Who would win in a fight: Legolas or Aragorn?

This is just a forum to see which one of the two "greatest" warriors in Middle-Earth would win in a battle against each other, even though they would never have one. Give the name and the reason why they would win.

We all love them both, but which one is the superior warrior.

My vote goes to. . . .

LEGOLAS!

He has more weaponry and more of a skill than Aragorn.
He's better with a bow, MUCH better, and he has 2 knives to circulate around and get anyone.

What do you think?

Well...of course everyones gonna say Legolas beacuse all girl LOTR fans love him....defiantly Aragorn though😉

i had have to say: there's already a thread like this ... 😐

lol!

legolas because he has more experiance and is far more nimble and could just pick of aragorn long raange with his bow.

aragorn has already deflected arrows with his sword and knife.

and where legolas has speed and nimbleness....aragorn has brute strength and a will of steel

but i digress

...and a chin to die for 😉

and he gets the girl 😱

although Legolas gets the girls.

and on the subject, what experience does Legolas have? That an 80 year old ranger doesnt?

actually when you think about it...not much really

i mean, leggy has been around a lot longer, but i'm sure that eveything he's ever done so has aragorn

hm...i wonder if legolas ever gets bored of the same things day in and day out?

I dont think legolas is too old, why he was sent on behalf of elves is beyond me.

I mean think about it, your in Rivendell holding a counsel and need a strong and capable elf, so they sent Legolas. Its not like he was their only choice being in a huge elf settlement.

Originally posted by Fëanor
i had have to say: there's already a thread like this ... 😐

Originally posted by The Inkeeper
I dont think legolas is too old, why he was sent on behalf of elves is beyond me.

I mean think about it, your in Rivendell holding a counsel and need a strong and capable elf, so they sent Legolas. Its not like he was their only choice being in a huge elf settlement.

actually legolas is something like 4 or 5 thousand years old and the son of the king of mirkwood.

Why would legolas and aragorn be fighting?

*is purposely being annoying*😖
😛

Originally posted by Dresta
actually legolas is something like 4 or 5 thousand years old and the son of the king of mirkwood.

I am aware of his princehood, but he is not 4 or 5 thousand years old.

If you can find me proof, solid proof from Tolkien himself, that states otherwise, then show me 🙂

And being the son of a king does not make you immedietely an amazing warrior, as orlando proved faultlessly in Troy.

Originally posted by The Inkeeper
And being the son of a king does not make you immedietely an amazing warrior, as orlando proved faultlessly in Troy.

Good example.

no...i doubt he's that old, as there was another legolas in gondolin, i think

unfortunately it was tolkien who wrote him in as to be a part of the nine...

trust me he is several thousand years old and a powerful elf warrior. and the innkeeper how the hell do you know that he isn't. you do know that elfs are immortal don't you

Yes i am also aware elves are immortal, unless killed in battle or by grief.

Legolas is not, and i stress that word, several thousand years old, until you can prove it (which you can not because Legolas' age is never given) i will continue to not believe you.