Who would win in a fight: Legolas or Aragorn?

There is alot more to suggest me, Exa and Shad are right 😊

Mostly because Exa and Shad say it is so.

But ok, end the argument.

you had to make that last comment didn't you. 🙄

Yes, your new so you havent yet realised that i always get the last word 😊

Its what i pride myself on.

i hate it when people do that

And I hate it when people pop up suddenly and conveniently act as if nobody else in the forum has read the book and thus know nothing of what they're talking about.

shadowy blue you don't know that your're right so shut your mouth

Originally posted by Dresta
shadowy blue you don't know that your're right so shut your mouth

Where's Smod to defend his girl's honour? 😛

Shadowy_Blue, unlike you, Dresta, has actually given some context to her theory and her belief.

You seem to just blindly believe she's wrong.

Originally posted by Dresta
shadowy blue you don't know that your're right so shut your mouth

Shut my mouth? I won't. And not a guy like you can make me.

Originally posted by Dresta
shadowy blue you don't know that your're right so shut your mouth

but to end it in such a manner is rather sophomoric and unnecessary, truth be told i've enjoyed both sides of view points...

we can all agree to disagree, but let us not stoop to such base levels as that

well said Fea!!

Originally posted by Dresta
actually legolas is something like 4 or 5 thousand years old and the son of the king of mirkwood.

2931, just to be exact

Originally posted by Fëanor
dude....to be fair - the debate so far has been good and refreshing since we've not had one since the summer of last year

but to end it in such a manner is rather sophomoric and unnecessary, truth be told i've enjoyed both sides of view points...

we can all agree to disagree, but let us not stoop to such base levels as that

what made me say that was the unnesessary comment before that from shadowy blue there was no need to flame me. also i was wrong when i said that Legolas was 4 or 5 thousand years old. i beleive that he was born sometime in the early third age and is probobly 2-3 thousand years old.

Originally posted by Murray
2931, just to be exact

Originally posted by Exabyte
As for the age, no, Tolkien never officially stated how old Legolas was. The movie makers defined his year of birth as 87 TA as Bloom mentioned in an interview; this would make him 2931 years old during the War of the Ring. This number is now widely accepted as 'true' among movie fans although it's pure fanfiction.

Are you serious with this question? Aragorn would wipe the floor with Legolas. Aragorn was probally the 3 best fighter in the 3rd age. Glorfindel being first, elladen and elohir being second, and Aragorn 3rd. I mean this question is insane, a wood elf vs a Dunedain raised by a Noldor elf. Aragorn Massacres Legolas.

Originally posted by Dresta
i hate it when people do that

Shame, but i will still get the last word 😊

Thats what i do baby.

Originally posted by Dresta
what made me say that was the unnesessary comment before that from shadowy blue there was no need to flame me.

Just to clarify, I never believed you one bit when you said that Legolas must be 4 or 5 thousand years old, or for this matter, 2 to 3 thousand (I still don't believe it though), so I politely tried to present the more plausible possibility by posting a link that explains everything. Then you kept insisting that Legolas must be old because he felt young in Fangorn Forest, then again, I tried to explain why that must have been. Then you started being all arrogant and rude implying that I obviously have absolutely no idea of what I was talking about because I messed up with one of my info. 🙄 Then I started to post more textual clues, and challenged you to present any of yours, which you never did.

Moreover, might I say that you've been arrogant and insistent from the get go, acting as if a member such as The Inkeeper who is (or was) an avid LotR fan wouldn't know that Legolas is immortal, not to mention that you were almost questioning his knowledge at just about anything. (Seriously, even a movie fan who hasn't read the book would know that Elves are immortal. 🙄 )

I know that I'm not right, and I never claimed to be, because we have no way of knowing what Legolas' exact age is. If I ever sounded rude or arrogant in any of my posts, it was a reaction to YOUR own attitude and the implications of your actions. If you got bugged by The Inkeeper's rubbing in of the fact that you're new, I'd bet that he did that because he's kinda annoyed at you too (correct me Chris if I'm wrong). We're not always rude here, in case you're wondering.

In short, I didn't initially mean to be rude towards anyone here. It's not like at the first sight of this thread, I immediately thought, "Hey, I'll post here, then crap on Dresta later!" 😱

🙄

I'm generally nice, but I can be a hell of an assh0le if provoked.

I just think your a hell of an ******* in general 😉

Nah im just kidding darlin'.

But yet again, i need to remind you all, i have the last word 😛

Originally posted by shadowy_blue
My comment was probably unnecessary, in such a way that your "you had to make that last comment, didn't you" (even though I'm sure that Chris was only trying to easen up things here and restore the peace) comment was unnecessary, but nowhere in my post did I say I was right. So it was rather funny when you suddenly started to put words into my mouth implying that I ever claimed that I was. I have no idea where you even got that from the one sentence post I made. I was just stating my opinion regarding some of the "I've-read-the-book-and-I-bet-you-didn't-so-you-must-have-no-idea-what-you're-talking-about" attitude of some of the newly pop up members here. (in case you're wondering, almost all of them are gone.) Now, don't you try to put words into my mouth again and accuse me of ever saying that you should leave too. I never said that. I'm just assuming you might imply such. 🙄

Just to clarify, I never believed you one bit when you said that Legolas must be 4 or 5 thousand years old, or for this matter, 2 to 3 thousand (I still don't believe it though), so I politely tried to present the more plausible possibility by posting a link that explains everything. Then you kept insisting that Legolas must be old because he felt young in Fangorn Forest, then again, I tried to explain why that must have been. Then you started being all arrogant and rude implying that I obviously have absolutely no idea of what I was talking about because I messed up with one of my info. 🙄 Then I started to post more textual clues, and challenged you to present any of yours, which you never did.

Moreover, might I say that you've been arrogant and insistent from the get go, acting as if a member such as [b]The Inkeeper who is (or was) an avid LotR fan wouldn't know that Legolas is immortal, not to mention that you were almost questioning his knowledge at just about anything. (Seriously, even a movie fan who hasn't read the book would know that Elves are immortal. 🙄 )

I know that I'm not right, and I never claimed to be, because we have no way of knowing what Legolas' exact age is. If I ever sounded rude or arrogant in any of my posts, it was a reaction to YOUR own attitude and the implications of your actions. If you got bugged by The Inkeeper's rubbing in of the fact that you're new, I'd bet that he did that because he's kinda annoyed at you too (correct me Chris if I'm wrong). We're not always rude here, in case you're wondering.

In short, I didn't initially mean to be rude towards anyone here. It's not like at the first sight of this thread, I immediately thought, "Hey, I'll post here, then crap on Dresta later!" 😱

🙄

I'm generally nice, but I can be a hell of an assh0le if provoked. [/B]

ok sorry if i annoyed you

*is dissappointed that she missed a debate*

Originally posted by Dresta
ok sorry if i annoyed you

LOL, j/k 😛

It's OK. 🙂 And re-reading my post...damn, I can't believe I wrote all those! 😱

I'm not sure whether to laugh or cry. 😐

Anyway, I'm sorry too if I was very rude or if I hurt you in anyway. 🙂

*let's Chris have the last word* 😛