Star Trek versus Star Wars: The Debate is Opened

Started by Shin_Blax17 pages

The weaker ones do anywayermm. The ones whose farts can blow up stars on the other hand..

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
The weaker ones do anywayermm. The ones whose farts can blow up stars on the other hand..

OMGZ!!!!! WHO CAN DO THAT!!!!!!!!! I MUST GNOE!!! TELL ME OF THE MIGHTY STAR DESTROYING FARTING JEDI AND SITH!!!!

PUUUUHHHHWEEEEEEEEEEEEZ!!!11!111!!1!!111!!

If I can find the scans from Dark Empire I'll sow them to you.

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
If I can find the scans from Dark Empire I'll sow them to you.

Oh my gosh...you're serious. How come I have never heard of this until now? 😮

Huh, dunno. But yeah the Expanded Universe Jedi from the books and comics are ridiculously powerful.

Some huge advantages that Trek has over SW is sheer speed, nothing in SW even comes close. Borg can also time travel, most of my knowledge of SW comes from the movies but with the nano things that powers the force I don’t see why the Borg nanos wouldn’t assimilate them as well or even one Jedi that gets assimilated into the hive and they would all have his knowledge of the force as well.

you cannot compare the two universes, you just cant.

SW is in another galaxy, a long time ago. ST is mased on this galaxy, present day, right?

If by nano you mean mitochlorians then yeah. However, the chances of even a single Jedi getting assimilated are slim. As I mentioned earlier, people like Sideous can literally rip holes in space-time with his attacks, and teleport anything from anywhere in the Galaxy. Also the Star Wars ships. Star Trek ships. It took the Enterprise several years to fly from one part to another quadrant of the Galaxy, while Star Wars ships can fly across the galaxy in hours.

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
If by nano you mean mitochlorians then yeah. However, the chances of even a single Jedi getting assimilated are slim. As I mentioned earlier, people like Sideous can literally rip holes in space-time with his attacks, and teleport anything from anywhere in the Galaxy. Also the Star Wars ships. Star Trek ships. It took the Enterprise several years to fly from one part to another quadrant of the Galaxy, while Star Wars ships can fly across the galaxy in hours.
Originally posted by Shin_Blax
If by nano you mean mitochlorians then yeah. However, the chances of even a single Jedi getting assimilated are slim. As I mentioned earlier, people like Sideous can literally rip holes in space-time with his attacks, and teleport anything from anywhere in the Galaxy. Also the Star Wars ships. Star Trek ships. It took the Enterprise several years to fly from one part to another quadrant of the Galaxy, while Star Wars ships can fly across the galaxy in hours.

Well in that case,

Slip stream velocity and sub space conduits. point nulled...end of story.

And no, it would be very easy to kill a Jedi. I am pretty damn sure that Data could move as fast as an average Jedi AND he is definitely stronger than any star wars character except maybe Markos Ragnos. Not to mention trying to block a wide beam phaser blast.

Why do you put me into these positions? I don't want to defend Star Trek, I want to defend Star Wars because I like it more.

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
If by nano you mean mitochlorians then yeah. However, the chances of even a single Jedi getting assimilated are slim. As I mentioned earlier, people like Sideous can literally rip holes in space-time with his attacks, and teleport anything from anywhere in the Galaxy. Also the Star Wars ships. Star Trek ships. It took the Enterprise several years to fly from one part to another quadrant of the Galaxy, while Star Wars ships can fly across the galaxy in hours.
While Jedi are tuff I will give you that but to say that just one Jedi can’t be caught I seriously doubt that. As for SW I have never heard of them flying even close to that speed, I just remember Han saying .5 past light speed but I did a search and from what I have found it seems that you are correct.

It is possible, but even if they have the mitochlorians that won't mean anything. They'd have to be trained, it'd take years.

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
It is possible, but even if they have the mitochlorians that won't mean anything. They'd have to be trained, it'd take years.
They would instantly have all of the knowledge of the Jedi that they assimilated as well as all other knowledge of tactics and locations or other forces that the Jedi knows.

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
It is possible, but even if they have the mitochlorians that won't mean anything. They'd have to be trained, it'd take years.

Not if you were secies 116. I am sure that they coud learn and master all of the force's secrets in a few days. Or how about an Organian? (That's cheating, right there😄.)

Originally posted by Da Pittman
They would instantly have all of the knowledge of the Jedi that they assimilated as well as all other knowledge of tactics and locations or other forces that the Jedi knows.

Right they would instantly know of the ones they assimilated but people react and feel the force in different ways. You can't take one or two and use them as a model.

Originally posted by Da Pittman
[B]Some huge advantages that Trek has over SW is sheer speed, nothing in SW even comes close.

Wrong. SW sheer speeds when it comes to FTL allows them to cross half the galaxy in hours(this is considered the norm for FTL speeds) while ST warp speeds crawl significantly slower. To illustrate this, it took the Star Trek Voyager 7 years to crawl from one part of a quadrant of a galaxy to another, with the assisted boost from stolen alien artifacts and godlike beings.
And, yes people feel free to brand me a nerd, because that is what I accept I am and have no problem with it. Go on, I know you want to..

I already mentioned everything you just said, last page 😐

Originally posted by Shin_Blax
Also the Star Wars ships > Star Trek ships. It took the Enterprise several years to fly from one part to another quadrant of the Galaxy, while Star Wars ships can fly across the galaxy in hours.

well, from what I see, and mind you I am not a huge ST fan, what kind of a chance would the enterprise stand against a fleet of star destroyers?

None. Actually, The Executor alone would destroy many, many Enterprise's before it went down. I've seen the numbers, and Star Wars ships do a lot more damage.