The Hobbit: Movie · Lord of the Rings

Thrain Restricted

really i thought they made the lord of the rings first and they made the hobbit to show u how bilbo got the hold of the ring in th lord of the rings wen they give it to frodo?

The Inkeeper Senior Member

Nope no2

Thrain Restricted

i like penguins

Jackie Malfoy Jacks

I would love it if they come out with "The Hobit movie" that would be so cool.Plus it would be a lot better then...(shuders)the cartoon!I hope Jackson decides to make it.JM

Mandos Why would I want more?

I don't care if they make or not the Hobbit. All the story is in my head and it's going to stay there for a long time. This book was for children most

Kementari Elven Queen

The Hobbit is coming out so is The Silmarillion😄 hehe
But i prefer someone else directing these too.. Not PJ .. did an awful job with LOTR !! Changed so much stuff and left out a lot!! The extended versions aint even half of the book!!! Added all these stupid scenes .. waste of time!! What happened to Tom Bombadil??? Anyway not gonna get into that now!!

For more info on the Hobbit visit the Empire (magazine) website.. coming soon section🙂

Kementari Elven Queen

Re: I heard that he might do the Hobbit but it was just a rumor.

Originally posted by Jackie Malfoy
I really hope he does do the Hobbit.I mean think of the fans out there who would love to forget the stupid cartoon and see a great movie!Me for starings would love to see "The Hobbit" as a movie.Anyone know if he is actly going to do it?
Cross your fingers that he does1See you around.JM 🤣

Thorondor Love?

Originally posted by Kementari
The Hobbit is coming out so is The Silmarillion😄

no2

Originally posted by Kementari
The Hobbit is coming out so is The Silmarillion😄 hehe
But i prefer someone else directing these too.. Not PJ .. did an awful job with LOTR !!

no2

Discos The Discmeister

^^ lol couldnt of said it better myself Thor....great scots think alike.

Discos - Silmarillion movie? haha how that made me laugh 😆

Exabyte Senior Member

shock shock
According to Ö3 and FF, Elijah, Sean, Dom and Billy said in interviews that PJ *does* want to do the Hobbit-movie, preferably with those four playing roles similar to their ones in LOTR 😖 htf is this supposed to work 😖 the article suggested that they played "relatives" of Sam, Merry etc... HUH 🤨 those have practically nothing to do with the Hobbit-storyline 🤨

But as the article includes other wrong-or-at-least-not-really-true information about the topic, I wouldnt really trust it 😐

shadowy_blue Senior Member

^LMAO! Exa, that's hilarious! 😆

But like you said, I'll just take it with a grain of salt..LOL. PJ did change a lot of things in the movie, but I don't think he'll go that far. 😂

Maikahyandowen Entropy

well, it's a pretty long book. something's bound to get changed somewhere

shadowy_blue Senior Member

Originally posted by Maikahyandowen
well, it's a pretty long book. something's bound to get changed somewhere

"The HOBBIT" isn't that long, and Exa's post was talking about how the 4 main hobbits in LotR will be coming back for a hypothetical "The HOBBIT" movie playing the same characters that they played in LoTR. Even if the book ("The Hobbit"😉 itself is long, putting the 4 actors wouldn't make sense at all. Not to mention the fact that none of those characters was already alive at the time of "The HOBBIT".

The Tired Hiker El Bastardo

Maybe it will take place in "OUTER SPACE!!!!" 😱

Nazgulinthedark Super Senior Member

Originally posted by Exabyte
shock shock
According to Ö3 and FF, Elijah, Sean, Dom and Billy said in interviews that PJ *does* want to do the Hobbit-movie, preferably with those four playing roles similar to their ones in LOTR 😖 htf is this supposed to work 😖 the article suggested that they played "relatives" of Sam, Merry etc... HUH 🤨 those have practically nothing to do with the Hobbit-storyline 🤨
But as the article includes other wrong-or-at-least-not-really-true information about the topic, I wouldnt really trust it 😐

bilbo and gandalf would still be in there 😊

Bar-en-Danwedh House of Ransom

i'd like to see the hobbit as a film...

there would be no need to really change anything...

most of the changes to LOTR were, IMHO, the right choices for the purposes of film...

not all things that work in books translate well to the screne...
i think PJ did a great job...

sure, there a few things i would have approached differently...

like leaving the elves out of helmsdeep, putting the wildmen back into that battle, eliminating the ranger sword and having aragorn fight with the broken narsil untill geting it reforged at rivendell in FOTR, etc.

but there is no real need to change anything from the hobbit...
it would all work quite well on film... virtually word for word...

Maikahyandowen Entropy

hopefully. knowing jackson he'll still find some way to change things

fini Hurricane stalker

did i read that right?

they making Silmarillion??

lord now who is the stupid idiot doing that?

Havoc470 Smo

whats wrong about a silmarillion movie?

Exabyte Senior Member

Originally posted by fini
did i read that right?
they making Silmarillion??

Read right, but the info itself is wrong 😑