Is KOTOR better than ROTS?

That's a pretty silly statement.

Fact is, there is little of objective quality about the KOTOR plot at all except for its twist which was only really a surprise to people with little experience of plots.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Sorry, absolutely none of KOTOR was a surprise to me. More cliched obviousness. But it was also pretending to be big and clever, which it was not. The twist was also... mundane.

ROTS was exactly what it said it was, and bravo to it.

There are many things to like about KOTOR. I don't even DISlike the plot. It was much better than many computer game plots. But I have never ever seen it as this super-genius thing that people seem to mysteriously say it is. Frankly, not wanting to sound pig-headed, but I've done SW games with much better plots. There's just nothing really fantastic to KOTOR. In fact, Baldur's Gate (from the same studio) had a better plot, as did Planescape: Torment.

Oh yes,I found that plot twist in ESB , how did you put it, "mundane" as well.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
You can restrict them to their plots and compare them, easily. Strip out the gaming of KOTOR and the special effects and acting of ROTS and all you have is a storyline. And I simply do not understand why KOTOR's rather typical plot ssores over ROTS's culmination of twenty five year's work.

You are right KOTOR isn't that great Plot wise

But KOTOR is a much better game than ROTS is a film

Were not arguing the game, were arguing the movie. Let this forum die. Like it almost did and was, drifting on page six in the E3 forum. I resurrected looking for Vader 476 to finish an argument. We made peace, this forum has served its purpose.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Sorry, absolutely none of KOTOR was a surprise to me. More cliched obviousness. But it was also pretending to be big and clever, which it was not. The twist was also... mundane.

ROTS was exactly what it said it was, and bravo to it.

There are many things to like about KOTOR. I don't even DISlike the plot. It was much better than many computer game plots. But I have never ever seen it as this super-genius thing that people seem to mysteriously say it is. Frankly, not wanting to sound pig-headed, but I've done SW games with much better plots. There's just nothing really fantastic to KOTOR. In fact, Baldur's Gate (from the same studio) had a better plot, as did Planescape: Torment.

WHAT?! what is better twist than (Just you aren't this far in the game. I don't like spoiling things for people.)

Spoiler:
YOU ARE REVAN?

Originally posted by Nactous
Were not arguing the game, were arguing the movie. Let this forum die. Like it almost did and was, drifting on page six in the E3 forum. I resurrected looking for Vader 476 to finish an argument. We made peace, this forum has served its purpose.

I agree

Originally posted by Nactous
Star Wars is not just limited to the movies, and anyone that thanks it is, is nothing more than a fool.

THANK YOU! 💃

Your welcome.

Lookie what I found. It brings tears to my eyes. The thread is the reason I joined KMC.

Wow, that was worth they effort of typing.

Yes, yes it was.

No no, THIS was.

Do you know what they call a Quarter-pounder with Cheese, in France?

Thats alitlle of topic.

As a game...most definately yes...kotor is better

Yeah the ROTS game was just..................blase.

Why are SW games (most of the time) Average!! it's not like they don't have funds!!

They don't wanna get our hopes up.

But KotOR is different.

sure is!!

No, I got my hopes up on that game...major disappointment.