The Force Theory: Discussion Thread

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Simply a lie- again.

prove it

"Anakin will be taken over by dark forces which in turn destroy the balance of the Galaxy"

If this quote was written at the time of TPM then is it not possible that 'when Anakin turns bad' could be in Ep2 with the slaughtering of the sandpeople....?

If so, Yes, the darkside would be out of balance already by the time of Ep3... 🙂

🤨

emp
It's true....the Dark Side penetrates the souls of even the most at peace with the Force....

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Actually the Force goes out of balance with the appearance of the Sith. They dont have to defeat the Jedi for the balance to shift.

Do not twist my words I know exactly what I said.

Hah! Up to you to prove I have lied first before I refute it.

My position has always been simply this- the Galaxy does not go out of Balance until the Jedi are destroyed. That position is backed by GL and has never changed. Now show me the lie.

Last warning with the hostility and the name calling - knock it off or

ok i understand, its unbalanced...but its not unbalanced.
its unbalanced until ep3 when anakin turns...then it will be REALLY unbalanced....???

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Hah! Up to you to prove I have lied first before I refute it.

My position has always been simply this- the Galaxy does not go out of Balance until the Jedi are destroyed. That position is backed by GL and has never changed. Now show me the lie.

Dude, you called ME a liar, so the burden is on you, or does that make too much sense?

No, it is becoming unbalanced but is not unbalanced yet.

That's simply what GL says. If you don't like the description... tough, that's how he likes it.

But what cannot be argued is that he directly says that it has not happened yet.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
My position has always been simply this- the Galaxy does not go out of Balance until the Jedi are destroyed. That position is backed by GL and has never changed.

Originally posted by bilb
Dude, you called ME a liar, so the burden is on you, or does that make too much sense?

Sigh... only in response to you saying I contradicted myself. You prove your things first, then I shall refute if necessary. That is how basic logic works.

"Actually the Force goes out of balance with the appearance of the Sith"

Yup, as you quoted yourself... that is what you said... and it is wrong. GL says so.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
I asked you to provide the quote. And the link to it. I did.

I have given you the quotes. I already said, that it is directly the Jedi is my opinion, but if you have a better event after Anakin turns bad, by all means give it. That it is after Anakin turns bad is direct from GL.

You know what? Go ahead & have your last word. Seems to be all you are good at. So have at it. You are in the wrong here, you know it, I know it & everyone else does too. So flame away. you know its too bad you get an such a high horse in this forum, you are actually a nice guy in others.

But where did he say this? An interview? From where did it come? I mean I can sit here and say GL says JarJar is Anakins father but that doesnt make it so.

I am not even vaguely in the wrong, GL supports me, you cannot deny what he has said, and he directly says it does not happen until after Anakin tuns bad. The only reason I think this is because GL said it. That is the only lead I have followed when it comes to facts, instead of letting possibly erroneous opinions interfere with what GL has already decided upon. I cannot truthfully say that the Death Star is a cube, that Han's name is Stanley, or that Luke is a Rodian. Likewise, I cannot truthfully say that the Force is out of Balance before Anakin turns evil, which in turn means it cannot have been simply when the Sith re-appeared. That's how it is.

This discussion was all from Cut magazine in '99.

Link?

What do you mean, link? It's a magazine, not a net page. Go read it.

Yes it does JP, because it's GL's MOVIES!
And bilbs, what the **** are you talking about? Ush has proven his point countless times, but you and JP are too much of a couple of divas to even admit that he is right.....🙄

Originally posted by Ushgarak
What do you mean, link? It's a magazine, not a net page. Go read it.

an article from a magazine i have never heard of that was printed in 99..

yeah that will be right there at the local bookseller or libary for me to read this....interview

Hey ARC, if you think I'm wrong thats cool. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, so long as it is their OWN opinion & not just blindly backing some else.

But I have never been called a diva...I'm flattered!!! 😮