Darth Vader versus Darth Tyranus

Originally posted by kamikz

Talking about Anakin right?
Well I don't think he would have been able to perform the move he did on Obi-Wan without getting him in a vulnerable position first, he had to break away his defences with a saber so he could catch him offguard. I don't really see him doing that to Anakin, as Anakin is imo, a far better duelist than Obi-Wan, and his style isn't passive like Obi-Wan's so he wouldn't really give Dooku the time to pull something like that off.
Anakin's defence against the force is better than Obi-Wan's anyway, isn't it?

Well Ox, that was ROTJ Vader, we're talking about ESB Vader. 😉

And yea i would put anakin above ob1 in force defenses.

19 more posts to go till 1000, ever saw count dookus 13 ur old pics? i saw it on wookie or wiki

Originally posted by Kas'Im
Anakin's defence against the force is better than Obi-Wan's anyway, isn't it?

I'd assume so (but all I have is an assumption), given that Anakin's raw command of the Force is quite a bit above anybody in the movies.

i'd say they were about equal because in rots they did that thing like they are trying to force push each other and it becomes a test of "force strength"

Noone wins and they both recoil back quite violently! But obviously Anakins superior overall

Originally posted by Ogami Itto
i'd say they were about equal because in rots they did that thing like they are trying to force push each other and it becomes a test of "force strength"

Noone wins and they both recoil back quite violently! But obviously Anakins superior overall

Well one instance shouldn't be used alone to determine such a thing. The EU actually shows Obi-Wan being in many vulnerable positions with the force, such as Assaj holding him still in the air with the force, whereas Anakin never seemed to be as bad.

How many posts do we need now? 14 or so??

that part in the movie was more to show that they knew each others moves, rather than their equality in the force. Anakin was above everyone.

Originally posted by Kas'Im
Well one instance shouldn't be used alone to determine such a thing. The EU actually shows Obi-Wan being in many vulnerable positions with the force, such as Assaj holding him still in the air with the force, whereas Anakin never seemed to be as bad.

Movie Pwns EU 😄

What more evidence do you want??? ROTS shows them both trying to use the force on each other and the result is a draw

Well Obi-Wan was never spectacular with the Force.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
that part in the movie was more to show that they knew each others moves, rather than their equality in the force. Anakin was above everyone.

If Anakin was more powerful in that respect he would have pushed Obi wan back without himself recoiling several feet

Anakin is more physical than "I am going to use the Force on you, Beware"

EDIT

Originally posted by Ogami Itto
Movie Pwns EU 😄

No contradiction though.

What more evidence do you want??? ROTS shows them both trying to use the force on each other and the result is a draw

Perhaps one was exerting himself more than the other, perhaps one was mroe tired than the other - there are many reasons to suggest that either one wouldn't produce the exact same power in a different situation.

And is there really any proof that's saying that the result of each attack was exactly the same, did you consider how much each weighed for instance, did you calculate the exact distance each fell back?

There's really no proof from that one instance that they were = in the force.

Anakin is more poweful and Obi seemed more tired. Anakin should have destroyed Obi with that push.

Movie Pwns EU

Not exactly. But I'm too lazy to prove it.

Gosh, people, post!!!

Originally posted by Kas'Im
No contradiction though.

Perhaps one was exerting himself more than the other, perhaps one was mroe tired than the other - there are many reasons to suggest that either one wouldn't produce the [b]exact same power in a different situation. [/B]

You were using EU in attempt to back up your aguement! The Movie shows them to be about equal in force defence thus overriding any EU examples that say otherwise

I mean come on, you seen it with your own eyes 😆

LOL

998

All right I'll finish this..................................