Originally posted by Janus Marius
[b]DS:Perhaps you're missing something. If Exar Kun easily shrugs off a powerful and difficult sever Force ability from the guy who excelled at them and in turn kills that Jedi Master without doing much more than raising his hand, what is Anakin or Yoda going to do to him while avoiding those casual amulet blasts?
Oh, God, the 'amulet blasts' argument.
It's not like Sith artifacts can be disabled via the Force, or Exar having to divide attention, or Yoda knowing things like Morichro, Malacia, and given he had the Tedryn Holocron, Force sever. Or just leap up and throw up a force shield and then launch a force wave when Exar is too busy focusing on blasting everything like a deranged lunatic to bother with defense.
Seriously, consider that. When you come up with a decent answer for that other than "OMFG Odan-urr sux" I might take you seriously.[Quote]
He has thrown around Jedi like ragdolls quite easily,
Unless they are remotely comparable to yoda and anakin in power and ability, irrelevant.
and he's dominated top tier Jedi masters with casual ease.
And as the Jedi in question here are more powerful and skilled than those Jedi, irrelevant. Yoda has dominated a Dark Lord of the Sith with relative ease, who was also a top tier Jedi master before growing even stronger
I know you're going to blow up and go "omfg but they weren't leik teh PT guyz!" because that's how you've always acted, but the point being Exar Kun dominated Force users in his area and once he became a Sith was undefeated. Even as a shade, he dominated Kyp and choked half of Luke's academy after being mad and isolated for thousands of years.
You neglect to mention here that what he did with Kyp was play off his fears. There was no force domination there, there was seducing him to the Dark Side.
You also neglect to mention that Streen was able to stop that choking.
There's no instance of Exar Kun being defeated using the Force and every example of him being unequalled during his timeframe.
This has bearing on a more powerful era, how? Darth Bane was also undefeated and unequalled during his timeframe. Same might go for Revan.
My point here is a simple: What bearing does this have on anything?
Even if you want to sit there and tell me the TotJ era jedi masters who were centuries old were completely worthless and only held in high esteem for their useless and non-applied Force knowledge, I'll just ignore you. There's nothing to indicate that the Jedi were weaker simply because they don't have as many showings as Yoda or as much grandiose narration surrounding them as Yoda or Mace. Clearly, they've only been depicted in one form of limited media, not several movies, games, books, comics, etc. Limited exposure is going to make them seem less impressive because they haven't been fighting much of a war during the timeframe in which Exar Kun takes power. Odan-Urr was stalked and killed in his own study without any time to prepare, for example.
Oh, so the 'they just haven't been in enough' argument? No, that doesn't fly. Odan appeared in three six issue miniseries, that's more than enough time to show something. Kun was in two and was practically the star villain of two novels, with a ton of writing in third party material.
I'm afraid the 'grandiose narration' is still part of the continuity and just because the PT have had more time to show off doesn't mean they're less powerful. If we have to decide between the guys with more backing or the guys with less, where we do we go logically, now?
I'm not sure how excessive knowledge of the Force and being renowned in arts that specifically were used in fighting the Sith somehow equate to Odan-Urr being some sort of worthless sage.
That 'excessive' knowledge line applies to Yoda. Oh, and is there any evidence of Odan fighting Sith now? As I pointed out, he did nothing during the Kirrek battle. The only Dark Lords left had either fled or died after Naga's purge and escape, leaving practically undefended Sith worlds to be genocided.
Odan headed to Ossus after the war. There is no evidence he ever left it since and devoted himself to learning and knowledge.
Yoda himself did not fight Sith until the very end of his life and spent most of his years in contemplation, teaching, and intensive study much like Odan-Urr.
as Yoda happily points out to Whie Malreaux, Yoda's fought and killed more than Whie can imagine. Yoda's early years are shrouded in mystery, but he did a lot of traveling, learning and there was quite a few battling with dark siders along the way. It's implied that he might well have battled some Sith along the way and unlike Odan, when the chips were down in a fight, Yoda proved himself.
