i was really REALLY upset that he dies...i mean harry has been going thru SOO Much and right now when he NEEDS a father figure...since these next few years are probably going to be the toughest ever for him since you-know-who is back. argh i was just really upset...hed only known him for 2 year and he was taken away from him...just like he knew his parents only for a couple days and he lost them...
In the department of mysteries... , in the death chamber, harry could hear voices from the veil in the center of the room. anyone has any theories about it? Luna made a reference to it at the end of book 5...which might have hinted sirius could come back...but if he can come back from the dead, dont you think harry's parents could too? i mean, if they all go to the same place? well, sirius FELL through the causeway i guess...but whats the difference? ANY OPINIONS????
maybe sirius was'nt even dead.... at least thats what i think... he just went behing the veil and diddnt come out right...? did any one see him when he was dead??? did any one see him die???
but i suppose if he did die there might be a spell or potion that could bring someone back from the dead right there would have to be at least one...
Yes exactly 🙂
When Voldy went into hiding all that was left off him was an etherel being like his soul, essence, metal self or w/e but without a tangible body to hold it in - I'm thinking with Sirius it may be something similar but I'd prefer it if he still had his body 😉 just in another form whilst he is wherever he is lol 😛
Well I think that this is what I think. Maybe it is like the deal with only being able to see the Like Flying Horses thingys.(cant remember what they are called) and you can only see them if you have seen someone die. But maybe if you have had someone die after Voldemort had fallen or something then you can here them talking behind the Veil.
Or maybe they have a special messege for someone or they just need to talk to them..............
I agree with rebelphoenix 🙂 I also thimk that Sirius is trapped in some kind of "shadow World," not saing that it is a place between life or death, but that the veil is like a dimension door to a horrible kind of vortex place were youre body and soul will be trapped.................. for ever maybe 🙁 So I dont belive the teories that says that all dead people can be reached by the veil, but that the veil is a "door" to another place, thats highly possible
woah....did someone merge all the veil threads into one?? confused....lol ok so we all think hes kinda in limbo right now? cause i mean the hint luna dropped totally gave away that he wasnt dead...either that or theres something specail about the chamber...lets jsut say that that probably wasnt the last time harry was giong to visit teh department of mysteries
I looked over the above notes, and I have recently read POA again, and in there the Divination teacher mentions a veil into the future... when she's first introducing the class to the subject... maybe the veil sirius fell through goes into the future, like the above mentioned dimension or plain or something like that... just an idea I thought I'd share.
Does it make any sense? Does it sound plausible?
Originally posted by Assilem
I looked over the above notes, and I have recently read POA again, and in there the Divination teacher mentions a veil into the future... when she's first introducing the class to the subject... maybe the veil sirius fell through goes into the future, like the above mentioned dimension or plain or something like that... just an idea I thought I'd share.
Does it make any sense? Does it sound plausible?
I dont remembr that part of the book? but i could be wrong. Tewlany is gone Frieze is there and who know Pavarti and Lavender couold have somthing to do with something. i mean.
there is no information about the 6th book. so we cant make any refernce to anything.