Star Trek versus Star Wars: The Debate is Opened

Started by Rogue Jedi17 pages

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
None. Actually, The Executor alone would destroy many, many Enterprise's before it went down. I've seen the numbers, and Star Wars ships do a lot more damage.
not to mention all the tie fighters buzzing around.

does ST have any small one man fighters like tie's or x wings?

Originally posted by doan_m
Wrong. SW sheer speeds when it comes to FTL allows them to cross half the galaxy in hours(this is considered the norm for FTL speeds) while ST warp speeds crawl significantly slower. To illustrate this, it took the Star Trek Voyager 7 years to crawl from one part of a quadrant of a galaxy to another, with the assisted boost from stolen alien artifacts and godlike beings.
And, yes people feel free to brand me a nerd, because that is what I accept I am and have no problem with it. Go on, I know you want to..
I already stated it in another post that I was mistaken, why don't you read my post first 😉

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
not to mention all the tie fighters buzzing around.

does ST have any small one man fighters like tie's or x wings?

Plenty.

Originally posted by Dreamt
Plenty.
as i said, not familiar with them. how do they compare to Xwings and Ties? do they have shields? hyperspace capability?

Not well. Star Wars tech flat out decimates Star Trek tech. Star Wars blasters, for example, are more powerful. Go to the Stardestroyer.net site for reference.

OK, in the SW universe, they have clone troopers. what is the equivalant of clone troopers in the ST universe? How well would 100 of the elite ST troopers fare against 100 elite Clone troopers?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, in the SW universe, they have clone troopers. what is the equivalant of clone troopers in the ST universe? How well would 100 of the elite ST troopers fare against 100 elite Clone troopers?
ST (Federation) really doesn’t have clones but they have genetically modified humans such as Khan, and they also can create holographic people with mobile imagers.

Originally posted by Da Pittman
ST (Federation) really doesn’t have clones but they have genetically modified humans such as Khan, and they also can create holographic people with mobile imagers.
and how would a group of these warriors fare against a group of clone troopers? both groups are elite, mind you.

Originally posted by Da Pittman
ST (Federation) really doesn’t have clones but they have genetically modified humans such as Khan, and they also can create holographic people with mobile imagers.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
OK, in the SW universe, they have clone troopers. what is the equivalant of clone troopers in the ST universe? How well would 100 of the elite ST troopers fare against 100 elite Clone troopers?

LOL! Oh hell no...there is a "clone" type that is much more badass than any clone trooper out there. They are called the Jem'Hadar. The Jem'Hadar are very much like the idea of clones from Star Wars.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Jem'Hadar

There are also the Vorta.

AND HOW WELL WOULD THEY DO AGAINST A GROUP OF ELITE CLONE TROOPERS.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
AND HOW WELL WOULD THEY DO AGAINST A GROUP OF ELITE CLONE TROOPERS.

Well, if the bad "assery" were carried over from the ST universe to the Star Wars universe, then the crappiest, fully grown Jem'Hadar should be better than even an elite clone trooper. They are supposed to be warlike, like Klingons accept more bad ass with better technology that comes "on-board" each clone.

There is also the changelings, which should be a formidable foe, even for a Jedi.

I think that if you eliminate the godlike characters from each of the worlds, the Jedi (Or Sith) would be more than enough for anything the Star Trek Universe could throw at it.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Well, if the bad "assery" were carried over from the ST universe to the Star Wars universe, then the crappiest, fully grown Jem'Hadar should be better than even an elite clone trooper. They are supposed to be warlike, like Klingons accept more bad ass with better technology that comes "on-board" each clone.

There is also the changelings, which should be a formidable foe, even for a Jedi.

I think that if you eliminate the godlike characters from each of the worlds, the Jedi (Or Sith) would be more than enough for anything the Star Trek Universe could throw at it.

another question. Avchase is under way, Han Solo is running from the enterprise, and he of course is in the Falcon. You know how he is always escaping, no matter if it is a group of ties, a star destroyer, or 4 or 5 star destroyers?

what kind of odds is he facing trying to escape the enterprise with Kirk at the helm?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
another question. Avchase is under way, Han Solo is running from the enterprise, and he of course is in the Falcon. You know how he is always escaping, no matter if it is a group of ties, a star destroyer, or 4 or 5 star destroyers?

what kind of odds is he facing trying to escape the enterprise with Kirk at the helm?

Kirk? Pretty damn good odds because Kirk was an airhead.

Picard or Janeway? He would have a hard time with his brig cell fo sho.

Han Solo is notorious for always beating the odds.

Originally posted by dadudemon
LOL! Oh hell no...there is a "clone" type that is much more badass than any clone trooper out there. They are called the Jem'Hadar. The Jem'Hadar are very much like the idea of clones from Star Wars.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Jem'Hadar

There are also the Vorta.

I was thinking about bringing them up but that is why I only put in the Federation. I wonder how the SW would deal with the phase technology?

how successful would Boba Fett be as a bounty hunter in the ST universe?

Han Solo would easily escape, considering the fact that Star Destroyers are faster and have much more and much bigger guns then the Enterprise.

http://stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/FiveMinutes.html

agreed.

See edit for details.

so the enterprise wouldnt have a chance against a star destroyer?