If God were to tell you to, would you fly an airplane into a building?

Started by RedAlertv219 pages

"God is something you will never find absolute proof of"

If God appeared and told me to do something radical, that would be proof enough for me. But now that I think about it, isnt murder an unforgivable sin? I might think twice about flying a plane into a building.

Originally posted by RedAlertv2
"God is something you will never find absolute proof of"

If God appeared and told me to do something radical, that would be proof enough for me. But now that I think about it, isnt murder an unforgivable sin? I might think twice about flying a plane into a building.

As long as you think, and do not have blind faith, you will do fine in life. But to do better requires a leap of faith. Blind faith is turning on the light and even though the light does not come on, you still believe the light is on. A leap of faith is knowing the light will come on before you flip the switch. If the light doesn't come on, then you know that it's dark.

Originally posted by RedAlertv2
Back on topic, I would fly a plane into a building if told to do so by God. My reasoning: If God tells me to do something, that means that I would have proof that God existed. Which means that if I filled his wishes I would probably go to heaven.

Let us presume that God has revealed His existence to you. How can you be sure His asking you to fly a plane into a building is not a test? Perhaps He does not want you to fly a plane into a building and by doing it, you will have failed.

Re: Re: Re: If God were to tell you to, would you fly an airplane into a building?

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
The question is designed to challenge you. So, put aside all doubt, God himself, told you directly, and clearly.

I want you to think about what it means to have a 'servant, master relationship with a omnipotent being'.

I do not have that kind of relationship with God. I am God, the down side to this is, so are you.

And yes, it is a good and challanging question, my reason for saying no is because god wants us to say no sometimes, he doesn't want us to act like zombies to his every tiny command nomatter what size it is, aslong as you know he's there.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
Let us presume that God has revealed His existence to you. How can you be sure His asking you to fly a plane into a building is not a test? Perhaps He does not want you to fly a plane into a building and by doing it, you will have failed.

That's sort of my point.

Hi Evil Dead

What does this have to do with this thread? I think you are off topic, please return to the correct topic. If God were to tell you to, would you fly an airplane into a building?

sorry......I got off a bit there. I just dislike it very much when we're discussing a topic and somebody gets off on another subject......and is actually wrong on the entire premise of the subject. If a person has the balls to switch the topic of discussion........a person should atleast be correct or know a little about the subject they are switching to.

Yes, I'd fly a plane into a building in a heartbeat. If a being could prove to me that they were the cause of all existence..........they created the universe and everything in it........I would do anything they ask. It's quite a feat to not only create an entire universe but to do so and keep it running for billions of years like clockwork.....down to the most miniscule details like insect populations affecting ecosystems on one small planet out of millions. Who am I to argue with it's logic, wisdom or wishes? I can't even keep up with my bills.......making sure they're all in the mail by the correct date to make sure they are all recieved on time.

Originally posted by Evil Dead
sorry......I got off a bit there. I just dislike it very much when we're discussing a topic and somebody gets off on another subject......and is actually wrong on the entire premise of the subject. If a person has the balls to switch the topic of discussion........a person should atleast be correct or know a little about the subject they are switching to.

Yes, I'd fly a plane into a building in a heartbeat. If a being could prove to me that they were the cause of all existence..........they created the universe and everything in it........I would do anything they ask. It's quite a feat to not only create an entire universe but to do so and keep it running for billions of years like clockwork.....down to the most miniscule details like insect populations affecting ecosystems on one small planet out of millions. Who am I to argue with it's logic, wisdom or wishes? I can't even keep up with my bills.......making sure they're all in the mail by the correct date to make sure they are all recieved on time.

Thank you for getting back on topic! I understand your frustration; I'm watching this thread closely and I even tried to help, but some people don't want to listen.

If I had a free will I would probably say...**** NO....well right after I am done cursing myself for going to hell.....

Originally posted by Bardock42
If I had a free will I would probably say...**** NO....well right after I am done cursing myself for going to hell.....

Hi Bardock42

Nice to see you post here. I guess you will have good company in hell.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
Hi Bardock42

Nice to see you post here. I guess you will have good company in hell.

MNaybe.. I read Dante....lots of good people down there....I just don't want to go to deep ..... getting tortured is not my kind of thing.....

Originally posted by Bardock42
MNaybe.. I read Dante....lots of good people down there....I just don't want to go to deep ..... getting tortured is not my kind of thing.....

Oh tht silly Dante....look what he's done.....

I have open communication with God/Spirit or what ever you want to call it SINCE I've left my former faith......I get replies...honeltly....

God assists you in making clear your choices not forcing anyone INTO A CHOICE...

Originally posted by debbiejo
Oh tht silly Dante....look what he's done.....

I have open communication with God/Spirit or what ever you want to call it SINCE I've left my former faith......I get replies...honeltly....

God assists you in making clear your choices not forcing anyone INTO A CHOICE...

Sure you do...........and sure he does......and.....actully just 😐

Originally posted by Bardock42
Sure you do...........and sure he does......and.....actully just 😐

I thought everybody heard voices.... 🙄

You're just not listening.........

I here alot of voices, some sound like bill Clinton, while some sound like Eddie Murphy.

no, i would not, i don't think any god would want you to kill his people

nope, God would never do that.

Originally posted by AngelGirl
no, i would not, i don't think any god would want you to kill his people

Good for you AngelGirl.

The rest of you who said yes, should be listening to her.

No, I would tell god to go screw himself and he is a crazy self indulged lunatic who wants me to kill myself and others for him.

Originally posted by JimMorrison227
No, I would tell god to go screw himself and he is a crazy self indulged lunatic who wants me to kill myself and others for him.

Hi JimMorrison227

"If God were to tell you to, would you fly an airplane into a building?"

Do you understand why I asked this question?

I don't think it is a good idea to say that because god is listening to every word we say.

Originally posted by cking
I don't think it is a good idea to say that because god is listening to every word we say.

He listens to every thought, too. ...Oops.

Does God really care if you insult Him? If an ant insulted me, I am afraid I would not be offended. Especially if I created the ant and had the power to snuff out its life with a single thought.

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
Good for you AngelGirl.

The rest of you who said yes, should be listening to her.


Thank you for referring me to the voice of God. AngelGirl's wisdom clearly transcends God's and she obviously has a better grasp of all things biblical.