Lightsaber versus Claws: Maul v Wolverine

Started by Darth_DaNThEMaN7 pages

they can cut through adamantium.

adamantium can beat melted down as we see in x2.

lightsaber can cut through anything but another laser.

even if it couldnt(it can)

maul will win.

For the sake of argument I don't think it can cut through adamantium. Wasn't there something in the Thrawn Crisis that Luke couldn't cut through? Either way I'd say that if Maul can cut through adamantium he could shove the saber into Logan's head and just let it sit in his brain for a while not allowing it to heal back for like 5 seconds til the brain dies.

Maul would win. Even if not with his saber. In a alternative story from marvel, magneto makes wolverine to cut his own throat thus dying. Same thing would happen. Maul just need to cut wolverine's throat. This, assuming that the light sabre wouldn't cut throught the adamantium, which I seriously doubt.

i think saber can cut through adamantium

Originally posted by Darth_DaNThEMaN
adamantium can beat melted down as we see in x2.

Adamantium is created by using certain processing on... iron I think. It must stay molten because if it cools it turns into adamantium and can't be remelted. I know this not only because I've read the comic history but because that's how Stryker explained it in the movie when they showed the very vats of molten pre-adamantium you're talking about.

They may not of gone into its base being iron... but they explained how adamantium is created.

Actually a lightsaber can't cut through:

-cortosis ore, capable of repelling or even shorting out a lightsaber blade (as shown in "I, Jedi" and in KOTOR)
-the unnamed metal superconductor used for ship armour hundreds of years before the Empire (as shown in "Shatterpoint"😉
-Mandalorian Iron ("Tales of the Jedi: Dark Lords of the Sith" comic)

So you can argue if a lightsaber could cut through adamantium.

BUT Dipsit and Rankkor got me to some terrible (for Wolvie) ideas here:

a)
Maul just has to use the force to keep Wolverine in position and than cut his throat with his lightsaber. The wound will immediatly cauterize because of the lightsabers heat. So there is no blood (and oxygen) transported to Wolverines brain any longer and he dies.

b)
Maul can use the force and pull the adamantium out of Wolverines body (splatter action).

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
a) Maul just has to use the force to keep Wolverine in position and than cut his throat with his lightsaber. The wound will immediatly cauterize because of the lightsabers heat. So there is no blood (and oxygen) transported to Wolverines brain any longer and he dies.

Maul could just use a technique that would work and behead him. Wolverine has regenerated charred wounds before. I know he shouldn't but he does.
b) Maul can use the force and pull the adamantium out of Wolverines body (splatter action).

You mean seperate it from the bones and stuff? That would be powerful messy but neat to see. For a while. I imagine it'd get as boring as shucking oysters after a while since there are so many bones.

When using the force its actually very possible to break every bone in somebody's body, doesn't matter what kind of material it is, I don't know if Maul is powerful enough to do it but a powerful Sith could destroy every bone in somebody's body.

Originally posted by Fishy
When using the force its actually very possible to break every bone in somebody's body, doesn't matter what kind of material it is, I don't know if Maul is powerful enough to do it but a powerful Sith could destroy every bone in somebody's body.

i doubt maul could do that. someone like revan, exar kun or kreia i'd imagine could very likely.

i mean no offense but this thread is kinda sour, i mean there's just no chance for wolvie 😉 unless throwin in juggernaut in the picture most comic book characters don't stand a chance

Originally posted by Fishy
When using the force its actually very possible to break every bone in somebody's body, doesn't matter what kind of material it is, I don't know if Maul is powerful enough to do it but a powerful Sith could destroy every bone in somebody's body.
Adamantium bones that have been bonded on a molecular level?

Originally posted by Darth_Rankkor
In a alternative story from marvel, magneto makes wolverine to cut his own throat thus dying.
In a recent avengers wolverine's claws were jammed into his throat, but that didn't kill him.

Maul should win this, he's got the force, so there should be nothing wolverine can do to maul.

But that lightsaber isn't going to work as it's been pointed out that there are materials in SW that can't be cut, and adamantium has survived the heat of the sun (though it took the help of the phoenix to keep wolverine from dying)

You'd have to fry all of Wolverine's organic material in order to kill him.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
Because lightsabers are a weapon of science and adamantium easily survives direct nuke hits, I just go with sabers not cutting but not blocking as not to have to deal with fanboys whining about the strength of adamantium.
If the lightsaber doesn't block adamantium, and vice versa, Maul's weapon is virtually useless.

Maul could tear his skeleton from his skin, not destroying the skeleton itself. Remember that in AoA wolverine was killed via sentinel blast, but his skeleton survived.

Originally posted by Creshosk
If the lightsaber doesn't block adamantium, and vice versa, Maul's weapon is virtually useless.

It's still good for cutting organic matter. Especially the parts holding the bones together that aren't laced with adamantium.
Originally posted by Gryn Jabar
Maul could tear his skeleton from his skin, not destroying the skeleton itself. Remember that in AoA wolverine was killed via sentinel blast, but his skeleton survived.

Alternate realities are different. He wasn't nearly as popular back then.

True, but let's assume that slavering at the mouth fanfs have nothing to do with this fight. Also, lets throw JP in there, how would he do?

force choke.

either way, maul wins.

Originally posted by Gryn Jabar
True, but let's assume that slavering at the mouth fanfs have nothing to do with this fight. Also, lets throw JP in there, how would he do?
JP?

He'd own both of these guys like they were nothing.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
It's still good for cutting organic matter. Especially the parts holding the bones together that aren't laced with adamantium.
Well what I'm saying is the the saber wouldn't block the claws either. If Maul doesn't start off with a force attack wolverine is going to kill him from the first attack.

Maul force chokes him, wolfy can't do anything about that

Originally posted by Creshosk
Well what I'm saying is the the saber wouldn't block the claws either. If Maul doesn't start off with a force attack wolverine is going to kill him from the first attack.

First attack? Selling Maul a little short aren't you?

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
First attack? Selling Maul a little short aren't you?
If Wolverine attacks with his claws, the natural instinct would be to try and block. The claws pass through the blade that was supposed to block the claws and. . . wolverine lands a hit with his claws. . . that were not blocked. . . by the lightsaber maul thought would block the claws. . . but didn't. . .

Have I said it enough different ways to get what I was thinking across?it's not sarcasm, I'm just not very eloquent with words sometimes . . .

wolverine.....in all sincerity.....is a b1tch compared to any sith.

nuff said.