All Of Star Trek Vs All Of Star Wars

Guilty until proven innocent, eh?

Yes, not everything is said in done because you'd have to find either a hardcore Trek fan willing to debate on a messageboard of 16 year olds on the Star Wars forum or find someone stupid enough to watch and read through about 40 years of episodes, movies, books, comic, and manuals.

I chose to debate time travel because it was a small, reletively contained part of Star Trek history. We debated it until there was nothing else to say about it. Done.

This thread reminds me alot of what a thread like "Mandarin vs Wolverine" would be like on a Wolverine messageboard. They just want to say Wolverine would snikt Mandarin in a hand to hand fight and don't know or care really that Mandarin uses rings that could probably level a city.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
Guilty until proven innocent, eh?

Yes, not everything is said in done because you'd have to find either a hardcore Trek fan willing to debate on a messageboard of 16 year olds on the Star Wars forum or find someone stupid enough to watch and read through about 40 years of episodes, movies, books, comic, and manuals.

I chose to debate time travel because it was a small, reletively contained part of Star Trek history. We debated it until there was nothing else to say about it. [b]Done.

This thread reminds me alot of what a thread like "Mandarin vs Wolverine" would be like on a Wolverine messageboard. They just want to say Wolverine would snikt Mandarin in a hand to hand fight and don't know or care really that Mandarin uses rings that could probably level a city. [/B]

Nobody else is going to post? Then I guess the debate is over.

Hooray! Wars Wins.

i was checking out something in the star wars.com databanks when i saw an ad that goes like this: Star Trek 2.0 weeknights at 11pm G4 g4tv.com

WHat the hell was that about? That's either Ironic, or whatever!

here:

Star Trek seems to be as good as anything else to advertise.

Originally posted by DarthBanevv
Nobody else is going to post? Then I guess the debate is over.

It's a never-ending battle. But Wars seems to have won here. By the time a new Trekkie comes this thread probably won't be on page 1 anymore. And without it being one of the first threads to pop-up it may be over for some time, until somebody re-discovers it.

...If it's never ending how can it be over at all? It sleeeeeps *green goblin voice* sleeeeeep.

And it does seem as if Star Wars wins via article b section 2: The LALALALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU! method.

If anything.

Swanky, again you mistake my posts. I meant that the argument is over on this forum. But it's a never-ending battle in other more visited places. Believe it or not other people have had this argument, other forums, websites, in IM, chatrooms, and other places on the web. What I meant to say is that the battle may be over here, but in other places it's a never-ending battle.

Star Trek doesn't exclude Governmental Entities/Races besides the Federation.

With that in mind, Star Trek.

In ROTJ a small, tiny little A-Wing crashed and took out an entire SUPER Star Destroyer. If thats all it takes... thats not saying much for SW technology.

Someone probably pointed this out, but it took out the Command Center of the Super Star Destroyer after it's Shield Generator's were destroyed.

Oh wow, DE Sidious's power of destroying fleets with the Dark Side of the Force is enough to wipe out the Federation's Fleets as they approach Sidious's flagship.

Oh wow, Q flicks his fingers and suddenly every Jedi has lost his powers.

Oh that's right...

SW Fanboys: No fair u hev teh ub3r Q!11

Q: Die. *Finger snap*

SW Fanboys: *Not existing*

No, but seriously... ST doesn't get Q, so therefore, why not restrict SW's side from having access to the force. Don't give me that "But they're the center of the SW universe" Ultima Fanboy BS. If ST is restricted to Mundane, then SW should be too.

Well, DarthDumbledore made the rules. Around here DarthDumbledore is a god.

This is not 'nam, this is bowling, there are rules.

Originally posted by Lord Chariol
Well, DarthDumbledore made the rules. Around here DarthDumbledore is a god.

This is not 'nam, this is bowling, there are rules.

If I understood the reference. 😖

Ok, NineCoronas. No force users. SW still wins. It doesn't really matter if we exculde them or not. It wasn't a big part of anyone's argument anyways.

Really? I saw a lot of things about star's being thrown around and Sidiou's ultimate power to the infinite. Then again, I only read the first 23 pages.

Everyone's Arguement also involved just the Federation, which is basically a gang of pussies.

Originally posted by NineCoronas
Everyone's Arguement also involved just the Federation, which is basically a gang of pussies.

Originally posted by DarthBanevv
Swanky, again you mistake my posts. I meant that the argument is over on this forum. But it's a never-ending battle in other more visited places. Believe it or not other people have had this argument, other forums, websites, in IM, chatrooms, and other places on the web. What I meant to say is that the battle may be over here, but in other places it's a never-ending battle.

It's been going on for a long time. Almost thirty years. Until ST is forgotten, this debate will persist in some way. Not through this thread probably, but in one way or another.

Originally posted by NineCoronas
If I understood the reference. 😖

Originally posted by DarthBanevv
It's been going on for a long time. Almost thirty years. Until ST is forgotten, this debate will persist in some way. Not through this thread probably, but in one way or another.

That's if it isn't ressurected every 3-4 days by someone posting that nobody has posted in the last 3-4 days.