Originally posted by APIECEOFME
Seriously people...don't you think that it is reaching a little to say that Harry is a horcrux? I don't even understand how this debate is still going on. It makes no sense. I've said it before, Harry would have to kill himself before Voldemort was able to be killed.
Why would Harry need to kill himself first? After he destroys the rest of them, and kills Voldemort, Voldemort is only living by the piece of his soul inside of Harry. Now Harry is able to die (presumably) by anyone. He has someone shoot a Killing Curse at him, bam hes dead, and the part of Voldemorts souls dead.
Yeah you guys are kinda confused on that. Harry doesnt HAVE to kill all the Horcruxes before he kills Voldemort. DUmbledore just said that it would be easier. For example, Harry kills Voldemort, but still has two Horcruxes left. It ,ight take Harry a year to find them, which gives Voldemort enough time to come back. Now say Harry is a Horcrux, and he's destroyed all the rest of the Horcruxes. He killed voldemort and then kills himself. There is no way Voldemort could come back within a matter of seconds.
But Harry isnt a Horcrux anyway.
Originally posted by DanZeke25
Yeah you guys are kinda confused on that. Harry doesnt HAVE to kill all the Horcruxes before he kills Voldemort. DUmbledore just said that it would be easier. For example, Harry kills Voldemort, but still has two Horcruxes left. It ,ight take Harry a year to find them, which gives Voldemort enough time to come back. Now say Harry is a Horcrux, and he's destroyed all the rest of the Horcruxes. He killed voldemort and then kills himself. There is no way Voldemort could come back within a matter of seconds.But Harry isnt a Horcrux anyway.
Exactly what I meant, and how I feel. Cheers Zeke
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
Why would Harry need to kill himself first? After he destroys the rest of them, and kills Voldemort, Voldemort is only living by the piece of his soul inside of Harry. Now Harry is able to die (presumably) by anyone. He has someone shoot a Killing Curse at him, bam hes dead, and the part of Voldemorts souls dead.
Originally posted by APIECEOFME
There were 6 horcruxes out in the world. But the seventh is in Voldemort's body. In the chapter "Horcruxes", DD says "The seventh piece of soul will be the last that anybody wishing to kill Voldemort must attack--the piece that lives inside his body." This is straight from the book, that's why I say that Harry would have to kill himself before Voldemort could die.
read my post.
Originally posted by APIECEOFME
There were 6 horcruxes out in the world. But the seventh is in Voldemort's body. In the chapter "Horcruxes", DD says "The seventh piece of soul will be the last that anybody wishing to kill Voldemort must attack--the piece that lives inside his body." This is straight from the book, that's why I say that Harry would have to kill himself before Voldemort could die.
"Anybody wishing to kill Voldemort must attack" meaning that if you destroy all Horcruxes Voldemort would then die if you killed his body. But you kill his body first, his soul/essence still lives correct? Now you destroy the 1 Horcrux left (Harry) therefore no more soul, no more essence, no more Voldemort.
From your posts I assume you think that if Harry kills Voldemort before he destroys all Horcruxes, then destroys the last Horcrux, Voldemort would still live? See my view is if Voldemort has one Horcrux left when his body gets killed, he'll live like he did during the 13 years he had no body. Destroy that last Horcrux, then Voldemort would just get erased from existence.
Originally posted by APIECEOFME
Where in the book does it say it would be "easier"? I just quoted the book where he says different
Remeber when the killing curse rebounded, and hit Voldemort. It killed him, but he was able to comeback because he has a Horcrux. Do you see how long it took for him to come back. Now say Harry kills Voldemort, but his spirit is still around, look ing for a Horcrux so he can 'come back'. If Harry killed himself immediatley after he killed Voldemort, tell me how Voldemort could come back.
"No it could go like this, Harry destroys all of the Horcrux, except himself. Then he takes on Voldemort, kills Voldermorts body, then kills himself. Therefore taking out Voldermort because there are no more Horcruxes, therefore no more soul". - Darth macabre
this is the best theory on here about harry being a horcrux I LOVE IT and i totally agree
What I'm trying to tell you is the piece of soul inside Voldemorts body is NOT a horcrux. It is what is left of his soul after he made the horcruxes. The quote I posted tells me that Harry must destroy all the horcruxes before he can kill Voldemort (that is, the piece of soul inside him). So if Harry is a horcrux he would have to destroy himself BEFORE he destroyed Voldemort. It says that in the book. If you can find a part of the book that says otherwise, I would like to hear it, but I'm going by what the book says.