The Missing Horcrux (spoiler alert)

his scar is still part of him. it's his skin. remember wen voldie couldn't touch him cuz of his mom's sacrafice? and the protection was all over him and everything? well the same goes for the luv that's in harry! it's even in his skin just like his mom's luv was! so the scar can't be it cuz it's in his skin wich is full of luv wich voldie can't stand! sry not trying to be rude or anything but if u payed any attention at all and if u used ur brain at all u would know that it is impossible that harry is the horcrux, accidentally or otherwise!

Originally posted by air
yes but remember exactly that a horcrux is a part of Voldemorts SOUL....when we actually witnessed Voldemort sharing his soul it stuck out the back of there head..and a part of your soul is a part of you...so Harry would be part Voldemort...having his thoughts etc. Im sorry i REALLY doubt like am 99.9999999% sure harry is NOT a horcrux...i dont see it as being feasible....and i think thats a little far fetched even for JK.

Umm, no.
Does Voldemort have a locket sticking out of his head? Does he have a ring sticking out of his head? The Horcrux is where you store your soul, its not the actual soul itself.

Originally posted by polowahine4
his scar is still part of him. it's his skin. remember wen voldie couldn't touch him cuz of his mom's sacrafice? and the protection was all over him and everything? well the same goes for the luv that's in harry! it's even in his skin just like his mom's luv was! so the scar can't be it cuz it's in his skin wich is full of luv wich voldie can't stand! sry not trying to be rude or anything but if u payed any attention at all and if u used ur brain at all u would know that it is impossible that harry is the horcrux, accidentally or otherwise!

Voldemort had to wait until GoF when he became whole again using Harry's blood...so maybe by doing so he 'blended' back with a bit of his soul that was inside Harry? He can touch Harry now, the love factor is irrelevant right now.

Originally posted by polowahine4
and if u used ur brain at all u would know that it is impossible that harry is the horcrux, accidentally or otherwise!

Impossible? How exactly is it impossible? See? All you fans dont actually backup your claims, you just post 'its impossible' 'Harry is NOT a Horcrux' and then go and repeat parts of the book and say thats your proof.
This thread is speculation. You think of an idea and try to back it up. And so far, theres enough backup to support the claim that Harry is a Horcrux. The seventh book hasnt been written yet, and until JKR actually says herself 'Harry is not a Horcrux' then we can end it.

Well, I agree in saying Harry is not a horcrux. I'd just like to ask the people who believes he is one question, "Why would Voldemort put a part of his soul in some one he knows he'll have to kill?"

Originally posted by polowahine4
he can't be a horcux cuz part of his soul couldn't survive in harry. remember in ootp in the ministry of magic voldie tries to posses harry so that dumbledore would kill harry in hopes of killin him? well later dd said that voldie couldn't stand being in harry cuz he's so full of luv. so wat makes u think that his soul can stand it if he can't?

that is the evidence i showed to prove myself "sir mist" so next time u wanna say something make sure u know all of wat i've said!
blowup

Originally posted by Sir Mist

Impossible? How exactly is it impossible? See? All you fans dont actually backup your claims, you just post 'its impossible' 'Harry is NOT a Horcrux' and then go and repeat parts of the book and say thats your proof.
This thread is speculation. You think of an idea and try to back it up. And so far, theres enough backup to support the claim that Harry is a Horcrux. The seventh book hasnt been written yet, and until JKR actually says herself 'Harry is not a Horcrux' then we can end it.

Im not saying its impossible, but it is highly unlikeley. I mean like 99.9% unlikely. You say the we havnt suppotred why he cant be a Horcrux. Well i have, incase you missed it. But you have no good evidence as to why Harry is a Horcrux. All you have is.. "It would be a good plan for Voldemort." Tell me, how exactly can he be a Horcrux?

Here is why i think Harry can't be a Horcrux.

The night Voldemort went to kill Harry, he used the Avada Kedavra curse and it rebounded and hit Voldemort. Since then he was unable to do magic for years, let alone a complicated spell like this. And he couldnt have made Harry a Horcrux before, because why would you make some one a Horcrux, and them try to kill him minuted later? And Voldemort has not done any wierd spells on Harry since he came back. So Harry can't be a Horcrux.

excactly!!!!! thank u danzeke!!!!!

And!

vvv

Originally posted by Director_Joe
Why would Voldemort put a part of his soul in some one he knows he'll have to kill?

Originally posted by DanZeke25

Here is why i think Harry can't be a Horcrux.

The night Voldemort went to kill Harry, he used the Avada Kedavra curse and it rebounded and hit Voldemort. Since then he was unable to do magic for years, let alone a complicated spell like this. And he couldnt have made Harry a Horcrux before, because why would you make some one a Horcrux, and them try to kill him minuted later? And Voldemort has not done any wierd spells on Harry since he came back. So Harry can't be a Horcrux.

