Will Episode III surpass any of the OT movies? [Merged]

Started by smoker421 pages

News flash it aint out yet

After three long years of relentless fighting, the Clone Wars are nearly at an end. The Jedi Council dispatches Obi-Wan Kenobi to bring General Grievous, the deadly leader of the Separatist droid army, to justice. Meanwhile, back on Coruscant, Chancellor Palpatine has grown in power.

His sweeping political changes transform the war-weary Republic into the mighty Galactic Empire. To his closest ally, Anakin Skywalker, he reveals the true nature of power and the promised secrets of the Force in an attempt to lure him to the dark side.

vs.

Hiding from the Empire's fleet of Imperial Star Destroyers, the Rebellion takes refuge on the ice planet of Hoth. While out on patrol, Luke Skywalker (Hamill) is confronted by the spirit of Obi-Wan Kenobi (Guinness), who instructs him to go to Dagobah and seek out the Jedi Master Yoda (Oz). The rebels are discovered, and following a battle with the Empire, Luke leaves the Rebellion to find Yoda, while Princess Leia (Fisher), Han Solo (Ford), Chewbacca (Mayhew) and the droids C-3PO (Daniels) and R2-D2 (Baker) leave Hoth in the Millennium Falcon.

After arriving on Dagobah, Luke begins his training with Yoda to becoming a Jedi Knight. Meanwhile, Darth Vader (Prowse/Jones), dispatches a number of bounty hunters to seek out Princess Leia and her protectors. Boba Fett, one of the hunters, tracks the Millennium Falcon to Cloud City where he devises a trap.

😂 Revenge of the opinion forcer

macgeek, take it easy. everyone has the right to their own opinion. No need to flip out. And why I wonder, are you comparing the plots of the old trilogy to the new ones? I personally think that none of the prequels could even come close to being as good as the first two. They are such classics......its a pity these new Star Wars fans nowadays.....Where are all the old fans?

Im here 🙂

High five! Good to know your here...

I do think that ROTS can be the best star wars movie ever and surpass ESB. We will find out for sure on May19th.

we are 99% sure now. and we will be 100% sure after.

There will be one thing that the so called "phycics" will say to the "non phycics" after Revenge of the Sith comes out.

The "non phycics" will be so ashamed that they didn't realise how good a movie it would be before hand, and the "phycics" will tell them, "You have paid the price for your lack of vision"

Do you mean psychics?

yes

after reading both the novels for both movies, I think the novel for ROTS is better.
Now, assuming the movies are better than the books (which in this case they are IMHO) ROTS has potential to blow everything else away.

Mainly the scene where Anakin wakes up as a robot and realizes what he's done. The very reason he betrayed everything he knew, (the Jedi order) all of his friends and family(fellow Jedi, mainly Obi-Wan) he still could not stop Padme's death. Not even that, he causes it as a result of this decision to "save her"! The heartbrake, the sorrow, the darkness that must have infested inside him are incredible and it really makes you feel bad for Anakin.

I think emotionally, it will destroy ESB, and overall it most likely will.

However, I still maintain the best line of the saga thus far is and possibly always will be, "No, I am your father!"

That's just the thing, no matter how entertaining the new Star Wars is, nothing beats the originals. They are called classics, something the new ones will never be.

Will you shut up hunchy? You really can't consider the possibility (fact most likely), that ROTS with blow the classics to hell. The classics will still be great movies, but next to ROTS they will be nothing.

I feel sorry for you hunchy, because after the movie comes out, you are going to feel like such a sorry fool. I promise I won't tease you about it. But i'm sure other people will. Listen to Darth Nefarus. He speaks the truth.

Calm down macgeek,

Nevermind....this thread is too dumb for my response

Originally posted by hunchy
no matter how entertaining the new Star Wars is, nothing beats the originals. They are called classics, something the new ones will never be.

Couldn't agree with you more!

There is NO WAY Revenge of the Sith will be better than the Original Trilogy.

end of story

... but that's just me

Devi Dodo, will also be ashamed after he see's it.

I try not to compare.

MacGeek, you do need to calm down. You expressed your opinion, I expressed mine. But there is one thing that you dont seem to understand...I think Revenge of the Sith will be a very good movie, but in my book nothing comes CLOSE to the old trilogy. No matter how good it is, I don't think it will even come within a league of the first two....and no, I will not be sorry after viewing it.