Lightsaber versus Claws: Maul v Wolverine

Started by Boris7 pages

Mr Maul.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Adamantium bones that have been bonded on a molecular level?

Well...maybe my memories are not that accurate here...I thought Wolverines bones had the adamantium around them and therefore can not be broken from the "outside". A force user could crush them without doing any damage to the adamantium. That would be a lot of pain I think.

Also Maul could "freeze" Wolverine completely through the force and than cut the whole flesh from the bones. I doubt that Wolverine would survive that since there would be nothing left to heal.

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Well...maybe my memories are not that accurate here...I thought Wolverines bones had the adamantium around them and therefore can not be broken from the "outside". A force user could crush them without doing any damage to the adamantium. That would be a lot of pain I think.
The characters have been undergoing alot of changes, the adamantium was removed by magneto some time ago, then when it was put in it was bonded on a molecular level.

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Also Maul could "freeze" Wolverine completely through the force and than cut the whole flesh from the bones. I doubt that Wolverine would survive that since there would be nothing left to heal.
He wouldn't be fast enough to get it all off before he healed back.

Maul could still win though. But he'd have to use the force. . .

Originally posted by Creshosk
If Wolverine attacks with his claws, the natural instinct would be to try and block. The claws pass through the blade that was supposed to block the claws and. . . wolverine lands a hit with his claws. . . that were not blocked. . . by the lightsaber maul thought would block the claws. . . but didn't. . .

But saber users know lightsabers to cut through anything. It makes more sense that he'd try to cut his claws off rather than try to block something that he thinks his saber will just sheer off and thus not block in the first place.

Originally posted by Creshosk
The characters have been undergoing alot of changes, the adamantium was removed by magneto some time ago, then when it was put in it was bonded on a molecular level.

Erm...bonded on a molecular level ? Does that mean that you have the adamantium somewhere in the bones ? Well...I think you could still pull it out with the force.


He wouldn't be fast enough to get it all off before he healed back.

Well. I didn't read comics for a long time but I don't think Wolverine is healing that fast. Having Wolverine who can't move Maul could cut pretty much stuff off...

Maul would win and that's that

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Erm...bonded on a molecular level ? Does that mean that you have the adamantium somewhere in the bones ? Well...I think you could still pull it out with the force.
you'd pull the bones with it unless you can seperate the molecules. . .

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
Well. I didn't read comics for a long time but I don't think Wolverine is healing that fast. Having Wolverine who can't move Maul could cut pretty much stuff off...
Haven't read one recently have you?

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
But saber users know lightsabers to cut through anything. It makes more sense that he'd try to cut his claws off rather than try to block something that he thinks his saber will just sheer off and thus not block in the first place.
But that's still the problem, he tries to cut the claws off, fails and is still hit by wolverine.

The saber won't stop the claws, it's like trying to block with a flashlight from the way you have it set up.

Originally posted by Creshosk
But that's still the problem, he tries to cut the claws off, fails and is still hit by wolverine.

The saber won't stop the claws, it's like trying to block with a flashlight from the way you have it set up.


But, hypothetically, if he didn't dodge after cutting off Wolverine's claws he's still get hit. He'd likely do one of those fancy shmancy bullfighter type moves where you attack while dodging.

Either way, Maul isn't going to be counting on his saber to block Wolverine's claws. Or rather, not counting on Wolverine's claws blocking his saber because in his mind he's going to cut through them just like every other metal.

Originally posted by Lord Darkstar
Maul force chokes him, wolfy can't do anything about that

Exactly. Wolverine crudely charges Maul and gets forced choked along the way. It's that simple. Wolverine is way out of his league here.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
But, hypothetically, if he didn't dodge after cutting off Wolverine's claws he's still get hit. He'd likely do one of those fancy shmancy bullfighter type moves where you attack while dodging.

Either way, Maul isn't going to be counting on his saber to block Wolverine's claws. Or rather, not counting on Wolverine's claws blocking his saber because in his mind he's going to cut through them just like every other metal.

And that's where he'd screw up.

It's obviously not goic to block or cut the claws. That's the problem.