Do we know how to make a horrux? No
could it be possible that LV had prepared everything, said all the "horcrux spells" and then everything went wrong, Yes.
It's a pitty that you can't come up with a better argument. Unfortunately, I ust realised myself a reason why Harry most likely is not a horcrux.....
DD said LV would make a horcrux that night, with harry's death, so he wouldn't made a horcrux when killing Lilly and james. when he then came to harry, I'm afraid Harry never died....(ooops)

Originally posted by Director_Joe
Well, I agree in saying Harry is not a horcrux. I'd just like to ask the people who believes he is one question, "Why would Voldemort put a part of his soul in some one he knows he'll have to kill?"

How many times must we go through this?
He could think 'Ok, rather than try and kill the prophesised chosen one whos gonna kill me, why not make him a part of me, so that even if he does kill me, I can come back using him. Hey, what a way to f*ck up the prophecy😱'

😐

Originally posted by polowahine4
that is the evidence i showed to prove myself "sir mist" so next time u wanna say something make sure u know all of wat i've said!
blowup

Again, I say, a Horcrux is where you store your soul. And again, youve just said stuff from the book.😐

Originally posted by DanZeke25
Here is why i think Harry can't be a Horcrux.

The night Voldemort went to kill Harry, he used the Avada Kedavra curse and it rebounded and hit Voldemort. Since then he was unable to do magic for years, let alone a complicated spell like this. And he couldnt have made Harry a Horcrux before, because why would you make some one a Horcrux, and them try to kill him minuted later? And Voldemort has not done any wierd spells on Harry since he came back. So Harry can't be a Horcrux.

Yeah, thats your good counter point. I havent actually mentioned how it is possible, because I havent thought every possible detail out yet, also noone knows what spells he used and what happened that night.

"because why would you make some one a Horcrux, and them try to kill him minuted later? " I think Ive already mentioned it could have happened by accident ie he doesnt know he has made Harry into a Horcrux. Or his plan just f*cked up.

And of course I have no good evidence, its called speculation until the facts roll out.

I give up trying to argue with 14yr old fangirls and people who cant think 2 feet ahead of themselves.

I find it hard to believe that Voldemort 'accidentally' split his soul... Could you imagine? "Yeah, me and a couple of buddy's kinda got drunk last night... I think I might have.... 'accidentally' ....put a seventh of my soul in Harry Potter... C'mon, it happens to the best of us."

Originally posted by Sir Mist
Again, I say, a Horcrux is where you store your soul. And again, youve just said stuff from the book.😐

I give up trying to argue with 14yr old fangirls and people who cant think 2 feet ahead of themselves.

of course we're sayin stuff from the book! where else would u get ur evidence? up ur butt? cuz that's wat it seems like ur doing! and for ur info i'm not a "14yr old fangirl" and i think i'm right in saying that i can think considerably farther ahead of me than u can!glare

Originally posted by Sir Mist
How many times must we go through this?
He could think 'Ok, rather than try and kill the prophesised chosen one whos gonna kill me, why not make him a part of me, so that even if he does kill me, I can come back using him. Hey, what a way to f*ck up the prophecy😱'

😐

Voldemort didn't know about the prophecy the night he tried to kill Harry as a baby, did he? 😕 {genuine query}

he only knew half of it.

Ok, thanks 👆

So, if he didn't know that one must die at the hands of the other, why would he try to kill Harry after making him a Horcrux? It doesn't make sense.

cuz he knew that harry was the only person who could kill him and that niether could live while the other survived but he didn't know that "he would have powers the dark lord knows not"

Oooh... thanks again 😄 I should know all this 🥷

the books have a clasic hero and villian feel to them, if horecrux Harry dies so that Voldi could die to i mean that is self sacrefice and "no greater love" kind of thing. Very Christ-like

Christ-like? 😑

Found on Wikipedia -

Rowling's main strengths as a writer include her ability to drive elaborate and largely seemless plots over a very wide canvas, the convincing internal logic of her fantasy world, and the acuteness of her characterisation. The three adolescents at the centre of the book are perceptively presented, the main adult characters have substance, and the minor characters are vivid and memorable. The Harry Potter books also contain much humour. On the other hand Rowling's prose style is not a major strength. Also, while there is much moral subtletly in many scenes in the books, the central clash between good and evil is drawn in largely black and white terms, and this disappoints some readers.

Rowling lets the ideas of racism, genocide, and other prejudices find their way in; these are the trademark of Voldemort and his Death Eaters, but also occasionally shown in the relationship between wizards and the non-magical (muggle) populace.

Those in italics are in reference to what you just said, I think you may have a point. Rowling writes a story with depth, yet bases the experiences of her characters on very simple principles. It's clever, IMO 😄

If harry is a horcrux harry is gonna have to kill himself to make voldie mortal........then who kills voldemort....because of the prophecy?

Harry is not a horcrux. Harry is a tempermental overly hormonal teenage boy who deserves to be killed 😄

Innkeeper, that was rather unnecessary 🙄