Emma Frost vs. Sue Richards (mental assault).

Started by Tha C-Master10 pages

ad sales argument, yadda yadda yadda.

It depends on who, if its a guy like batman or spiderman, I'd be more inclined to agree, but EMMA , she's a *****.

But I go by arguments, and look at the polls( depending on who, to see if the results correlate), why would people vote for emma out of popularity, its like namor..

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
ad sales argument, yadda yadda yadda.

It depends on who, if its a guy like batman or spiderman, I'd be more inclined to agree, but EMMA , she's a *****.

But I go by arguments, and look at the polls( depending on who, to see if the results correlate), why would people vote for emma out of popularity, its like namor..

And this doesn't change the fact that it is an appel to the populace. You can't use polls simply when the polls suit you to the answer you like, as you can't discard them when they aren't in your favor.

I discard polls always as they are simple public opinion. which we've seen doesn't translate into truth.

Sonic for example does not have a chance against Flash, yet he has a 50% chance against him in the gaming section?

If Emma is less popular than Sue and still manages to win in the polls - then shouldn't the polls, if anything, be understating her advantage. Ergo doesn't that make the outcome of the poll at least somewhat more relevant than anything with Wolverine, Batman, Superman etc. in it.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
If Emma is less popular than Sue and still manages to win in the polls - then shouldn't the polls, if anything, be understating her advantage. Ergo doesn't that make the outcome of the poll at least somewhat more relevant than anything with Wolverine, Batman, Superman etc. in it.
Can't pick and choose I'm affraid.

I'm on Emma's side, but you still can't use a poll as objective evidence other than what the majority of people think.

But what the majority of people think does not make something truth.

Even if the Majority are right in any given instance. They'd be right because they know the truth, rather than their opinion MAKES it the truth.

Originally posted by Creshosk

Even if the Majority are right in any given instance. They'd be right because they know the truth, rather than their opinion MAKES it the truth.

Depends who you're asking then. Some polls will be more valuable than others.

Originally posted by Victor Von Doom
Depends who you're asking then. Some polls will be more valuable than others.
Why are some polls more important? Who chooses which ones are important and which ones aren't?

And are some people's opinions more important than others? Who decides whose opinion is more valuable?

Originally posted by Creshosk
Why are some polls more important? Who chooses which ones are important and which ones aren't?

And are some people's opinions more important than others? Who decides whose opinion is more valuable?

Poll of the public on the MMR vaccination.

Poll of doctors on the MMR vaccination.

eurgh Emma is a major bi.tch..I feel tht sue has the stamina to take her on quiet easy and win..

Originally posted by Victor Von Doom
Poll of the public on the MMR vaccination.

Poll of doctors on the MMR vaccination.

I mean within comicdom. 🙄

And hey doctors have been wrong in the past before? Leeches? Balancing humours? Bad smells causing disease?

Originally posted by Creshosk
I mean within comicdom. 🙄

And hey doctors have been wrong in the past before? Leeches? Balancing humours? Bad smells causing disease?

They have, but the point is about esoteric knowledge.

As regards comics- fair point. Was just speaking in general.

Originally posted by Victor Von Doom
They have, but the point is about esoteric knowledge.

As regards comics- fair point. Was just speaking in general.

Even now a days I went through an army of doctors, diagnosed with everything under the sun until one doctor figured out I had temporal lobe epilepsy.

Yeah, does happen.

Everybody happy now?

Good!

Next thread!

Probably mistaken in optimism, that sentiment.

Worth a try.

Originally posted by Creshosk
And this doesn't change the fact that it is an appel to the populace. You can't use polls simply when the polls suit you to the answer you like, as you can't discard them when they aren't in your favor.

I discard polls always as they are simple public opinion. which we've seen doesn't translate into truth.

Sonic for example does not have a chance against Flash, yet he has a 50% chance against him in the gaming section?

Arguments come first, and like I said, I would sympathize if it were a character like wolverine, but it isn't.

It wasn't my argument anyway, the polls just happen to correlate.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
the polls just happen to correlate.
That's my point. 😉

Your point is to corrleate the polls with the arguments and views put on the thread, as was mine, particularly here...

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Your point is to corrleate the polls with the arguments and views put on the thread, as was mine, particularly here...
No I mean the polls just happen to correlate this time. I still don't see them as being valid evidence though.

k...