Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince - Book 2005

He's good! *twitch.* Good I tell you! Good!... has anyone notice in the pictures in the book he doesn't look a thing like he does in the movies....

yes, and I agree with you one hundred percent about Snape being good.

^ you people are MAD mad i tell you

Snape is bad, coz he killed DD, wether it was planned or not, I don't care! crybaby

Whose says being mad is a bad thing? All because Snape killed DD doesn't mean he's bad!!!!!!!!!!

yea it does, and we're not gonna find out for anouther 2 years coz JK is a very slow writer

^ way too slow 🙁

And we we find out,I'll celebrate if I was right about Snape.

i thinks snapes is bad, cos if he wasnt he wouldnt kill anyone...

i realised something, it could be nothing, im prob lookin to closely at everything but dumbledore says hes going for a drink to rosemerta, and he does kinda have a drink...the potion, in the cave.
also i cant forget that twinkle in his eye at the end of gof...i wanna know more about dumbledore.

Snape is not bad!!! As much as I hate defending this character, I have to say that he was following DD's orders, so he was doing what he was told.

snape is evil, i wonder if he might turn good in 7th book. would'nt put it past jk

GOOD! GOOD! GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!

Snape wasn't following DD orders. he just plain killed him.

He's been good since he went for the job as Defense Against the Dark Arts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by Maikahyandowen
Snape wasn't following DD orders. he just plain killed him.

GOOOOOOD! *twitch*

how is Snape good?

.... We've said it so many times......

what, the DADA job?

No, read before and on other threads. I'm tired of it.