Originally posted by AuraAngel
Because he looks like Tobi,
Proof?
Cause the Tobi that attacked Konoha seems tall...like the Tobi Itachi found in the woods or the Tobi controlling the Mist Kage...but current Tobi does not seem nearly as tall as that Tobi. Hmmm. Different Tobis? 🙂
That's just height. But you need a same face thing going on to say that he looks like Tobi. Meow.
Originally posted by AuraAngel
fights like Tobi,
I agree, here. But they do not fight exactly like eachother.
Originally posted by AuraAngel
has Tobi's abilities,
Tobi has Tobi's abilities? Very interesting point. So an eye-swap is out of the question?
Originally posted by AuraAngel
lacks Madara's abilities(including the Senju ones that require no eye),
But wasn't that Kabuto's doing? Seems like an irrelevant point to make. I never said that old Tobi HAS to be old Madara. Just that the two Tobis may not be the same person.
Originally posted by AuraAngel
acts like Tobi and not Madara,
Hmmm. Not true. Old Tobi seems significantly different that current Tobi.
Originally posted by AuraAngel
is recognized by Minato inside Naruto's seal,
Lemme try: "A man in a dark cloak, behind a mask, with the same sharingan abilities I fought years ago? It's probably the same person!"
But was my argument ever that? No. My argument is actually directly against that one: there's no reason to conclude they are the same person because eye-swapping has occurred.
Originally posted by AuraAngel
and a ton of other incidences that wouldn't make this idea make sense.
No true. Old Tobi could be a different Tobi than current Tobi mostly because current Tobi is significantly shorter than current Tobi. What say ye?
Originally posted by AuraAngel
And yeah no, gonna cut you off before you quote this, individually looking at each reason and trying to rationalize around them.
So you don't want me to respond to each reason and point? So what is the point in making them if you don't want me to respond to them? 🙂