He was also physically small and weak, and yet it was his understanding of the Force which allowed him to overcome his enemies, not his overwhelming level of power alone.
And? When Yoda opened himself to the Force, he was a nearly unstoppable fighter and has demonstrated incredible levels of speed and strength
Faunus:
I'm not sure where you're drawing this from. Yoda is considered exceptional among the PT Jedi era for his understanding and command of the Force, but a good deal of that comes from his wisdom and practice. Odan-Urr was not some pencil pusher who sat at a desk all day and acquired worthless second-hand knowledge. He notes he was busy cleaning up after the war with Sadow and learned his Force Sever ability combating them.
and this is contradicted by other sources. He says he became 'adept' with it during the war. And? Odan's contribution to the war was standing around on Kirrek letting people depending on him be torn to bits. Teta and the Republic proceeded to burn the Sith planets to ash afterwards.
Yoda lived an active life. He kept himself sharp and studied hard in the Force and kept his combat skills up to date.
The very fact that he pretty much made up the ability while fighting the Sith is incredible.
Yeah, except there's no evidence he 'made up' the ability and I question his definition of Sith Lord, knowing the Sith Lords were fled or dead by the time Odan would have entered combat.
If he can use sever force on a Sith Acolyte? Good for him.
Yoda doesn't display this level of Force manipulation, even if he should conceivably have knowledge of it.
Yoda does not simply try to sever the Force from Sidious, or from Dooku or a host of other Dark Siders he could have done it on.
Unlike that mongrel idiot Odan, Yoda might actually put some stock in how severing people from the force is a horrible thing not to be done lightly. Not only that, notice how Vodo and Nomi don't use it on Ulic permanently? Or join together for an attack on Exar with it?
By that same standard, when would Yoda have found need or necessity to do so? He needed to kill Palpatine, his equal or near-equal in the Force who would conceivably be able to resist it. And he's there to KILL Palpatine. he wants to save Dooku, not destroy him.The only other times I recall Yoda facing Dark Siders are the Bpfasshi group who he kills and Ventress who he handily defeats without even igniting his saber.
Also, if Force Sever is in such wide appeal during the TOTJ era, why did nobody do it during the third great Schism? Might've helped save an entire star system before the Dark Jedi destroyed it. The idea of Odan just going "Lol Sever Force" at every opportunity is kind of undercut given that the one single time he faced an opponent of great power, his attempt failed and he was instantly killed.
Just because Yoda has literally dozens of depictions showing him doing all manners of Force feats does not necessarily make him vastly superior to Odan-Urr.
Ridiculous assertion. There is no evidence Odan is more powerful and far more evidence on Yoda's side. Plus, Yoda's power in regards to other Jedi is directly stated in certain places.
Even if he does have more Force potential (Which is a debatable point when you consider you can't measure Odan-Urr's potential at all), this isn't a blank check for him to piss all over Exar Kun. Kun himself was clearly leagues above any of the Jedi Masters in the TotJ era.
So what? Unless this has bearing on Yoda, it is irrelevant. Compare and contrast Yoda's abilities to Kun's alones and see who comes out on top. Kun can beat Yoda's inferiors. This isn't a strong case for him at all.
So to bring this loop back to a close, Kun >>>>> Odan-Urr. Since Odan-Urr is one of the best TotJ era Jedi along with Vodo, this means Kun is clearly a Force beast at this point, as if his showings weren't enough. The idea that Yoda >>>> all other Jedi masters by virtue of his heavier exposure is flawed. [/B]
Yeah, we know Kun is something, but guess what? So is Yoda. Yoda's own feats are enough to place him up alongside the best and that includes Exar. His own demonstrated feats are enough to make a case for him on his own against Kun and it's a good case.
That Yoda>>>>the other Jedi based on available evidence and demonstrated ability plus heavy textual backing on Yoda's behalf? Not so flawed