Maul wins through the use of the force, not the lightsaber.

Originally posted by Bobafetty
Exactly. Wolverine crudely charges Maul and gets forced choked along the way. It's that simple. Wolverine is way out of his league here.
Thats a better idea than going lightsaber aganst the claws. And that's how he could win.

from what i could tell from these discussions, the lightsaber shouldn't be able to CUT through the attacking adamantium claws, but be able to repell them, as in not just go through them without hurting it in any way. So after a while as Maul realizes all of wolverine's skeleton is protected, he could just force grip wolverine, hold him in the air and stab his lightsaber in wolverine's eye. I'd sure love to see Wolverine heal from that.
And also, if he could, it wouldn't be instant. Please don't confuse wolverine with deadpool mkay? The fight would still be won by Maul, and not JUST by using the force.

~wickerman~

Originally posted by Wickerman
from what i could tell from these discussions, the lightsaber shouldn't be able to CUT through the attacking adamantium claws, but be able to repell them, as in not just go through them without hurting it in any way. So after a while as Maul realizes all of wolverine's skeleton is protected, he could just force grip wolverine, hold him in the air and stab his lightsaber in wolverine's eye. I'd sure love to see Wolverine heal from that.
And also, if he could, it wouldn't be instant. Please don't confuse wolverine with deadpool mkay? The fight would still be won by Maul, and not JUST by using the force.

~wickerman~

If the claws are repealed that means they could block each other.

And why wouldn't it be instant? Wolverine has been healing instantly.

Originally posted by Creshosk
If the claws are repealed that means they could block each other.

And why wouldn't it be instant? Wolverine has been healing instantly.

yeah, they could block each other.
And has he healed instantly from wounds as grave as a lightsaber in his brain??? (i find Marvel comicbook inconsistency FAR greater than SW. I mean they make DP out to have a much quicker regenerative power than Wolverine, but now HE can heal at the same rate?)

~wickerman~

Originally posted by Wickerman
yeah, they could block each other.
And has he healed instantly from wounds as grave as a lightsaber in his brain???
In his brain? 😐

http://www.bio.psu.edu/faculty/strauss/anatomy/skel/pics/Anterior%20Skull%20copy.jpg

If adamantium stops lightsabers then there's only the blace the optioc nerve goes through.

And it's really difficult to knock him out or even give him a concussion, I think he'd heal from a lightsaber to the eye just fine.

Originally posted by Wickerman
(i find Marvel comicbook inconsistency FAR greater than SW. I mean they make DP out to have a much quicker regenerative power than Wolverine, but now HE can heal at the same rate?)

~wickerman~

Spiderman can talk to insects now and has orgainc webbing. . . Yeah they've been upgrading their characters. . . 😕

Originally posted by Creshosk
In his brain? 😐

http://www.bio.psu.edu/faculty/strauss/anatomy/skel/pics/Anterior%20Skull%20copy.jpg

If adamantium stops lightsabers then there's only the blace the optioc nerve goes through.

And it's really difficult to knock him out or even give him a concussion, I think he'd heal from a lightsaber to the eye just fine.

Spiderman can talk to insects now and has orgainc webbing. . . Yeah they've been upgrading their characters. . . 😕

Hmmm...i guess my anatomy skills need retuning 🙁 been proven wrong.
And yeah, i know concussions won't hurt him much. I remember the whole Spiderman bashing his head into a tombstone crap. And yeah, i know bout the organic webbing crap too. But this ain't the right forum for that Bub 😛

~wickerman~

woveine can't use the force!!! one force chopke later Mauls the VIctpr!!!oooo drunk

Just. Cut. The. Spine.

Originally posted by Wickerman
Hmmm...i guess my anatomy skills need retuning 🙁 been proven wrong.
And yeah, i know concussions won't hurt him much. I remember the whole Spiderman bashing his head into a tombstone crap. And yeah, i know bout the organic webbing crap too. But this ain't the right forum for that Bub 😛

~wickerman~

Nah, it's just to show how the characters have been powered up.

Maul wins this because of the Force

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
Just. Cut. The. Spine.
Where? Because I'm still not convinced that would work.