Originally posted by King Kandy
Meanwhile, his supposed superior Harribel got solod by Toshiro, someone definitively below Ichigo judging from Soul Society Arc, and the #1 loses to Shikai.
Not really- think about how Hitsugaya's normal freeze attack badly wounded Luppi, but his ultimate attack, which he was hesitant to use even in shikai mode, failed to visibly harm her when used in bankai mode, merely trapped her for awhile and she showed no signs of injury upon being freed. I also think Hitsugaya's more powerful than he seemed early on, he just has a habit of being caught off-guard due to inexperience. Since Harribel was playing softball to let moisture build up, that played into his hands pretty well, but ultimately it was Aizen, not Toshiro, who killed her.
I do agree that #1 losing to shikai was bad, but he did cream two vizard captains first, so I think it's supposed to be a sign of 'the old guard are just that badass'.