Silver Surfer vs. Superman vs. Thor in PURE PHYSICAL BRAWL

Started by Starscream M7 pages

Originally posted by carver9
If that rock that hulk chunked at the mountain destroyed it, it had to be at least twice the size of that pyramid unless you think a pyramid can destroy a mountain.
in comics, anything is possible

Originally posted by Starscream M
in comics, anything is possible

So spiderman can hold a planet together like hulk did.

Originally posted by carver9
If that rock that hulk chunked at the mountain destroyed it, it had to be at least twice the size of that pyramid unless you think a pyramid can destroy a mountain.

I agree, the ship wasnt half the size of the pyramid but it had to weigh thousands of tons and hulk one handed it. But the mods told me to stay off this subject and I actually got a warning so PLEASE dont respond back to my post.

🤨

we just didnt want the thread to turn into a supes v hulk thread, thats all...

Originally posted by carver9
So spiderman can hold a planet together like hulk did.
stop being ridiculous...

my point was that things in comics don't necessarily comport to realworld science...aka a pyramid might smash a mountain in comics

I didn't mean to imply that there was no logic at all in comics...aka spiderman doing hulk level feats

Originally posted by Raoul
🤨

we just didnt want the thread to turn into a supes v hulk thread, thats all...

I understand that and I agree with it, thats why I told him not to respond. 🙂

Originally posted by Starscream M
stop being ridiculous...

my point was that things in comics don't necessarily comport to realworld science...aka a pyramid might smash a mountain in comics

I didn't mean to imply that there was no logic at all in comics...aka spiderman doing hulk level feats

I understand that but I dont think that the writers would be fool enough to have a pyramid destroying a mountain, that would just be plain ridiculous. I have never seen something like that happen in comics.

Originally posted by carver9
I understand that but I dont think that the writers would be fool enough to have a pyramid destroying a mountain, that would just be plain ridiculous. I have never seen something like that happen in comics.

actually, there was the time when- oh...

Originally posted by Raoul
actually, there was the time when- oh...

😆

Ok, you got me.

...unless you think a pyramid can destroy a mountain.
Perhaps, if you throw it fast enough (F=ma), especially since (IIRC) a mass moving at 86% cee has the kinetic force equal to all that mass being converted entirely into energy.

EDIT: just did some quick Googling and math. Basically, figure a 5-million-ton pyramid converted entirely into energy would cause an explosive force of about 100 million gigatons. Contrast that with the estimated 200 million megaton impact of Shoemaker-Levy.

Fun With Numbers.

😮‍💨

Supes wins !!!

Originally posted by Mindship
Perhaps, if you throw it fast enough (F=ma), especially since (IIRC) a mass moving at 86% cee has the kinetic force equal to all that mass being converted entirely into energy.

EDIT: just did some quick Googling and math. Basically, figure a 5-million-ton pyramid converted entirely into energy would cause an explosive force of about 100 million gigatons. Contrast that with the estimated 200 million megaton impact of Shoemaker-Levy.

Fun With Numbers.

😮‍💨

I understand that and agree but if it was thrown at the speed hulk threw it, it wouldnt destroy a mountain. If anything it would crumble once hitting the mountain. Good mathmatic skills though.

Originally posted by carver9
...but if it was thrown at the speed hulk threw it, it wouldnt destroy a mountain. If anything it would crumble once hitting the mountain.
Probably. Not everyone can do that Precrisis stuff. 😖hifty:

Originally posted by Mindship
Probably. Not everyone can do that Precrisis stuff. 😖hifty:

😆

This is spite. Superman wins all day.

And Superman murders Thor even if Thor has Mjlonir.
How's then apples?

Originally posted by h1a8
This is spite. Superman wins all day.

And Superman murders Thor even if Thor has Mjlonir.
How's then apples?

Now this is hilarious. h1a8, its pointless to argue with you, especially against superman because you mind is always made up, theres no changing it.

I will end my sentence with this though, Thor>superman.

Originally posted by h1a8
This is spite. Superman wins all day.

And Superman murders Thor even if Thor has Mjlonir.
How's then apples?

THor looses in a physical brawl but if he has his hammer its easiliy even. Give thor his belt and supes dies a horrible death.

Thor is physically stronger then superman with his belt.

But this is a pure physical brawl. supes should beat thor probobly everytime.

Superman for the win here imo.

Superman, unless of course Thor and Surfer work as a team.
Then Thor and Surfer would duke it out.

with no magic I give it supes

Just Muscle - Supes wins