What if just the scar is the horcrux. . . I mean there is a possibility that him being close to a piece of Voldy is what gave him some of his powers, like his connection to Voldy, the snake and the Parceltongue. . .
But if he was accidently made into one could it be possible to have blended away from Harry? Since he can't see through the snakes eyes either? But retained the parceltongue because he could do that for years and that just became part of his own powers?
Might the final Horcrux be in the Room of Requirement? I'd read that bit again but my sister has the copy of the book at the moment and I haven't found the time to pry it from her grasp yet.
Didn't Harry embellish the top of the head of an aged bust with a wig and a tiara? Maybe it was Ravenclaw's tiara...
Originally posted by kobra_fang
Might the final Horcrux be in the Room of Requirement? I'd read that bit again but my sister has the copy of the book at the moment and I haven't found the time to pry it from her grasp yet.Didn't Harry embellish the top of the head of an aged bust with a wig and a tiara? Maybe it was Ravenclaw's tiara...
that's a cool thought about ravenclaw's tiara! hhmmmmm... never thought of that! must reread... 📖
The missing Horcrux might be at the ministry of MAgic, hidden there by Malfoy Luciuse, it also might might be at Godrc Hall, but so far we know very little about the place.
Neither Harry, nor his scar can be a horcrux, because Voldermort created the horcruxes long before Harry was born, and because every time that Harry met Voldermort he tried to kill him. Now, would he be killing his horcrux? of course not, give Voldermort some credits ppl, he neither Grabb nor Gayle.
Originally posted by Sir Mist
I was thinking this also...something to do with Harry....who better to make a Horcrux into than the one who is supposedly destined to destroy you?It'd tie together the parts with Harry sharing visions with not only Voldemort, but also Nagini (if Nagini turns out to be a Horcrux too).
I havent read that book for ages, did they ever explain why Harry had a connection with the snake?
But anyways, theres enough to put together for a valid argument having Harry as a Horcrux.
(Could the first post be edited a bit so the page isnt so wide?)
well i was thinking that Harry himself was the Horocrux?
i mean maybe his body was meant to be the last and final horocrux. but Voldemort did not kill him.... becuase Harrys death was to be the last death for the final horocrux... and what if Voldemort got destroyed or what ever by him killing Harry and then putting is soul into him..
Originally posted by Sir Mist
Yeah...we've said that many times...but people here dont listen...theyll shoot your theories down so fast you wont know what happened..So Im not even gonna bother arguing, Ill just slap things in here like that poll from mugglenet.....shows we're not the only ones who think this way...
i knew many people thought he was a Horcrux.. that poll wasnt surprising to me at all
Sir Mist-i dont really think people here are terrible, they've just got strong opinions, thats all. I personally agree with you and tonks. There's a "part" and "similiarities" between Voldemort and Harry that are linked by his scar. maybe its not necessarily him, but the piece of flesh that is his scar is a horcrux. voldemort already has a part of himself it seems, instilled in harry i.e. when harry looked at dumbledore he was upset, the snake incident because of the brain link, etc. that link makes it seem ineviatable that harry or a part of him is a horcrux. plus the fact that some form of powers were transferred from voldemort to harry. if voldemort has 1/7 of his own soul...and he did this BEFORE attacking harry when he was a baby, could it be possible since he was "reduced no nothing close to a human" that some of his soul...maybe 1/2 of that 1/7 of voldemorts soul could be transferred to harry? so in fact there'd by 8 horcruxes and not 7?
jsut theorizing. and as head of my house guys, please dont disrespect other people's thoughts. discreet disagreement is fine, but no member bashing or Phoenix is going to have to close the thread. and all of you have awsome theories, but if someone goes bonkers thats it for the rest of us. so please! politness!
Originally posted by LadySlytherin
jsut theorizing. and as head of my house guys, please dont disrespect other people's thoughts. discreet disagreement is fine, but no member bashing or Phoenix is going to have to close the thread. and all of you have awsome theories, but if someone goes bonkers thats it for the rest of us. so please! politness!
Head of your house?
What does that have to do with anything? 😑
and i've said it before but i guess i'll have to say it again, part of voldie's soul couldn't possibly survive in harry wether it's his scar or him. just a reminder... remember in ootp in the ministry wen voldie tried to possess him and he couldn't cuz harry's full of luv!?! how could some of him soul survive in a body full of love wen he couldn't!?!?!
i've been kinda rude in this thread and i'm sorry but i'm very opinionated but i would like someone who believes harry's a horcrux to answer this cuz i haven't had an answer about that and it makes me really discredit all u guys say...
o and as for nagini it is explained that the reason harry was the snake in his dream was cuz voldie was possessing the snake at that time and since harry was in his mind he was also in the snake.
Originally posted by polowahine4
and i've said it before but i guess i'll have to say it again, part of voldie's soul couldn't possibly survive in harry wether it's his scar or him. just a reminder... remember in ootp in the ministry wen voldie tried to possess him and he couldn't cuz harry's full of luv!?! how could some of him soul survive in a body full of love wen he couldn't!?!?!
i've been kinda rude in this thread and i'm sorry but i'm very opinionated but i would like someone who believes harry's a horcrux to answer this cuz i haven't had an answer about that and it makes me really discredit all u guys say...o and as for nagini it is explained that the reason harry was the snake in his dream was cuz voldie was possessing the snake at that time and since harry was in his mind he was also in the snake.
Exactly.
Originally posted by DarkC
And Dumbledore quite plainly said that Voldemort meant to make Harry his final Horcrux, but the curse backfired on him instead. And Voldemort screws up too in the aftermath of the Tournament and the Department of Mysteries.