616 wolverine vs ultimate captain america

Started by wolvertooth16 pages

thats the point, he was just hiting namor underwated, but grimm thinks he shouldnt do it because namor is too fast but when the thing hits namor underwater and almost beat him thats just fine

Logan also was even more powered up thanks to Tony Stark suit, that Logan was using. Even an atleantean with a sword could not cut that armor.

daredevil the problem with people here is just that wolverine kicked there favorite character ass so they are mad

yes grimm22 and darkcrawler your characters got owned by wolverine on panel 🙂

I still think this fight would be close, but im going to give cap the majority 7/10

That underwater showing wasn't really any ownage, but just one hit at that. Heck on land Namor KO'ed Logan with one shot.

Of course it was a sneak attack though.

ye but on the land wolverine owned namor

namor ko logan from behind with a cheap shot, wolverine stabed him and could kill him but he threw namor down like trash and took out his guard

Also anyone remember the time U.Cap defeated Logan with a gun. Or in the rematch were he against defeats ultim Logan with a gernade.

USAgent who is stronger then U.Cap tries the same strategy on 616-Logan. Lets see how it goes shall we. Exept not in different fights but in the same one and a big explosion at that.

Now of course this just proves Logan is much better then his ultimate version.

But this just shows Logan can take punishment and keep on coming. Whats the point you ask since U.Cap can also takes explosions and keep coming?

Thats the point U.Cap will only be doing that to Logan....punches....kicks.......shield-strikes....which are effective of course, won't bring Logan down thanks to his skeleton and healing factor.

On the other hand will Logans kicks and punches bring U.Cap down, nope same for him. But U.Cap's mistakes in the fight will cost him much....Much more considering this isn't what Logan will do. He's not going to slug it out with him, but use his long claws and lop arms off and head and other gruesome things. Where his claws can easily go through.

Things that Logan can instanly heal from are going to handicapp or cripple U.Cap badly.

Don't get me wrong U.Cap gives a good fight but Logan for majority.

Originally posted by Grimm22
ULTIMATE MARVEL my friend 😐

Ultimate Marvel, not 616

My mistake, bro.

Just for the hell of it here is Ult. Cap taking Ultimate Wolverine out with a grenade, they dont really pertain to this debate, but (I really like these pannels) 😉


http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=untitledscanned144rh.jpg

http://img309.imageshack.us/my.php?image=untitledscanned154pg.jpg

Here is 616-Logan having the upperhand on 616-Captain America. They don't pertain to this debate, but I like the scans as well. 😉

Cap getting saved by the X-men when he fights Logan.

Again Cyclops saving Cap from Wolverine.

Capt it Up - You were ranting about how strong Rachel's telekinesis is.. Well, it's not really that strong.. Betsy has stronger telekinesis.

Originally posted by Jyppe
Capt it Up - You were ranting about how strong Rachel's telekinesis is.. Well, it's not really that strong.. Betsy has stronger telekinesis.

even if that is true which i doubt. betsy is a first class telekinesses as well

Also anyone remember the time U.Cap defeated Logan with a gun. Or in the rematch were he against defeats ultim Logan with a gernade.

USAgent who is stronger then U.Cap tries the same strategy on 616-Logan. Lets see how it goes shall we. Exept not in different fights but in the same one and a big explosion at that.

http://img142.imageshack.us/my.php?image=newinvaders619if5.jpg

http://img182.imageshack.us/my.php?image=newinvaders620yv4.jpg

http://img182.imageshack.us/my.php?image=newinvaders621sc9.jpg

Now of course this just proves Logan is much better then his ultimate version.

But this just shows Logan can take punishment and keep on coming. Whats the point you ask since U.Cap can also takes explosions and keep coming?

Thats the point U.Cap will only be doing that to Logan....punches....kicks.......shield-strikes....which are effective of course, won't bring Logan down thanks to his skeleton and healing factor.

On the other hand will Logans kicks and punches bring U.Cap down, nope same for him. But U.Cap's mistakes in the fight will cost him much....Much more considering this isn't what Logan will do. He's not going to slug it out with him, but use his long claws and lop arms off and head and other gruesome things. Where his claws can easily go through to inflict much more massive damage then, simple strikes which Logan would heal from.

Things that Logan can instanly heal from are going to handicapp or cripple U.Cap badly.

Don't get me wrong U.Cap gives a good fight but Logan for majority 7/10.

well, since these are two different universes and adamantium, thus, is different in the Ult universe(not indestructible like someone said, just real durable) and Marvels is indestructible, that just gives it away right there that Wolvie wins. his "indestructible" adamantium claws would slash Caps "extremely durable" adamantium shield, then thats when Logan guts him..Wolvie ftw 7/10 sheesh. why do they have to make things so complicated 🙄 if his shield was just vibranium and completely indestructible like 616 cap, this would be a much better fight.

Originally posted by Daredevil1
Here is 616-Logan having the upperhand on 616-Captain America. They don't pertain to this debate, but I like the scans as well. 😉

Cap getting saved by the X-men when he fights Logan.

Again Cyclops saving Cap from Wolverine.

Argh that should not have happened! ranting

So in response to what Capt It Up said, he chose that Wolverine in Enemy Of The State was not in the worst shape of his life by the time Cap got to him and nailed him with a moneyshot. But he was clearly beaten at that point.

And I'm asking anybody to believe that this was Cap's victory. Not by any means. What I want you guys to admit, is that you don't have to destroy Wolverine completely to beat him. Wolvie fanboys keep touting his incineration by Nitro and other bouts of healing to show that he is pretty much unbeatable. But healable and unbeatable are two different things. You cannot equate the two.

