The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

Originally posted by Mist
I was thinking this also...something to do with Harry....who better to make a Horcrux into than the one who is supposedly destined to destroy you?

It'd tie together the parts with Harry sharing visions with not only Voldemort, but also Nagini (if Nagini turns out to be a Horcrux too).

I havent read that book for ages, did they ever explain why Harry had a connection with the snake?

But anyways, theres enough to put together for a valid argument having Harry as a Horcrux.

(Could the first post be edited a bit so the page isnt so wide?)

Perfect. And, if you didn't take notice, if the Horcrux really is in Harry of perhaps Harry's scar, and the last word in the book is SCAR... 😉 See where I'm going with this?

I seriously bet that the scar is a horcrux

This is stupid. It can't happen, otherwise Voldemort would be invincible, the boy who is the only one who can destroy him... Has to destroy himself before destroying Voldemort?

I gotta reread the book...

Originally posted by 2Tidus!
This is stupid. It can't happen, otherwise Voldemort would be invincible, the boy who is the only one who can destroy him... Has to destroy himself before destroying Voldemort?

I gotta reread the book...

No it could go like this, Harry destroys all of the Horcrux, except himself. Then he takes on Voldemort, kills Voldermorts body, then kills himself. Therefore taking out Voldermort because there are no more Horcruxes, therefore no more soul.

We both know that Voldemort always puts his Horcrux in a possesion he is proud off, the diary which shows everybody he is the heir of Salazar Slitherin and etc...

And I don't think that the scar is a possesion to be proud off. It shows how Voldemort got ****ed up by a one year old 😛.

And I also don't think that somebody could accidently make a Horcrux, it's dark magic and hard to perform a horcrux, even harder when you make a seventh piece.

well then maybe your stupid hero won't win in the end!

It can't be Harry guys... I believe DD said it belongs to Ravenclaw or Gryffindor.... hasn't anyone thought of that? I think the sorting hat is a good idea, but to which did it belong to again?

The sorting hat belonged to Godric Gryffindor.

Well there we go, it belonged to Gryffindor. Voldemort could have done it while in Dumbledore's office when he came back. Maybe it is easier than thought to do it, or he has mastered it enough to do it in a nonverbal spell.

This is true...the sorting hat is a very good possibility.

Then, also, he will have to go back to Hogwarts, evade teachers and all, and try and destroy the hat... or maybe destroy the hat during the ceremony! Oh, interesting idea... *picturing it now....... gets ready for fanfic.*

No, the hat can't be a Horcrux. Voldemort always makes his most prized possestions Horcruxes. And the hat would be too oblivious to everybody, it would be easy to destroy it if somebody found out...

But who would think of it?

I think someone should've sensed it... But they didn't.
I think DD would've known if it's a Horcrux...

He doesn't know what the last one is, so he might not've known. But I know for sure it isn't Harry... thats just plan stupid. Everyone would think of it and try and kill Harry.... *gets pitchfork out.* HES MINE! 😛

Well first of all, the Sorting Hat is for all of the founding houses. They put the brains in the hat, not just Godric, and the Hat doesn't even belong to the Dark Lord. DD says his most prized possessions, meaning they belong to him. And I'm sure, DD has a way of checking if something was a horcrux or not.

Well Harry doens't belong to him either.

i dont think harry is a horcux or at least his scar isnt. he only got the scar cause of the prophecy when it said voldomort would mark him as his equal, and marking him would be the scar. besides voldomort has been trying to kill harry all along that would be pretty stupid to put ur soul into somthin ur trying to kill.

Seriously people...don't you think that it is reaching a little to say that Harry is a horcrux? I don't even understand how this debate is still going on. It makes no sense. I've said it before, Harry would have to kill himself before Voldemort was able to be killed.

Also, I think Voldy got his 7 before Harry was born.