Lazerlike42
Darth Incompetant
I used to think that way but I have spent the better part of 24 hours straight on here realizing that at besy my belief is questionable.
We have Lucas confirming that the lightning is what turned his face ugly. That begs the question why would he let himself get that messed up for a lie, when it was totally unecessary and Anakin would have turned anyways. Yes he then showed it to the senate as evidence, but he is simply playing things to his benefit, just as he played Amidala's UNINTENDED escape from Naboo in TPM to his own designs.
Look, he loses his saber before Anakin gets there, and so he tries to fry Mace because he's desperate. What if Anakin doesn't do anything? What if Mace wasn't such a bumbling idiot and just stabbed Palpatine instead of rambling on dramatically? He was being overpowered dramatically before Anakin gets there, and had plenty of chance to actually die, any given second during that time he could have. Do you really think he put himself at that risk?
Further, look at this post by mtyrdr:
There are two truly pivotal moments over the course of the six movies: Anakin's turning on the Jedi to save Sidious, and Vader's turning on Sidious to save Luke. This is a blatant, obvious parallel on far, far too many levels to be a coincidence. In order for this to be true, however, Palpatine must have needed Anakin in order to survive. Anything less throws the entire theme of the six movies out of whack. Anakin's actions were what directly allowed for both the beginning and the end of the Empire. Without the former, the latter loses all significance, and the theme of redemption is partially ruined.
FURTHERMORE, Ian overacted in ROTJ, too, but he wasn't lying to anybody then....