Therefore, Ult. Cap does not need to inflict so much damage to Wolverine to literally destroy him. He just needs to inflict enough damage to set him up for the moneyshot. TK blast? Fiery plane crash? A little cold, a knock on the head with a piece of wood and one Cyke blast followed by a mighty shield strike? Sounds like Ult. Cap could set that up.

So, there are two points you could criticize my analysis. And those really are the only two points I've been using to support my conclusions. 1) Wolverine was beaten by the end of Enemy of the State. 2) Ult. Cap (the brilliant tactician that he is) could set up that kind of damage dealing on his own.

So argue that 1) that Wolverine was NOT beaten under any circumstances in Enemy of the State. OR 2) that Ult. Cap (brilliant tactician though he may be) cannot inflict that kind of damage.

EDIT: BTW, what's up with that 'Zap!' sound effect when Cap lays a hook on Logan? Oh... and for Cap to look down and complain about a nick during battle? Yeah... I agree it could happen, but give me a break. That was the one in a million times Cap would actually let his guard down during battle.

That was a sneak attack by Cap from Wolverine being hurt from other characters/events. Logan has taken beatdowns from stronger bricks then U.Cap and has kept coming.

Not relevant to a one on one battle with no sneak attacks or other characters.

Well, I think it is relevant. I'm not sure anybody has seen how a fighter could down Wolverine barring some kind of PIS. In a throw down, how do you beat Wolverine? Well, I think Millar showed that Wolverine, given enough damage can get smashed in the back of the head and be down for the count for a victory to be assessed.

Thereafter, can Ult. Cap come up with that kind of damage? Sure, I think so. Guy's probably got a machine gun in hand. H2H first, knock Wolvie down and open his guts up with his shield, load his carcass up with 2-3 full rounds. Maybe stuff his mouth with a few hand grenades, then say a badass quip and smash his head into the ground with his shield.

You guys don't think Ult. Cap could do that? I suppose, here, its up to Ult. Cap's speed, agility, strength, fighting ability and tactics that have to be put to the test. The test is, Can Ult. Cap inflict enough damage, fasty enough to set him up for a money shot so that Wolvie's healing factor becomes a non-issue?

I think he could. 9/10

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
But healable and unbeatable are two different things. You cannot equate the two.

Therefore, Ult. Cap does not need to inflict so much damage to Wolverine to literally destroy him. He just needs to inflict enough damage to set him up for the moneyshot. TK blast? Fiery plane crash? A little cold, a knock on the head with a piece of wood and one Cyke blast followed by a mighty shield strike? Sounds like Ult. Cap could set that up.


You do realize that this is a no prep match. For ultimate Capt to set up that kind of damage he would need prep time and out side help neither of which he has in this fight. Please tell me what capt has one him that can generate the damage that one of the fastest planes in the world going through the woods full speed and crashing. Or generate the power that the TK blast has to generate to knock wolverine through two door that a class 100 could not even dent. Also I want to see ult capt generate the kind of force scots optic blast at full power can generate. The fact is that Ult capt does not have any were near that fire power he simple has a machine gun and a grenade or two.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Ult. Cap (the brilliant tactician that he is) could set up that kind of damage dealing on his own.

First he has no prep. Second off he does not have that kind of to be able to do that kind of damage. Also 616 wolverine has as good tactics if not better then ultimate capt.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
So argue that 1) that Wolverine was NOT beaten under any circumstances in Enemy of the State. OR 2) that Ult. Cap (brilliant tactician though he may be) cannot inflict that kind of damage.

Ult capt can not inflict that kind of damage.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Well, I think it is relevant. I'm not sure anybody has seen how a fighter could down Wolverine barring some kind of PIS. In a throw down, how do you beat Wolverine? Well, I think Millar showed that Wolverine, given enough damage can get smashed in the back of the head and be down for the count for a victory to be assessed.

The fact is the damage logan received in that issue was beyond any thing ult. capt could throw at logan. Also did you read the tie ins? He was walking around with a sword through him in one and in the other an oil tanker blow up next too him and he was still standing while on fire. Not to mention did you read agent of shield when logan fought gorgon and took hits through the gut and heart and kept on fighting.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Thereafter, can Ult. Cap come up with that kind of damage? Sure, I think so.

How honestly how can ult capt do that with a machine gun He has no prep he has no weapon close to the power of the plane crash let a lone the TK.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Guy's probably got a machine gun in hand.

Which won’t help ult capt at all. Not only could logan simply dodge the bullets, but logan can also take the punishment with out flinching and will be quite fine as seen below.
http://img237.imageshack.us/my.php?image=5599de7baf8.jpg

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
H2H first, knock Wolvie down and open his guts up with his shield, load his carcass up with 2-3 full rounds. Maybe stuff his mouth with a few hand grenades, then say a badass quip and smash his head into the ground with his shield.

How is ultimate capt do this? Logan the superior fighter and nothing capt will do with his fist can really damage logan. Not to mention logan stabs ult capt it over. This scenario you have come up with is terrible and would never happen.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
You guys don't think Ult. Cap could do that?

Dam right I don’t

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I suppose, here, its up to Ult. Cap's speed, agility, strength, fighting ability and tactics that have to be put to the test.

To bad Longs superior in all those areas ecpt perhaps strength

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
The test is, Can Ult. Cap inflict enough damage, fasty enough to set him up for a money shot so that Wolvie's healing factor becomes a non-issue?

Not unless logan just sat there and let him lol

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I think he could. 9/10

That just ridiculous to think