Originally posted by DanZeke25Agree.
Harry is not a Horcrux. Here are the reasons why.1. You have to perform a spell to make somebody/thing a horcrux.
2. The only spell Voldemort did that night is Avada Kedavra.
3. I know this because the killing curse rebounded and hit Voldemort. So he was too weak to perform any spell. Especially a tough one.
4. And he has never performed any wierd spell on Harry since he came back.So Harry is not a horcrux.
I don't agree. Where is the exact proof that Voldemort ONLY used the killing curse on Harry? If he chose Harry to be his only "competition" I know I would plant a horcrux on him. And if it's not a horcrux, just what IS the scar then? Do you know trio of fire? No one can say that Voldemort is an idiot, he is extremely smart. So smart as to put his own soul into Harry. Perhaps Harry is the first human horcrux! and the side-effects were the ability to take on some of voldemorts traits! Lightning-Struck Tower....Lightning Struck Forehead!
Originally posted by LordYomi13You got to remember that Voldemort didn't know the whole prophecy either. I'm not the one to decide what the scar is.. because, well, I can't think of anything at the moment and I will let the other two choose. (Cool Kurama sig.)
I don't agree. Where is the exact proof that Voldemort ONLY used the killing curse on Harry? If he chose Harry to be his only "competition" I know I would plant a horcrux on him. And if it's not a horcrux, just what IS the scar then? Do you know trio of fire? No one can say that Voldemort is an idiot, he is extremely smart. So smart as to put his own soul into Harry. Perhaps Harry is the first human horcrux! and the side-effects were the ability to take on some of voldemorts traits! Lightning-Struck Tower....Lightning Struck Forehead!
Originally posted by LordYomi13But would it really matter? I mean, hell, we all know that Harry would kill himself then... I think Moldy Voldy would know that too.
Well perhaps he did. Or perhaps he took that chance and understood that his equal might one day surpass him.
Originally posted by LordYomi13Followed the clues.
and you were pretty right on with the Harry and Ginny thing
Originally posted by LordYomi13
Spoilers perhaps!................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ Ok in one of J.K Rowlings interviews posted on this site, she says that there is a horcrux that no one knows about. She says if you re-read the book you might figure it out. I was thinking, could the horcrux be harry's scar?
When were the Horcrux's made exactly? Because Voldemort made the diary one when he was at school, (before he became weak, bcoz he gave it too Malfoy). And the Goblet and the other item when he stole them.
The only opportunity he would have had to turn Harry into one would have been at the very beginning when he gave him the scar. Because Harry was not born before then. And at the point he was too weak to perform the spell and divide his soul, as trying to kill Harry drained him.
An explanation for that could be that by trying to kill him, Voldemort fulfilled the prophecy and that means the spell he thought was going to kill Harry actually made him a Horcrux. Then it could be explained that is why he was drained of all power, because he had just split his soul for about the 7th time. Also the transference of powers to Harry could be explained by Harry gaining part of Voldy's soul. The diary held Voldemort's memory to be unleashed again. So it may be understandable that part of Voldemort went into Harry, just as it did the diary.
It is all very confusing, I just can't believe we have to wait sooooooo long..
Originally posted by LordYomi13
I don't agree. Where is the exact proof that Voldemort ONLY used the killing curse on Harry? If he chose Harry to be his only "competition" I know I would plant a horcrux on him. And if it's not a horcrux, just what IS the scar then? Do you know trio of fire? No one can say that Voldemort is an idiot, he is extremely smart. So smart as to put his own soul into Harry. Perhaps Harry is the first human horcrux! and the side-effects were the ability to take on some of voldemorts traits! Lightning-Struck Tower....Lightning Struck Forehead!
If Voldemort put a Horcrux in Harry, Then why would he try to kill him right after he put a Horcrux in him? He couldnt have done it after because the curse rebounded and hit him. He was too weak to do it.
I'm telling you. I would bet that Harry isnt a horcrux,
Originally posted by Saratn
Okay, so if Harry was one of the horcruxes, then was was the Dark Lord trying to kill him in the first book, the second book, the fourth, and the fifth??? Why would he kill someone that as his soul in??? I believe Snape is good, he was only acting on Dumbledore's orders. He said something like he didn't want to and Dumbledore said that he must or something like that. I don't remember clearly.
Well theres actually a reasonable excuse for Voldemort trying to kill harry. Its actually pretty brilliant really, think about it. Voldemort gets killed by Harry, Harry doesnt kill himself, therefore Voldermorts still around. But, now heres the brilliant part, Voldermort kills Harry, he loses a Horcrux yes, oh well, now hes completely immortal. No one can kill him due to the prophecy. Now Voldemort rules the world. Get it?
does anyone remember in the book when harry and dumbledore are usin the pensiecve to revisit the memorys from voldys past ...they come to the one where voldemort returns to hogwarts for a teaching position...although im not so sure because in one of jks interviews she mentions tht theres more to the hat than what we know...i think tht the sorting hat may be a horcrux it would have been easy for voldy to put part of his soul into the hat