Sirius will seriously, definitely be BACK!

I don't think JKR would kill a character off (esp Sirius) and make Harry go through all that w/luna and Nick to just have him come back again. It would be like twisting the plot to make it a happy ending. i think Harry might talk to Sirius through the veil in 6 or 7 and realize that he has to let go. It just doesn't seem like JKR to negate death though.

hey guys....random slighty off the topic harry potter question....so, you know in book five, when harry can see the thestrals...why couldn't he see them b/f? I mean, he saw his mom die right after he was born....but yet he couldn't see them until he saw Cedric die......

well i dont know, there are theories that he wasnt old enough to register seeing it, and also that he didnt actually see it, he just saw the green light made by the spell.

i think i read an interview about this. rowling said he couldn't see them before cause death has to sink in ??

I have a theory about how the avada kedavera (sp?) curse works. You see the spirit can never truely die. only the body can die and the spirit is released to choose to stay or to go to the spiritual realm. Here's how i think the avada kedavera curse works. It forces the spirit to be released from the body and directly into the spiritual realm because it doesn't harm the body at all. well a body can't live without a spirit. as far as dementors go the soul and the spirit are kinda seperate from eachother The soul is what gives a person his/her character while the spirit gives that person life. Now here's my theory. since Sirius' whole body fell through the veil He's not really dead, just trapped in a whole different realm. If any of this makes any since If this doesn't make since just ask me about what confuses you and I will try to make it clearer

do you think harry would die with avada kedavera?
i think since he resisted it once he wouldn't die from it? u know what i mean ?

I think what happened the first time is when Harry's mom died for him it gave Harry a kind of magic shield that kept the curse from spirit instead it touched him enough to give him that scar and the actual curse deflected back on voldemort. The way that voldemorts powers got tranfered is this, Every spell that any wizard or witch does has a bit of the caster's power in it, the spell doesn't take away the power just uses the power. Well when the spell was deflected voldemorts power went through the invisible shield and into Harry giving Harry an even better chance of surviving that curse. I hope im making sense if im not ask and I'll try to explain better

i will have to read these again 4 then to fully penetrate my brain 😕

just say what confuses you about what i said and i will try to make it clearer

the spirit and the soul being separate from each other

Ok the soul gives a person his/her character and personality, and will, The spirit is what gives a person life

So when the dementors suck out a person's soul it takes away thier free will. The spirit is nothing without a soul to guide it

Let me put it another way dementors make people feel unhappy and i mean reeealllly unhappy when a dementor sucks out a persons soul they are really sucking out thier feelings, thier heart, thier mind, but thier spirit remains

so when a dementor kisses u and u lose your soul.
when u die you lose your spirit.
so when your in the spirit realm can you find your soul or do you stay as a soulless spirit?
and r there wars in the spirit realm between good and evil

let me try to make this a liitle more clearer. Ok The soul and the spirit are together, when a dementor "kisses" you it sucks the soul out of your spirit. when a person dies however the soul stays with the spirit. Have you ever heard of lost souls? they are spirits of people who have died that dementors have sucked the souls out of

i now understand
thank you

but with Sirius since his whole body fell into that realm he may still be alive just trapped with no way out

everybody hopes for that (maybe not snape 😎 )

wow, thats a really deep theory angiethedragon...i'm impressed! And i think its starting to make some sense to my brain, after you explained it...and then reexplained it! And I still believe that sirius could come back, and this theory makes that idea even more believeable!

ok do we know that the veil goes to spirit realm or soul realm??