Official Episode 3 fan review page [Merged]

well i went into the midnight preview knowing the whole storyline and having read every spoiler and seen every leaked picture imaginable, and i still managed to miss bits that i realy wanted to look out for. there's just so much going o!

it's wicked tho, what a movie! very different to all of the previous films with some of the camera angles, general atmosphere, but really dense and enjoyable. special mention to obi's giant lizard friend (cant remember her name) and Yoda's mindbendingly expressive animation, cool as f*ck!

erm.. the 'fancy' wipes tho, not into them. i could aslo have done without vader screaming 'nooooo' at the end. bit corny for me, but i never thought that would work anyway ;]

but really the final verdict is that it's f*cking briliant.

All in all, it's goof enough to forgive its flaws. Unlike EpI and II. Maybe GL should go and redo those two for the next 28 years, he finally got the hang of it.

only weird dialogue and questionable acting came for Sam and Ian during their fight

No, he had some questionable dialogue. And his whimpering during the fight with Mace (yes I understand he was provoking Anakin) was just too pathetic for a Sith Lord.

I loved every second of Ian. Flawless.

I agree.... well, apart from the ugly rubber mask.

anakins transformation was a bit abrupt.

one second hes all "what have I done?"

next second: "Yes, master I will slaughter them all".

some of the dialogue was painful, some was OK. Fights were great, too many lightsabers though. It diluted the impact. Yoda and Sidious shouldnt have used them against each other, would have been a cooler fight with just the force.

Anakin, Darth Vader Rather when he messes up the room where he finds out he supposedly killed Padme, The "NOOO!" was really corny.....

but i thought it was cool, i predicted the whole movie though, except for some parts....

But the acting was horrible! ugh!

The only acting that bothered me was Sam's... and maybe a few lines from Hayden and Natalie, but they were ok for the most part.

I mean, this is Star Wars... what were you expecting?

GL did what I feared he would do with this movie, he didnt consider some facts of the OT and just blew the scene with Luke and Leia in ROTJ away

yea... does Lucas really think we're gonna buy that Luke - err, Leia I mean - remembers that one smile Padme gives her two seconds after he's born? and when his eyes aren't even open?

you can't explain your way around that one... PLOT HOLE!

Yes, and many more.

How about this one: Ï haven't gone by the name of OB1 since all before you were born".

everyone in the OT turns out to be liars!!!

great call queeq

We already knew that Obi was a lier. I can buy that Leia may remember seeing her mother. After all, she is a jedi baby. If her eyes are open and Luke's aren't, it is plausible. Besides, I believe that she shares that connection to their mother that Luke share's to their father.

That's right it's Leia not Luke... I guess you could kinda argue that. It's a stretch... but it'll have to do 😉

Does nobody else think the wipes they used were totally ridiculous?

Sure it's a stretch. It does work, though.

actually it was Luke who got the most time in front of his mother so the entire event kills off Luke and Leias conversation at Endor. Besides Luke is trained in the jedi ways and encountered his father which would explain his connection toward him, as for Leia nothing

Finti's right. Lucas slaughtered the ROTJ scene.

oh and those litle wrecking droids that got onto Obis ship was a bit too much as well.......