ROTJ Luke Skywalker vs. TPM Obi-Wan Kenobi

These vs threads are fun...

anyways, both are in their twenties, both were knighted after their respective movies, and both tapped into the darkside during their lightsaber duels. So who wins?

My vote goes for Obi-Wan, gotta go with the guy with more experience and training here.

Oh yeah, and I used the search button, and nothing came up, so don't trample over me if this has been done before.

Obi-Wan easily takes this. By ROTJ, Luke's movements were still clumsy and unproffesional, and before you attack me with all this "But the choreographies sucked blah blah blah..." think of it this way. Luke by ROTJ has had a week of training and only like what two years of experience? So it would be quite normal if someone like him would swing his lightsaber the way he did. I really don't think the choreographies have anything to do with it. Obi-Wan showed some awesome saber skills against Maul, who was a much better swordsman that Vader, and as you have mentioned, he was more experienced and recieved much more training. Luke's all about raw power (which is useless if you can't even control it properly), that's pretty much it.

I voted Luke! Muhahahaha!! I will always chose the OT over the PT!
Cuz you know choreagraphy sucked and Luke is uber talented, haha!

lol, ass...

im gonna have to give it to obi won this time. He has more training and experience and is definetly more skilled.

Originally posted by Vaapad_Master
lol, ass...

surprise WHAT!!! Thou art reported to my mom now! Muhahaha!!!

dude, chill, I was only joking 😄 you're cool 😉

mmh.. okay then.

Originally posted by Vaapad_Master
dude, chill, I was only joking 😄 you're cool 😉

I disagree. JK.

Obi-wan would take Luke probably. I'd give Luke a fair chance though.

Of course Luke has a chance, but I give Obi-Wan the definite edge, for the reasons I have mentioned above.

But which people will argue against, citing eighties' choreography and everything else in the world just to get around admitting that Luke is inferior.

DABBLEJUH TIIIIHH EFFF ?!

Luke would kill Obi-1 really Im not joking. Luke only s33ms to be weak bcuz of 80s choreography and he had lung cancer in ROTJ. So he wasnt swinging his blade he was only coughing !!!1111oneoneeleven

Serious:
Obi-Wan would pretty much school Luke. He has 2 decades more experience handling a lightsaber. He has more fighting experience (I guess) at least he had much more practice with a lightsaber and - I guess - many hours of lightsaber-vs-lightsaber training against other Jedi. So he has the edge on Luke when it comes to fighting experience and handling a lightsaber.

And Luke was swinging his lightsaber deadly enough to kill "normal" people but he overwhelmed Vader with sheer power (powered by the dark side) and he only managed that because Vader couldn't do the movements Obi-Wan could use in the same situation.

So Obi wins that fight...

dude luke can can win because he will whine so much that Obi will kill himself after 20 hours of it

Originally posted by Darth Avis
dude luke can can win because he will whine so much that Obi will kill himself after 20 hours of it

hours ? Seconds !

Yoda: "A lot of your fathers whine in you, I sense !"

lol yea Luke wins thats the thread

lmao, yeah, that's one way luke can win the fight.

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
DABBLEJUH TIIIIHH EFFF ?!

Luke would kill Obi-1 really Im not joking. Luke only s33ms to be weak bcuz of 80s choreography and he had lung cancer in ROTJ. So he wasnt swinging his blade he was only coughing !!!1111oneoneeleven

Damn.. I hate it when people get funnier than me.. wallbash

Luke wins by default because Obi-Wan would piss his pants laughing to his death while watching Luke swing his lightsaber like a blindfolded kid with a baseball bat.

But seriously, Obi-Wan would totally kick Luke's ass.

LOl yeah, like in ROTJ when he was showing poor display on how to use a lightsaber. The only thing that impressed me was when he broke the saber lock with vader in like 4 seconds.