Wow, He Really Screwed Up With Those Films Didnt He (LOTR inaccuracies)

re-reading the books i have decided that jacksons lord of the rings films are a disapointment
i am not at all happy with the way he portrayed the characters.

Sauron-the all seeing eye was his palantir, it even says in the books there is an unsleeping eye IN the tower, not a huge one that sits outside on top of barud dur, what if it rains, silly thig to do

Boromir- he was not at all like he is in the film,the way they caused all the friction with him and frodo and aragorn, that was needless boromir was the most human and noble of the fellowship and did not demand to take the ring to gondor he asked if it would be a good idea

Saruman- worst portrayed charcter of them all, where was the fear about him? he was supposed to be frightened out of his skin half the time, when the nazgul come he actually went to beg gandalf for his pardon and pity....but gandalf was gone, what do they do in the film, make the bugers breakdance

i was 80% displeased with the charcter portrayals

i was actuaklly thinking of this yesterday, not about portrayed characters unfortunatly, re-reading the part the Haldir at Helms Deep when he wasnt bleeding there

sauron, just noticing? 😛 yea, you're right

yeah, im unhappy with it

and at the moment im looking for reasons to complain 🙁

don't be daft.....the films are made and this time 6 months ago you couldnt praise him enough fool

although you do have a ligitimate claim,

I read the books....and I still think that it was a good trilogy, 😛

well, nobody asked you😛

lol..j/k kit

I agree...with kit..
sauron's lost his mind..the films are great...

hmmm i see u finally ran out of things good to say about the movies.hehe

yeah PJ could have done better, but he did damn good anyway

Character portrayals? Yeah...I didn't like all of them. Some were messed up a little bit *coughLegolascough*, but overall, I'm happy. 🙂

Overall changes from the book? I also have some disappointments, but I understand why they did it. 🙂

In conclusion, I still think the movies are great, and I'm glad about that. 😄

well am with kit and smodden,.....you guys should be with me i posted first fools 😛

if this is just a wind-up you can kiss my grits sauron

Discos - you dont deserve that title "sauron" nono

Let's put it this way:
The Movies were great.
But the books were even better.

sauron...sauron...sauron...you dont know what ur taking about silly, the movies are excellent and brilliant, i love them and the books, woohooooooo!! lol im a little hyper!

well said Solo!

I think both the movies and the books are awesome, very awesome, the movies and the books are addicting to watch and read over and over, its great to be able to escape into such a amazing world, a world of journeys and adventures, hobbits, elves, ents, wizards and escape to the places like rivendell, the shire, lothorian, rohan...its just wonderful!

yep, anotjer great point

i usually do that to escape reality, watch a film or come online 🙂

thanks, exactly, its great to escape reality and go into a world such as middle earth, i feel at peace when i do that, which i badly want middle earth to be real, for me to go to

i want to fly and become eagos

Escaping Reality is my middle name.

mines is danger

Ya so is mine Escaping Reality's Dangers.