Plot holes in Episode III

what kinda of non-sense is this....they should all burn because of the heat plus anakin didn't touch the lava,he was far from it but still his body went on fire unlike palpatine)sidious i think it's a mistake from GL

Yes, star wars universe is exact same as ours

Originally posted by ShadowKing
The only reason Obi and Ani didn't burn while on the floating platforms were because of the force field (okay stop laughing now).

Yeah they did a good job of making it perfectly clear what the force field was good for.

Maybe this is a plot hole or not, but if Vader thought Padme died pregnant, when did he realize his kids were alive? Does anybody know?

Originally posted by The Last Son
Maybe this is a plot hole or not, but if Vader thought Padme died pregnant, when did he realize his kids were alive? Does anybody know?

He never knew she had twins, and learned of Luke either when he sensed him from the TIE in ANH or when Palpatine tells him in ESB.

OK when does he realize Luke had a twin sister? And can you really sense your relatives with the force if you believe them to be dead for over 19 years? Hard to believe.

The force does many things. He found out about Leia when he "read Luke's mind" in ROTJ.

That makes sense. It's too bad Leia never got to meet her father. They never show her looking at the ghosts in ROTJ.

Originally posted by The Last Son
OK when does he realize Luke had a twin sister? And can you really sense your relatives with the force if you believe them to be dead for over 19 years? Hard to believe.

Luke seems to realise about Leia in the instant Obi tells him the truth on Dagobah.
And isn't everything the Force enables characters to do hard to believe?
Move objects without touching them?
Leap unbelievable distances?
Generate lightning?
etc

It's a fantasy film...

"Excuse me Bill Nye the Science Guy"

Originally posted by The Last Son
...Luke's Uncle thought that Anikan shouldn't have gotten invoved in the Clone Wars.

and for that we acuse Obi-Wan of lying?

if there was a scene with Owen telling Anakin "go kick some azz, bro!", then i would see the point - but i don't see why we need a scene with with Owen telling Anakin "please, give up this Jedi stuff and settle down on the farm" to keep Obi from being a liar.

...maybe Owen sent Ani an email, like "i worry about you sometimes, please quit fighting and come live with us on the farm, where it's safe".

Hilarious.

OB1 also tells Luke in EP4 that Darth Vader killed the Jedi, when it was the storm troopers that did this.

Really lame was the "higher ground" excuse for why OB1 defeated Annakin.

Actually, Ben tells Luke the Vader "helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights". Which he did.

Obi Wan didn't exactly win because he had the high ground. He won because Anakin was being a stupid arrogant prick.

Besides which, most of Vader's aiding the EMpire in jedi hunting takes place between III and IV.

Hows this for an inconsistency: During the final battle Anakin says to Obi-Wan: "If your not with me, then your against me" to which Obi Wan replies: "Only a Sith deals in absolutes". Later on after Anakin has been defeated, Obi-Wan says to him: "You were my brother, I loved you". Correct me if Im wrong, but sure love is an absolute??

Originally posted by zombieman
Hows this for an inconsistency: During the final battle Anakin says to Obi-Wan: "If your not with me, then your against me" to which Obi Wan replies: "Only a Sith deals in absolutes". Later on after Anakin has been defeated, Obi-Wan says to him: "You were my brother, I loved you". Correct me if Im wrong, but sure love is an absolute??

For all of you people who think that there are plot holes you need to watch the anime disc titled "the clone wars"

and as far as ANH where you all say obi wan is lying about the droids, he isn't. He remembers them what he says is "I don't remember ever owning a droid" because R2 says he is the PROPERTY of obiwan. And all obiwan is saying is that he never ownedn R2 but he knows who R2 is.

I never got that impression that Obi won recognized the droids in Episode 4 until I saw the prequels. Which leads me to the question, how did Princess Lea know where he was or that artoo would find him?

Originally posted by The Last Son
I never got that impression that Obi won recognized the droids in Episode 4 until I saw the prequels. Which leads me to the question, how did Princess Lea know where he was or that artoo would find him?

bail probably told her...