The Force Theory: Discussion Thread

(shrugs)

Truth hurts, but there you go.

Look here is my OPINION:

The Sith will EVENTUALLY totally destroy the balance one Ani falls BUT the balance has been getting more & more out of whack for 1000 years.

Is that better?

Hopefully Lil b got my PM to close this....

*edit*: hit the refresh once in a while walla...

...or not.

Originally posted by bilb
Look here is my OPINION:

The Sith will EVENTUALLY totally destroy the balance one Ani falls BUT the balance has been getting more & more out of whack for 1000 years.

Is that better?

exactly ✅

I must say you two are making different arguments. JP is saying that this erosion is a slow process over time (the sand scales, ect.) and ush if I understand correct your saying that the prcess happens in one event. So thats the real argument correct?

That's because the context of the interview is made up- it is made-up stuff intercut with what he really did say to Cut Magazine.

That doesn't seem objectionable, Bilb. So long as no direct contradiction is being made to GL's statement that the Balance of the Force is not destroyed until after Anakin turns, any theory works.

Originally posted by Cowboyography
I must say you two are making different arguments. JP is saying that this erosion is a slow process over time (the sand scales, ect.) and ush if I understand correct your saying that the prcess happens in one event. So thats the real argument correct?

Not quite. There is a process of destroying Balance- that process is not complete, and therefore the Balance is not actually destroyed, until after Anakin turns.

GRRRRRRRRRRRRR! Did I ever say anything about when it was destroyed????????? NO!
I said it goes out of balance with the appeance of the Sith. For the love of God read what I write. This is my whole point. It's not about when the balance is finally destroyed, or when it's brought back. It's when it actually SHIFTS out of balance.

So what exactly are you two arguing now? Or have you both forgot?

Originally posted by Ushgarak
That's because the context of the interview is made up- it is made-up stuff intercut with what he really did say to Cut Magazine.

That doesn't seem objectionable, Bilb. So long as no direct contradiction is being made to GL's statement that the Balance of the Force is not destroyed until after Anakin turns, any theory works.

So can we end this now? PLEASE? This is what I said on page one of this thread anyway! Good Lord we are all stubborn! 😆

The point is that people were saying that the Balance was gone before that point. GL simply does not see it that way.

So sorry, JP, that's still wrong. Until the Balance is destroyed, it is still Balanced.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
So what exactly are you two arguing now? Or have you both forgot?

😂
😂
😂
😂
😂
😂

who said you said destoyed?

🤨
Let's have an orgy!
*Hopes that stops insanity - at least temporarily*

Originally posted by Ushgarak
and therefore the Balance is not actually destroyed, until after Anakin turns.

Is that because Anakin was meant to bring balance to the force so when he turns the force loses balance..??? emp

I just love my ultra fabulous Palps smilie.

Ok, so I may be opening a whole new can of worms here but, Ush if it is as you say & the balance is DESTROYED once Ani turns, what happens once he kills Palps in ROTJ? Balance again? & if so how is that possible if it was totally destroyted as you have said?

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Until the Balance is destroyed, it is still Balanced.

ARGH! Where is the beating the head on the computer smilie???
So, if you use that logic. If you drop a teaspoon of sand back on those scales they are still in balance until a rock (Anakin) comes along and gets dropped there?

Actually, to be accurate, I never said the Balance is gone once Anakin turns, merely that GL says the Sith do it AFTER he turns, and I cannot think of an event that suits that better than the destruction of the Jedi.

And killing Sidious restores the Balance... err, that's as complex as it gets. Clearly, either state it not perfect or irreversible.