The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)
Spoilers perhaps!.............................................................................................. Ok in one of J.K Rowlings interviews posted on this site, she says that there is a horcrux that no one knows about. She says if you re-read the book you might figure it out. I was thinking, could the horcrux be harry's scar?
I was thinking this also...something to do with Harry....who better to make a Horcrux into than the one who is supposedly destined to destroy you?
It'd tie together the parts with Harry sharing visions with not only Voldemort, but also Nagini (if Nagini turns out to be a Horcrux too).
I havent read that book for ages, did they ever explain why Harry had a connection with the snake?
But anyways, theres enough to put together for a valid argument having Harry as a Horcrux.
(Could the first post be edited a bit so the page isnt so wide?)
Originally posted by NightCrawler341this is all very confusing.
But also kind of stupid because, and i really can see this, Voldemort would know that Harry would kill himself, leaving that Horcrux easy to destory. Besides, hasn't Voldemort been trying to kill Harry?
Originally posted by NightCrawler341I agree on that one though
Snape good, Harry not horcrux because he would have to destroy himself before destroying Moldy Voldy.... ain't happenin'.
Originally posted by Fwiw187
I totally agree with you guys... that is what i was think also.... now, is snape good or bad.. i THink good
Go find another thread for that.
Originally posted by NightCrawler341
But also kind of stupid because, and i really can see this, Voldemort would know that Harry would kill himself, leaving that Horcrux easy to destory. Besides, hasn't Voldemort been trying to kill Harry?
Maybe Voldemort doesnt know? He didnt know some of his powers transferred to Harry, maybe he became a Horcrux somehow?
Or maybe he does know, and Harry became a Horcrux accidentally or something, and Voldemort is trying to kill Harry to remove that Horcrux because its too dangerous to leave it inside the person whos trying to destroy you?
Okay, so if Harry was one of the horcruxes, then was was the Dark Lord trying to kill him in the first book, the second book, the fourth, and the fifth??? Why would he kill someone that as his soul in??? I believe Snape is good, he was only acting on Dumbledore's orders. He said something like he didn't want to and Dumbledore said that he must or something like that. I don't remember clearly.
well I think harry's scar is the horcrux. The fact that voldemort tried to kill him so many times is because he knew ultimately he couldn't lose. If potter beat him, he'd still have the other horcruxes. It wouldn't matter if Potter beat him. It's a win-win situation for voldemort. I think he really does know that it will ultimately come down to Harry vs Voldemort to the death, and he has the advantage. The only was that voldemort can die is if harry and ALL THE horcruxes are destroyed. Not just harry.
Originally posted by Saratn
Okay, so if Harry was one of the horcruxes, then was was the Dark Lord trying to kill him in the first book, the second book, the fourth, and the fifth??? Why would he kill someone that as his soul in??? I believe Snape is good, he was only acting on Dumbledore's orders. He said something like he didn't want to and Dumbledore said that he must or something like that. I don't remember clearly.
Perhaps it was an accident? He sure as hell didnt mean to give Harry some of his powers when he gave him the scar, maybe he also transferred his soul.
He'd try and kill Harry anyway, maybe he doesnt know Harry could be part of his soul.
Originally posted by IceWithin
I think it's very possible... I would've never guessed myself though, great thinking LordYomi.
I really hope not though.
Exactly, I think its possible but I hope not. It'd be a good twist and climax though, you gotta give it that...
It'd be worthy of comparing to the Vader/Luke scene, thats for sure..
Neville isn't the one that Voldemort marked as his equal, it was Harry. So Harry has to be the one who has to kill him, not Neville. Plus Voldemort would get weaker for each horcrux he loses, that's why Dumbledore was trying to get them. If he doesn't have any of them, then he will be able to die like any mortal person.
I posted this on another thread...what about the potential that Harry was
originally a horcrux but had to be used to bring voldy back at the end of
GoF. I mean, Harry was needed to restore voldy back to life. And there
hasn't been as big of a connection after that. Other than voldemort
trying to read Harry's thoughts.
Harry is not a Horcrux. Here are the reasons why.
1. You have to perform a spell to make somebody/thing a horcrux.
2. The only spell Voldemort did that night is Avada Kedavra.
3. I know this because the killing curse rebounded and hit Voldemort. So he was too weak to perform any spell. Especially a tough one.
4. And he has never performed any wierd spell on Harry since he came back.
So Harry is not a horcrux.