Are the Sith really Evil? Honestly

Started by Uber_God6 pages

He means grey as how he didnt kill luke when he had the chance and when he turned back to the light at the end of rotj

And I still mean Grey my ass 😛

🙄

SITH ARE EVIL JEDI ARE GOOD END STORY CLOSE THIS EXUCSE O A FORUM DOWN

I'm glad you cleared that up ryano 😛

ok, so the sith create imbalances in the force while the jedi create balance.

so let's say your in a small, cramped room with two guys. one of the sprays febreeze and the other one is lactose intolerant but keeps eating cheese and farting anyway. so which one of them is evil?

ok then ryano king god of all star wars knowledge

Originally posted by Lan©eWindu™
Reading this thread reminds me of the Death Star 2 discussion in Clerks.

The Rebels killed a whole bunch of innocent construction workers, they are no better than the Sith.

AS GL said in response to that, they were only a bunch of evil bugs anyway...

you have to understand that 1 both sith and jedi cannot live without each other the jedi created the imbalance by wiping out all the sith there was already an imbalance in the FORCE not in there world system but in THE FORCE! the way i see things is that its a yin and yang system that runs the star wars universe...both the jedi and sith codes i disagree with the jedi code says no emotion...sounds like communism to me (which in all actuallity looks good on paper) but you see how no emotions looks like in the movie equiliberium...everything is grey and there is no art...you take passion away then there goes love and everyother wonderful emotion with it. and the sith code i have a problem with that because they say peace is a lie...i believe peace is something that can be attained once a man decides to look past his own condition and culture but man is so ready to be offended for culture or conditions sake that he would rather die fighting then to try and understand each other...Im gonna stop right here i just wanted to get you guys to think a little bit. I think peace can be attained if your passionate enough to want it...just becarful where your passion leads you.

Originally posted by Darth Christian
you have to understand that 1 both sith and jedi cannot live without each other the jedi created the imbalance by wiping out all the sith there was already an imbalance in the FORCE not in there world system but in THE FORCE! the way i see things is that its a yin and yang system that runs the star wars universe...both the jedi and sith codes i disagree with the jedi code says no emotion...sounds like communism to me (which in all actuallity looks good on paper) but you see how no emotions looks like in the movie equiliberium...everything is grey and there is no art...you take passion away then there goes love and everyother wonderful emotion with it. and the sith code i have a problem with that because they say peace is a lie...i believe peace is something that can be attained once a man decides to look past his own condition and culture but man is so ready to be offended for culture or conditions sake that he would rather die fighting then to try and understand each other...Im gonna stop right here i just wanted to get you guys to think a little bit. I think peace can be attained if your passionate enough to want it...just becarful where your passion leads you.
Resurrection much? Oh and Peace is a lie. I've never been at peace.

Furthermore, it is incorrect. 😬 The Sith and the Jedi are not Ying and Yang.

the sith are evil. Honestly.

Come-on!! The DEATH Star???? Jedi don't blow planets up, killing billions of innocents......that is PURE evil!

Oh yeah, cuz the jedi have never concentrated thier power into a wall of light that would almost certainly have wiped out the Massassi had not Exar Kun got their first. Iirc that is.

This isn't directed at the original poster btw.

Originally posted by sanatayesse
From what I've been reading on the novels and comics, Palpatine's point of view sounds very convincing in that Jedi are taught that sith are evil and its probably the same thing for the sith. I think George Lucas mentioned something that the sith were like the first civilization who were present, until the jedi came and wiped them out. I mean I know the sith ways seem akward like: master and apprentice trying to kill eachother off, but I feel that is just what they do in the nature and that's why they are very powerful. Remember the quote from episode 3 trailer: "the darkside of the force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural". In the end there will always be two opposite disctinct sides with opposite points of view and maybe that's why palpatine is so good in luring Ankakin to join him. Whenever I hear the word dark side, I always got the idea that no one really knows where that side leads(kinda like the dark ages) and the jedi perceive it as evil. Anyhow, I hope this kinda makes people think....PEACE!!

The Sith kill innocents. I find that evil.

Bane killed a random, innocent family in order to heal himself by taking strength in their suffering.

Sith = evil

The mythos of Star Wars contains ethical absolutes unlike ours.

The Sith are clearly evil.

Originally posted by Autokrat
The mythos of Star Wars contains ethical absolutes unlike ours.

The Sith are clearly evil.

True, the sith are evil (as shown in my above example, an act that is really horrible), but just because GL says that X are evil doesn't mean that they are.

Morality does not alter from universe to universe. What people say is right/wrong might, but logic and reason do not.

Bane killed a random, innocent family in order to heal himself by taking strength in their suffering.

Sith = evil

Yup.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yup.

That's evil.

The fact that he takes strength in their suffering is ridiculous.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Bane killed a random, innocent family in order to heal himself by taking strength in their suffering.

Sith = evil

So preserving your own life makes you evil?