Yo - Illadelph! For once I agree with one of your posts lol! 😄
Yeah - PC has the power to knock Surfer's socks off.
But KNite can still do the job, if the Surfer has the chance to pull it off.
Again, like a lot of fights, it depends on whether Supes has his thinking cap on.
If he doesn't and he stands there, then he's gonna be suffering.
Originally posted by ZephroCarnelian
lol - too true.But since when was PC well written? 😉
Nah - if he used all of his powers, he physically couldn't lose any fight.
How do you fight someone you can't touch, can't harm, can travel through time and move many thousands of times faster than light lol?
Seriously Zeph to read a good pre crisi story hunt this up as a starting point
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/graphic_novels/new_graphic_novel1118.htm
its superb there were lots of others as well but this is a good starting point.
It's entirely possible for Supes to pull of a win here, but I don't see him taking the majoritybarring PIS. I know that PC Supes had virtually every power in existence at one point in time, but Surfer's not really outclassed in that respect because his power cosmic has the ability to simulate just aboutany power(and has at one point in time or another. Aside from that Surfer has the ability to simulate BOTH of PC Supermans weaknesses. I would give it to Supes 10/10 if it happend in a comic, but using the forum rules I would only give him 3 or 4 out of 10.
Originally posted by darthgoober
It's entirely possible for Supes to pull of a win here, but I don't see him taking the majoritybarring PIS. I know that PC Supes had virtually every power in existence at one point in time, but Surfer's not really outclassed in that respect because his power cosmic has the ability to simulate just aboutany power(and has at one point in time or another. Aside from that Surfer has the ability to simulate BOTH of PC Supermans weaknesses. I would give it to Supes 10/10 if it happend in a comic, but using the forum rules I would only give him 3 or 4 out of 10.
Nah. Pre-C Superman was just all around more uber than Surfer. He'd make Norrin wish he never became SS.
I agree that he would beat Supes if he can hit him with that energy...that is the key point. If Supes' has his game face on...then, SS would be hard pressed to hit him with anything. He could hit current Supes' with little problems....but, i just don't see him hitting pre-crisis supes' without a lot of luck. It's been said that pre-crisis could juggle planets or sneeze galaxies away...that's really far more than a highfather on earth could pull off in today's comics. I'm sure Supes' could throw planet sized asteroids at SS at faster than light speeds...and surfer would have to dodge all of that. Surfer would be lucky to have enough time to simulate those blasts and aim them directly at superman. As fast as Supes is...he could literally appear out of know where and punch surfer off of his board.
After thinking about it some more...i think Surfer would take a majority against post-crisis supes'...i don't think he would take all of them. Against pre-crisis....only luck would allow SS to win, imo....pre-crisis was just too overpowered
Originally posted by charlemagne9746
lol...yeah, i see ya. The majority on this thread have voted for pre-crisis supes'...given that he doesn't give SS the chance to use the kryptonite energy frequencies
Assuming that Supes is actually faster than Surfer(and I for one would consider that a stretch), I seriously doubt that the difference would be so drastic that Surfer couldn't handle it. Remember when you and I started, we were talking PC Supes and CURRENT Surfer(who has been upgraded). Surfer would have no problem responding to Supes attacks, all the while blasting away with red sunlight out of his eye's, And as bad as he was, there's no way that Supes can punch away on Surfer, and manage to dodge Surfer's red sun eyebeams from point blank.