Let me see.
First room:
Yoda has the advantage here because his is small, a powerful force user and has his "claws" which should make some climbing actions easier. Since in my oppinion this room would rely on an combination of force use and physical condition, I rate it like this:
1. Yoda (huge time advantage here)
2. Exar Kun
3. Revan
4. Mace
5. Obi-Wan
Second room:
I think the people who know Sith lightning will simply toast anything in the water withit before starting with swimming. But I don't think that they will be able to catch Yoda here. So it remains:
1. Yoda (close)
2. Exar Kun (close)
3. Revan (huge advantage on Obi and Mace)
4. Mace
5. Obi-Wan
Third room:
Since this relies on duelling skills Obi-Wan will have the most problems here. Yoda would simply jump in and cut the warriors down, Exar and Revan might need a little more time and Mace again more time while Obi-Wan would maybe have quite some problems here. Again:
1. Yoda
2. Exar Kun
3. Revan
4. Mace
5. Obi-Wan
Fourth room:
A test of intelligence. Revan and Yoda will do that stuff quite quick, since they both knew quite much so will Mace who is said to know much about the history of the order (this would include some Sith history as well). Kun, after all, is a Sith and Obi-Wan will have the most problems here I guess. So after this room:
1. Yoda
2. Revan
3. Exar Kun
4. Mace
5. Obi-Wan
Last room:
Yoda would simply avoid the Rancor, Revan will distract it, Kun can freeze it and Obi-Wan and Mace would have equal problems to get past it but since Mace is still in front of Obi-Wan my final suggestion is:
1. Yoda
2. Revan
3. Exar Kun
4. Mace
5. Obi-Wan (out)
Sorgo, the time limit was overdue at the time and I had two to three additional "against" Dooku votes at the last second. Since I felt there wasn't a strong enough case for Dooku to survive a raging civil war at the ripe age of eighty and as Illustrious says, we must try to go with what we have as opposed to what we can only speculate at. Anyone can "survive" a firefight or a battle, either through sheer luck or determination or both... But in the situation I had called to mind, Dooku doesn't have clearly as easy a time as Obi-Wan Kenobi. And in any case, he would be horribly hampered in round two, so assuming I did let him live until this point, he would probably drop off right away anyways.
This thread isn't to appease a fanbase; it's to encourage something different at this stale old subforum, and we're moving on. Tonight at about 7 or 8 PM eastern I'll initiate round three, but don't sweat it- I'll probably make more threads like this.
Nai: I think you're overestimating Yoda a lot, especially in the fights and in the tunnel particularly. Remember Yoda is about a third smaller than anyone else, and has small limbs... He has to swim three times as fast to keep pace with longer, taller players like Kun, Mace, and Revan. Essentially the advantage he has in the first trial is pretty well damaged by his trek in that tunnel. But all the same, it's about the same result. Edit: Correction. Yoda will have an easier time keeping his head above water, since the size is more accomodating, so it may not be as bad as the others. But certainly no walk in the park.
Illustrious: Thanks for keeping tally. I don't have the mind about me with work and all.
Hmm well lets see...
First room, Well Yoda obviously.
Exar Kun and Revan will follow closely, with a slight lead for Revan
Then Mace or Obi Wan, I don't really know but i'm going with Mace.
So that would be
Yoda
Revan
Exar
Mace
Obi
Second room
Exar Kun and Revan will shoot the creatures down before jumping into the water. I don't know who's a better swimmer but Kun is more powerful with the force IMO so he would probably win this.
Yoda would come in after that, because of well I don't know, I just imagine that he's pretty fast.
Obi Wan would be after that and Mace Windu would be last, at least I think so. This is based on nothing really.
So that means
Exar Kun
Revan
Yoda
Obi Wan
Mace
The fight.
Revan will win this I think because he will move fast and hard, Exar Kun will also take them quite fast but I think just a little slower then Revan. Both can overpower them with the force in a second probably, but I rate Revan higher as a duelist so he wins.
Now Yoda is very good but he takes to much time to strike somebody down. I think he would take longer then those two, leaving Mace as fourth and Obi Wan as last. Obi Wan will take far longer then the others here if he even makes it that is. But if he does its going to take him a shit load of time.
Then you have walking around a beast.
Revan, Obi Wan and Yoda will do this the fastest. I'm guessing Yoda first, Revan second, Obi third, then Mace and then Exar. I don't know why but I just don't see Exar as somebody that sneaks around.
Meaning
Yoda
Revan
Obi Wan
Mace
Exar Kun.
Not sure I follow that last lineup. I mean, of all the players, Obi-Wan's fighting style takes the longest to kill, with Yoda somewhere between slow and hella fast depending on the opponent. The time Obi-Wan would need for an opening against two average Sith duellists (And note that these are shades of long dead sith retainers... they are probably pretty good) would be considerable next to everyone else. And I think you are underrating Exar Kun by a great deal.
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Nai: I think you're overestimating Yoda a lot, especially in the fights and in the tunnel particularly. Remember Yoda is about a third smaller than anyone else, and has small limbs... He has to swim three times as fast to keep pace with longer, taller players like Kun, Mace, and Revan. Essentially the advantage he has in the first trial is pretty well damaged by his trek in that tunnel. But all the same, it's about the same result. Edit: Correction. Yoda will have an easier time keeping his head above water, since the size is more accomodating, so it may not be as bad as the others. But certainly no walk in the park.
I don't think I'm overestimating Yoda. The room as I imagine it would contain a lot of jumps, climbing action and stuff like that. When we judge Yoda by his movement ability in fights (which I did) he might get through that room much faster than the others. Then in the tunnel he has:
a) an advantage because he might be able to keep his head over the water and breathe easily
b) he has the greatest manouverability with his small lightsaber to defend against the creatures in the water (compared to Obi-Wan and Mace)
c) He might just use the force to pull something off (boost the water out of the tunnel, move faster or stuff like that).
Actually that doesn't matter because he will have a great advantage compared to the others in the last room while I don't think that Revan (who is the only one that might go through room number four faster than Yoda) has a great advantage in the duel and he will lose a lot of time facing the Rancor (since Yoda can pretty much run through the room).
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
I swear, Nai and Illustrious and Rayvann, you all pull sigs out of your ass. I must be the only one who makes one every time I want to change, huh?
No...I had nothing to do today so I decided to make a new sig. Took me quite some time to find the pics and put them into it.
And while you have written this I just switched the color of the text. 😉
Originally posted by Nai Fohl
No...I had nothing to do today so I decided to make a new sig. Took me quite some time to find the pics and put them into it.And while you have written this I just switched the color of the text. 😉
I see that. Barely, but I see that. I like it better this way, although the outlines are harder to see since they clash with the background color.