My theory is: Dumbledore is dead, because he trusted snape. But the fact still remains that Snape was a death eater. Mr Malfoy was imprisoned because he tried to kill Harry. Draco, who was Mr. Malfoy's son, followed in his father's footsteps, I mean look at what happened to Katie Bell in HBP in Silver And Opals. That necklace was deadly, it could have killed her. So I think that Snape really is working for Voldemort
Re: Dumbledore Discussion (Spoiler Info)
Originally posted by Lord DarqueLand
I'm not sure Dumbledore is really dead. I mean i know his picture is now on the wall and the funeral but he could be like Gandalf from LOTR. I have 2 theories right now1. Dumbledore told Snape to kill him and anger Harry enough to become a better wizard cause i quote from Snape Chapter 28 "Blocked again and again and again until you learn to keep your mouth shut and your mind closed Potter!" Now that Harry is angry enough at Snape, he knows the only way he can beat Snape is to 1, close his mind and 2 practice occulemency.
2.I quote Dumbledore Chapter "As far as i know -- as far, I am sure, as Voldemort knew -- no wizard had ever done more than tear his soul in two." I know people might think im insane but Dumbledore must've killed someone in his life like a Death Eater or something. I'm thinking that Dumbledore has a horcrux.
Give me your ideas! 😛
Maybe Fawkes is his horcrux.
Omg thats almost what i thought!
but my theory is:
that snape is actually good and is still working for dumbledore even though hes dead
and dumbledore knew he had to die
and he had previously talked to snape about how he had to kill him
because snape is still on the good side
but he had to proove extreeme loyalty to voldemort to spy on the bad side
i know its complicated, but i hope u get what i'm tryna say