The Force Theory: Discussion Thread

Originally posted by Ushgarak
And I will remind you that George Lucas has also directly stated that the Force does not go out of balance until AFTER Anakin is taken over by dark forces. This does not happen until the end of Episode III.

Ooooo, a fight! 😈

It is not twisting, it is saying what he said. It is abundantly clear.

Along with this quote:

"Anakin will be taken over by dark forces which in turn destroy the balance of the Galaxy"

In turn. AFTER he goes bad. Again- future tense.

Sorry, GL is clear. The balance is not destroyed until after these events.

emp Stop your arguing and hostility!!!!

Ok so lets see if you have sand on both sides of a scale, and on one side the sand starts to erode, does the scale go out of balance? But then maybe in your world it doesnt.

Well, it beggars belief that someone can read something that says that something is going to happen, future tense, and say it is me twisting that to not agree that it thereofre means it has already happened.

It is ludicrous and if people continue to say that is twisting, I will continue to be angry. It is FACT.

And JP, whatever nonsensical allegory you want to come up with, it does not change what GL has said.

Process started, Not finished, Force going to go out of Balance- has not done so yet. Clearly your allegories are therefore not appropriate.

Ush please make up your mind...
Is it out of balance only agter Ani is turned or is it eroding from within for all these years. Every other post you contradict yourself and then wonder why we mere mortals dont get it. WTF?

Answer my question about the sand and the scale.

Now you are just lying. I have not once contradicted myself. Read my posts again.

<--------Still waiting.........you cant ignore physics.

Originally Posted by: The Emperor
emp
Yes, yes....give in to your hate! With each passing moment, you make yourself more my servant.....

I answered your point already' Cannot ignore physics' is simply gibberish.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Now you are just lying. I have not once contradicted myself. Read my posts again.

Trust me I have read them more than I would like, so just answer the question once and for all... In your infinite wisdom when does the imbalance happen?

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I answered your point already' Cannot ignore physics' is simply gibberish.

😆 no you're wrong, it's just that simple. If the force was already startting to ERODE as Lucas said in TPM then it's already begun to shift out of balance! And the laws of physics are not gibberish.

The actual state in which the Galaxy can be said to be out of Balance is almost certainly when the Jedi are destroyed. That it is the destruction of the Jedi that does it is my opinion, but it fits all the facts, especially as the destruction of the Sith in turn restores it.

As whatever it is does not happen until after Anakin turns bad- fact from GL- I think you will be hard pushed to think of a better one.

But the process that is causing that, the start of the slippage of Balance towards the point of Unbalance, is happening from the moment Sidious starts his plans.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
😆 no you're wrong, it's just that simple. If the force was already startting to ERODE as Lucas said in TPM then it's already begun to shift out of balance! And the laws of physics are not gibberish.

Physics is not, you attempting to use an inaccurate analogy to try and contradict what GL says about his own universe most certainly is.

GL says it has not happened yet. Fact. All the waste-of-time talking about sand will not change that.

So for 3 pages you have argued both sides & just now found a way to tie them together, Convenient

Simply a lie- again.

Uh I believe thats exactly what I said. With the appearance of the Sith. Please post the exact quote with a link where Lucas said the force doesnt go out of balance until the Jedi are defeated.

No, you said the Galaxy was already unbalanced. Not true. It is heading that way, but it is not unbalanced yet- that is what GL says.