Originally posted by socool8520
I guess, however he has had some ridiculous victories as well. Deidara, Danzou, Oro, and Itachi. The only one I was really impressed with at all was the Deidara fight. Itachi should have destroyed him. Oro would have killed him if he had been healthy. Danzou's over confidence let him be defeated by a simple genjutsu. Other than Bee, who has made look good that shouldn't already been considered good? Bee is a jinchurikii, so he should be viewed as good. A is a hokage, again it should be assumed he is good.
Deidara and Sasuke had one of the best fights in the manga and it was actually a very close and surprisingly intelligent battle, with lots of twists that actually make a lot of sense. The only low point is the ending, which admittedly was Kishi putting himself into a corner and needing to flub the rules to continue.
Itachi didn't want to beat Sasuke. It's made explicitly clear that if Itachi had wanted to, he would have killed Sasuke. Not that Sasuke didn't show an overall decent display of skill in that fight. He was just fighting a battle he could not really lose.
The fight with Orochimaru is one of the most unintentionally awesome moments in the manga. Sasuke was completely in the right to attack Orochimaru when he was at his weakest. Why give him a shot at actually winning? The fight itself happened offscreen though, which sucked.
The Danzo fight is also one of my favorite fights. The fact that Danzo was defeated by his own overconfidence is not a detriment to the fight. Sasuke knew he was overconfident and played on that fact.
Whether we can simply conclude that they were probably strong or not is irrelevant. This is a Shonen manga after all. The best way to show that someone is strong is to have them fight. Sure, you can look at A and figure that he is strong. But him beating the crap out of Sasuke drives home the fact far better.