpkinpie4ever191 pages

yeah i found it to be funny. dark im going to put you and hermione on my buddie list for being h/hr shippers and being really nice to other ppl you dont agree with thanx for not being mean like some ppl i know. anyway as usual good essay and keep up the good work

tnx guys for the compliments.

well nightcrawler, sorry if u didnt like the ginny thing but well its my nature to dodge some things 2 prove any hhr point hehehe 😄

Oh well. No harm done. I probably would have done the same. ^.^

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I just find it kind of a waste of time to put Ginny when it is Hermione. But heck, can't do nothin' to change that.

Leave it alone, it was quite imaginative. Albeit totally wrong.

O.O TheSun. I said no harm done. I let it alone......

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
O.O TheSun. I said no harm done. I let it alone......

I'm ever so glad.

I've just found something that will make H/Hr Shippers want to kill me...

On this page, scroll down to a long list of chats and click on 'Press Club' and under the question 'What happened to Harry's grandparents?', you will find this quote...

"do Harry and Hermione have a date? [laughter] No. They are - they're very platonic friends. But I won't answer for anyone else, nudge, nudge, wink, wink."

erm who said that plz dont tell....wait a minute jkr would never ever say something from the book out loud to everyone!!!! i know so jkr is very secretive she would never tell anyone about whats in her new book.... not even her close friend sean....heres a quote:Will Ron and Hermione ever get together?

A:Well—[Laughter.] What do you think? [Audience member: I think they will]. I’m not going to say. I can’t say, can I? I think that, by now, I’ve given quite a lot of clues on the subject. That is all I’m going to say. You will have to read between the lines on that one.

which has been pumpkin pies motto for years now....

Originally posted by Phoenix
"do Harry and Hermione have a date? [laughter] No. They are - they're very platonic friends. But I won't answer for anyone else, nudge, nudge, wink, wink."

This is an old quote, from i think either when POA or GOF was coming out. In those books, yes, they were very platonic and didn't go on a date, so that quote is correct for those books. That quots isn't about the future, just about the book she was promoting, which im pretty sure was GOF. I think the "wink wink" part is about harry liking cho and hermione "dating" krum in GOF.

Originally posted by TheSun
Well surely, as readers, you are not experiencing the true purposes of Harry Potter, if you are simply being extroadinarily shallow and looking to see who hooks up with who? If you want that go and watch some of those inane American soap/drama things.

Do not think that we are ignoring the rest of the elements of Harry Potter that make it so interesting. We chose it in the first place because of its creativity and the magic that Potter fans have come to love so well.

Romance, however, is a part of the plot in the series that add interest. In this case, a lot of interest. Which is why we are pledged to it.

I still see Hermoine more as a motherly figure to Harry. Isn't she like Lily kinda? For Harry it might be like going out with his mom? 😑

nnnoooo... i really don't see it that way. Yes she looks after him and tries to take care of him, but I see that as one of the strengths of their relationship and part of why it would be so good if they got together. She's the only girl that appears to truly care about harry's mental and physical well being. I think Mrs. Weesly is more of the mother figure for Harry, for obvious reasons.

I will admit, it is most likely Harry will end up with Hermione in the books, but I'm still going for Harry and Ginny, though it is less likely.

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I still see Hermoine more as a motherly figure to Harry. Isn't she like Lily kinda? For Harry it might be like going out with his mom? 😑

What? 🤨

Exactly.

Originally posted by pumpkinpie4ever
erm who said that plz dont tell....wait a minute jkr would never ever say something from the book out loud to everyone!!!! i know so jkr is very secretive she would never tell anyone about whats in her new book.... not even her close friend sean....heres a quote:Will Ron and Hermione ever get together?

A:Well—[Laughter.] What do you think? [Audience member: I think they will]. I’m not going to say. I can’t say, can I? I think that, by now, I’ve given quite a lot of clues on the subject. That is all I’m going to say. You will have to read between the lines on that one.

which has been pumpkin pies motto for years now....


The quote above and this quote from JKR herself surely confirm that Hermione and Ron are destined for togetherness? JKR does give big hints regarding shipping, such as the one I posted fromt he Edinburgh Book Festival, because she believes that it's obvious anyway, and not a pivotal point of the plot.

Okay, now here is my pitch on why Harry and Hermione shouldn't be together. In another thread that I had just recently started about the connections between Harry Potter and the Gang and James and his gang, Harry connected to James as Hermione is connected to Lupin. Now, if you haven't noticed, Lupin and James never hooked up, but if I find a way to link Lily with anyone else, I could figure out who Harry will be with.

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
Okay, now here is my pitch on why Harry and Hermione shouldn't be together. In another thread that I had just recently started about the connections between Harry Potter and the Gang and James and his gang, Harry connected to James as Hermione is connected to Lupin. Now, if you haven't noticed, Lupin and James never hooked up, but if I find a way to link Lily with anyone else, I could figure out who Harry will be with.

Well I would expect James not to go with Lupin, since he's not gay.

There are similarities between the two "gangs", but only characteristic. James and Lily pretty much were a very unlikely pair at OWLs, but as Lupin said: "He deflated his head a bit in the seventh year."

Originally posted by TheSun
The quote above and this quote from JKR herself surely confirm that Hermione and Ron are destined for togetherness? JKR does give big hints regarding shipping, such as the one I posted fromt he Edinburgh Book Festival, because she believes that it's obvious anyway, and not a pivotal point of the plot.

As KKD said.....
This is an old quote, from either when POA or GOF was coming out. In those books, yes, they were very platonic and didn't go on a date, so that quote is correct for those books. That quotes isn't about the future, just about the book she was promoting, which im pretty sure was GOF. The "wink wink" part is about harry liking cho and hermione "dating" krum in GOF.

Yep, I second that Dark! I've heard the quote about harry and hermione being platonic friends millions of times (it's what other ships use as their main evidence) and it does nothing to sway my opinion. Plus I find it really hard to get any kind of concerte evidence from anything JKR ever says, since she's so clever about not giving ANYTHING away. I wish she did though 🙁

I don't think anything anyone says will change anyones opinion. We are just going to keep going in circles till the sixth book comes out and we find out who with who.