Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
No evidence for this really.
For one, we don't know how strong Prime Hiruzen was, except that the Hiruzen we saw was just a shadow compared to Prime.
Secondly, it wasn't really Orochimaru fighting for most of the battle, but the two Hokages, but meh, I suppose it's fairly moot.
Thirdly, if it weren't for Hiruzen's low stamina, he would have beaten Orochimaru, but he obviously would have died in the process.
Prime Sarutobi didn't have the death god tech, remember? 🙂 The Yondaime taught him that.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
We have no idea if he's surpassed Itachi yet though. MS Sasuke has most definitely not surpassed Itachi in terms of overall skill. EMS Sasuke is an unknown.
Itachi is not another generation, though. He's only a few years older than Sasuke. He was 21 when he died. I'd say that he was between Sasuke's generation and Kakashi's generation (duh, right? lol). Those are the "two" definitive generations we see in Naruto. Each generation is usually "viewed" in the manga as the squad leader and the genin. The Second to Hiruzen, Hiruzen to Jiraiya, Jiraiya to Minato, Minato to Kakashi, and Kakashi to Naruto.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
At his Prime perhaps. Hashirama had Tailed Beasts under his power at one point though, so I don't think Hiruzen is stronger than that version of Hashirama.
I dunno. That's debatable (obviously). We just don't know enough. As far as smarts, knowledge, and versatility, yeah, Sarutobi sounds to be much further ahead than both the first or second.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
At best, they are about equals now. This is another one of those 'passing of the torch' instances.
I disagree based on his last feat. If they were equals, then his father would have "ended" things quickly, as well. He didn't and it was in his best interest to do so. So, at best, his father is not nearly as strong as the full power version of his son.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Nah. For one, Shikamaru isn't as smart as his father, and for another, his father likely knows more Shadow techs. He might even have a higher chakra level.
I disagree. I think he's already smarter than his father. Sakura said Shikimaru was the smartest in Konoha (but that was shipuuden, only.)
Also, by feats alone, he is stronger than his father.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Agreed. But I will point out that we do not know how good Sakumo was, and that he was as famous as the Sannin were.
We do know: he was around as strong as the Sannin, from one quote we saw.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
He has surpassed his father, but he's still below Hiashi IMO, as is Hinata.
Since he wasn't taught the main-line's techs but figure some out, that already puts him in a league of his own. Even Hiashi was shocked that he figured that out.
The last databook shows there to be a 3 point difference between them, overall. The major difference is a 2 point difference in hand seals. Neji is actually .5 faster than Hiashi.
If they were to fight, it would be tough to determine who the winner would be. I give the nod to Neji only because of his apparent “genius.”
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Agreed, but he hasn't surpassed Raikage. awesome
Same generation, dewd. 😄
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Meh, I think it might be a generalization, and that it would encompass both a torch passing and a surpassing in strength in certain cases. The Will of Fire is about protecting everyone else and the next generation so that they can then take over.
I would say that it is "most" cases and the torch isn't really passed until they surpass them.
The Yondaime, despite probably being less knowledgably than Hiruzen, probably could beat a prime Hiruzen just because of how potent his techs were.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Besides, we both know that 'surpassing' doesn't necessarily have to mean overall strength.
I disagree, in the context of Naruto. I believe it has to be both.
If you made the case to me that it refers to the older gen getting weaker as they age and the younger gen finally passing them, I may partially agree to that. But, still, in the context of Naruto, they are showing a clear "surpassing."
About the "legends" of the past: even Shikaku said that the legends of the past are exaggerated (in his pep talk to the "new" ino-shika-cho).
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Yeah, while life wouldn't exist on our planet without the Moon, we have no idea whether the Naruto world operates the same way. For all we know, Earth in Naruto verse could be that of the Flat-Model. Or that the creation of the Moon shaped the Naruto World into what it is today.
I agree. I don't think 12 year old boys in Japan are generally aware of how important the moon is to life on earth, so Kishimoto can get away with it.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Both Madara and Nagato made reference to the Sage creating the Moon, and they are the only ones in the current generation to have fully read his Tablet, which was basically his biography, so I think there's a fair chance that he actually created the Moon, when he was nearly dead.
No, the tablet was mostly about techs, not his complete biography. It gave a very brief overview of his biography, imo.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Naruto in 6 Tailed mode had more than decent speed. But even he couldn't overcome the gravity of Nagato's much weaker Chibaku Tensei (and 6 Tailed Kyuubi was earlier able to overcome Shinra Tensei). There's a lot of gravitational force at work, and I doubt any ninja with decent speed would be able to take out the Sage once the sphere is out.
That's quite obviously PIS. Remove PIS of the Kyuubi sitting there growling and, instead, running at the body and we have a different outcome.
Someone much more ruthless and to the point, like Kakashi, would have taken care of this "concentrating" Pain.
I doubt it if he could pull off that tech with just about any upper A class or S class ninja because of the concentration and time it takes.
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Then there's his Izanagi which allowed him to create and turn reality to illusions. So basically he can invalidate his death for as long as the tech is active, which should be near unlimited as
a) He would have the largest known chakra reserve
b) He has the Rinnegan, which based on how he used Izanagi multiple times, does not shut when Izanagi is used.
There's no way to prove that Izanagi worked, at all, beyond Madara's words.
Additionally, his form of Izanagi was a creation version, not a "save-my-own-life-with-illusion-substitutions" version. He would basically create life from chakra, is how it was explained. It was a form of Izanagi, not the one Danzo was using.
As an example of the difference, he couldn't save himself from death. He should have been able to create a new, young, perfect body and then transferred his soul to it...but he couldn't. Another example: he used chakra to create the 9 demons, which were "creatures."
Originally posted by King Kandy
Isn't the whole reason why the "infinite tsukuyomi" is supposed to work, because the body of the ten tails is within the moon? I would say that is proof that the moon feat is legit. I mean, I guess you could say that Madara hasn't used that technique yet, but everyone takes it pretty damn seriously.
No, the moon's eye plan is reflecting the illusion off the moon to everyone on earth. The juubi's body being in there is only coincidental.
Originally posted by King Kandy
How could he be killed, when Izanagi can reduce his death to an illusion?
Addressed this already: that's not the same Izanagi.