Thor vs. Hulk

Originally posted by Accel
It doesn't bother me that Hulk was killed, just that he was killed in THAT way.

We've seen Juggernaut feel physical pain before.
We've seen Thor have trouble holding up a sky scraper before.
We've seen Gladiator amped with the uni-power take two whole minutes to fly halfway around the world.
We've seen Thor knocked down by a firehose.
We've seen Kyle Rayner have his ring easily pulled off by Batman.

What do all of these scenarios have in common? Not only are they all low showings, but they contradict each character's consistent showings.

I'm aware that Hulk was killed. If the writer states so, there's no denying it. However, that doesn't mean it SHOULD have happened (at least not like that).Possibly, the writer wasn't aware of Hulk's history with his healing factor, or something.

The difference between those and Hulk's death is that is was never stated by Marvel that Hulk is immortal, while it was well within those other characters power sets to easily accomplish those feats. Marvel has never stated that Hulk couldn't be killed, it is you that believes that.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
The difference between those and Hulk's death is that is was never stated by Marvel that Hulk is immortal, while it was well within those other characters power sets to easily accomplish those feats. Marvel has never stated that Hulk couldn't be killed, it is you that believes that.

He's not immortal. He just has a very effective healing factor. His healing feats back this up. Unless Thor negated that factor, Hulk should have healed just fine form the beating Thor gave him.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
The odinforce was being blocked when he fought Hulk, so it was basically Classic Thor with one arm vs Hulk and Thing.

Thor can do much more than use the god blast, summon lightning, and stop time. He can create and use anti matter, paralyze people, absorb other gods mystical energy, shrink people, create null bombs, etc. Thor has a lot of things he can do with Mjolnir that he often time doesn't do.

Strange is Strange, but I'd like to see teh scans saying it will restrict his powers to Classic levels if you don't mind.

Originally posted by Dalak
Strange is Strange, but I'd like to see teh scans saying it will restrict his powers to Classic levels if you don't mind.

It was not Strange but rather the other skyfathers who blocked Thor from the Odin Force using an amulet. Strange was simply the courier who slipped it onto Thor while Thor was distracted. He did not seem to even know that he had the amulet on, only that the Odin Power was gone.

Originally posted by aliveinboston
It was not Strange but rather the other skyfathers who blocked Thor from the Odin Force using an amulet. Strange was simply the courier who slipped it onto Thor while Thor was distracted. He did not seem to even know that he had the amulet on, only that the Odin Power was gone.

I'd still like to see scans

Originally posted by Dalak
I'd still like to see scans

I have them

Originally posted by Soujaboy
I have them

So I have to wait for them after I already asked for them?

Thier in the Thor respect thread, about 3 pages back. Its just a page ot two befor Thor whoops hulk and the thing oh and cap.

Originally posted by MJOILNIR
Thier in the Thor respect thread, about 3 pages back. Its just a page ot two befor Thor whoops hulk and the thing oh and cap.

The info on teh necklace is or the fight? THe fight I don't need to see. SInce whatever happened to put Hulk on the ground happened offscreen it can't be said how he was 'killed', because I'm sure that anyone can agree a Tree is not capable of doing it.

http://img107.imageshack.us/my.php?image=page0164hx.jpg
As you can see, thor says "no mortal can do this" and strange replies "no but the council elite pantheon of earth can"

Originally posted by MJOILNIR
http://img107.imageshack.us/my.php?image=page0164hx.jpg
As you can see, thor says "no mortal can do this" and strange replies "no but the council elite pantheon of earth can"

Wait a second, THor gouged his eyes out and needed the Odinforce to see right? He wasn't blind in that fight from what I saw.

Didnt look blind did he 😖hifty: I bet cap thought he could use his eyes to 😆

Ha ha! 😐

http://img107.imageshack.us/my.php?image=page0203wn.jpg

So is it a consensus that "The Blind Shall See" RKT even when restricted from the Odinforce isn't the same as El Classico?

Originally posted by Dalak
Wait a second, THor gouged his eyes out and needed the Odinforce to see right? He wasn't blind in that fight from what I saw.

That's because that was just King Thor, before giving up both eyes for the wisdom of the runes - becoming Rune King Thor.

Originally posted by roughrider
That's because that was just King Thor, before giving up both eyes for the wisdom of the runes - becoming Rune King Thor.

THor had 2 arms when he gouged his eyes out, so how does that work?

Originally posted by Dalak
THor had 2 arms when he gouged his eyes out, so how does that work?

Originally posted by Big Sexy
Thats because the events of that comic were reversed which is kinda why Wolverine, Hulk, Strange,and Thing are not dead now.

It seems strange to me looking at an apparent Scar on the scan with teh necklace.

Originally posted by Dalak
THor had 2 arms when he gouged his eyes out, so how does that work?

The climax of the lengthy "The Ruling" storyline, had him killing Deask in the Destroyer armour, and using Zarkko's time-travel tech to go back to his past self when he became King, warning him not to do his mistakes with ruling Earth and such. So with that, that version of Thor would ceast to exist, and the present Thor would not get into the confrontation that led him to lose an arm in the fight against the heroes. This Thor goes on to become Rune King Thor.