Darth Vader versus Darth Tyranus

Started by Quinlan_Vos64 pages

...Finally, we have reached 1000 posts ! A milestone here at the SW Versus Forum!!! Therefore, good job to everyone! WE HAVE REACHED THE BIG 1000

Originally posted by Ogami Itto
You were using EU in attempt to back up your aguement! The Movie shows them to be about equal in force defence thus overriding any EU examples that say otherwise

I mean come on, you seen it with your own eyes 😆

Refer to my second point.

Why did you disturb the 1000 post count!!!???

Yea, ok. Well Lucas said, "At the time of ROTS, Anakin is THE MOST POWERFUL JEDI, Ob1 just has the experience."

So Anakin is above OB1. It should be common sense that they showed both of them doing it at the same to show how familiar they were with each other. And you dont know which one was pushing harder, or if thats even a possibility. If a push is just a push, then it wouldnt matter who was stronger.

Exactly. Also Ogami, please note that there is more to defending against the force than just defending TK. For example defending against TK is vastly different to defending against lightning for instance.

In fact there is more to defending against TK than just defending a force push, what is required to defend against a force push is most likely pretty different from what is required to defend against a force crush or something.

😂 😂 Okay the movie is wrong

Did the movie say that it was show they were equal? Not at all.

😂 😂 Okay Lucas is wrong.

you were talking about "force defence"i.e. the ability to defend yourself from force attacks!!read my earlier posts I stated Anakin is more powerful than Obi Wan 😂 😂 😂

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
Did the movie say that it was show they were equal? Not at all.
😆

I wasnt talking about forec defense at all. You said they were equal and i said they weren't. You said the movie was wrong, I said that Lucas is wrong.

That's it. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
Well Ox, that was ROTJ Vader, we're talking about ESB Vader. 😉

And yea i would put anakin above ob1 in force defenses.

I was talking about forec defenses! hysterical

well that was before, lol...now im just referring to force power.

Anakin is above Obi-Wan in the lightsaber for sure. However, while Anakin is PROBABLY better than Kenobi in the Force, the movie shows that they're are equal. Now the movie isn't 100% correct, as the EU plays a major role in Star Wars. In addition, the ROTS novelization says Anakin is the best. However, this is a slight exaggeration as Yoda and Mace are better.

However, in the movie, they should have shown Anaking throwing Obi away to show he's stronger, otherwise people think they're equal in the Force.

Originally posted by Quinlan_Vos
Anakin is above Obi-Wan in the lightsaber for sure. However, while Anakin is PROBABLY better than Kenobi in the Force, the movie shows that they're are equal. Now the movie isn't 100% correct, as the EU plays a major role in Star Wars. In addition, the ROTS novelization says Anakin is the best. However, this is a slight exaggeration as Yoda and Mace are better.

However, in the movie, they should have shown Anaking throwing Obi away to show he's stronger, otherwise people think they're equal in the Force.

Actually, EU means nothing if its at all different than the movies. Anakin is indeed the most powerful, the only thing is Yoda, Mace, and OB1 have more experience. Thats it. The movies are 100% correct UNLESS Lucas himself says something different. Movies are above EU, hands down. Yoda and Mace are better, but not more powerful, as stated by the novel AND Lucas. And the movies don't show they're equal, it shows they know each others moves.

ok we hit the 1013 mark, congragulations on the 1000 posts! now this is the biggest thread

I believe that's been mentioned before but it doesn't matter. Good job to you ESB for all the Vader arguments you gave against Rampant Ox and his cronies lol.

what and i did NOTHING? 😠 😖hifty:

That comment was meant personally toward ESB. Of course you put up a spectacle against who was it (Nikkolas??) and against Rampant Ox. Believe me, there was several people involved in the struggle. You and ESB were the two primary ones and there was also some really good side lengthy arguments for Vader by others that added to the Vader team's power.

i was kidding anyways...all good.

tyvm for the comment vos, not to forget you were part of the team too so personaly id give you all the credits, you and subject 🙂

and for the dooku team, id give it to rampant ox for his confidence in dooku and his amazing support for the count lol, honest and to all those in the dooku team,

😮 Thankyou.

But a special round of applause for everyone who participated. We have reached a landmark 1000 posts in a SW vs thread.

clapclapclapclap